Only Katy.

Edited August 15, 201410 yr by Retroman

Katy Perry.

ARTPOP proves Gaga is more try hard than edgy.

 

 

I voted for "Katy Perry". If everyone's albums had the eccentric-ness of some of Gaga's songs I'd be put off massively.

i prefer katy perry's music to lady gaga's music so i voted for katy perry

I think I would have struggled to choose more if it wasn't for Katy's latest era. I never took to 'Roar' and 'Unconditionally' just grates on me so much it's unreal. I haven't been mad keen on this ARTPOP era either, but at least I enjoyed 'Applause'.

 

In terms of other songs from previous eras, Katy's released some real solid gems, especially 'Teenage Dream', 'E.T.', 'Hot N' Cold', 'I Kissed A Girl' 'Firework' etc, and 'Paparazzi' is probably one of my favourite songs ever, but saying that, I don't listen to her past hits all that much.

 

I do like the dark depth in a lot of Gaga's songs and I often find Katy Perry's music a little too basic. I mean, 'Roar' sounds like it was written for five year olds IMO.

 

But I think I'm going to go for GAGA.

Edited November 17, 201311 yr by Parallel Reality

I wish people would learn to read.

I am definitely more of a Katy Perry. I love simple songs, with catchy beats/hooks ect. If it ain't broke, don't fix it! I find a lot of songs that try to be edgy and push boundaries are just shit.

I can't believe the amount of people who haven't understood what this topic is?! :lol:

easily a gaga. altho ironically katy perry's roar is one of my favourite songs of the year (yes i know what the topic is about) and when i DO like pure pop songs i go hard a la 'come & get it' (amazing!) so there's a definitely a katy streak in me.

I chose Katy. The more risky pop works when it works but it's far more hit and miss for me, whereas there's rarely a generic pop song I dislike.

GaGa has higher highs ("Bad Romance", "Telephone", "Paparazzi") and is a far better vocalist, but she is pretty inconsistent - I am liking the new single "Do What U Want" however. Perry is vocally very average and pretty inconsistent too. I don't love any of her songs, and I dislike a lot of them, "Roar" is pretty awful to my ears (one of the more overrated pop singles of the year) and "California Gurls" was so bad that I grew to hate her for a time in 2010 when she became inexplicably successful.

This isn't a "Katy Perry vs. Lady GaGa" outright "rivalry" topic. It's more based on you and your pop tastes.

 

GaGa has higher highs ("Bad Romance", "Telephone", "Paparazzi") and is a far better vocalist, but she is pretty inconsistent - I am liking the new single "Do What U Want" however. Perry is vocally very average and pretty inconsistent too. I don't love any of her songs, and I dislike a lot of them, "Roar" is pretty awful to my ears (one of the more overrated pop singles of the year) and "California Gurls" was so bad that I grew to hate her for a time in 2010 when she became inexplicably successful.

Oh doctor bitch :((((

I am 100% a GaGa. Ain't nobody got time for safe pop music.

I'd say Katy Perry as generally my favourite songs are simple ballads and catchy pop tunes.

Oh doctor bitch :((((

 

I've just never felt like a plastic bag drifting through the wind wanting to start again. :(

 

Those are my pop tastes. I'd much rather listen to The Fame Mons†er than anything Katy Perry has recorded.

I'm a Lily Allen, to be honest.

Gaga easily

 

Seen her 3 times, seeing her again at Jingle Bell Ball, camped outside venues for her, waited outside hotels to get close to her

 

No one compares to Gaga IMHO, music/personality/work ethic, the complete package

I wish people would learn to read.

 

 

I can't believe the amount of people who haven't understood what this topic is?! :lol:

 

Or maybe you just haven't understood the amount of people using the example of Katy/Gaga's music to explain their choices?

Or maybe you just haven't understood the amount of people using the example of Katy/Gaga's music to explain their choices?

Disliking what Lady Gaga is making does not mean you hate all "weird" music. You're reaching.

Or maybe you just haven't understood the amount of people using the example of Katy/Gaga's music to explain their choices?

 

For once i agree with you

 

I love Gaga's music but i buy into the whole package, the personality, the fact she speaks out about what she believes in, the fact she is a workaholic, her outfits, the music is a very nice side issue