May 9, 201411 yr Anyone but Louis would be great, he's had his time now. I just hope the Mel rumours are true.. surely its not long till they need to be revealed now?
May 10, 201411 yr Cheryl Cole is following Demi Lovato... Could she be joining the panel? Plus she said on her BGMT interview last year that she'd love to do the UK version if she was asked.
May 10, 201411 yr Just noticed the age being lowered to 14... Did they not do that before and the girl was kicked off the show for beating someone up?
May 10, 201411 yr I like Demi she has good chemistry with Simon and will probably get on well with Cheryl, would rather someone different though
May 10, 201411 yr Louis has confirmed he is returning :cheer: Why on earth are you cheering this? Really is so awful as a judge. Hasn't had an original thought since the 1st season.
May 10, 201411 yr Why on earth are you cheering this? Really is so awful as a judge. Hasn't had an original thought since the 1st season. Entertainment value. Yeah, as an actual judge, he's not brilliant. But he's the life and soul of the show IMO, great TV and it wouldn't be the same without him.
May 10, 201411 yr Really is so awful as a judge. Hasn't had an original thought since the 1st season. Couldn't agree more. Literally the worst judge that has appeared on any show like this. He just repeats generic sentences and is just the producer's puppet. The whole Carolynne v Rylan thing was a clear example of how he is not fit to judge, let alone judge the biggest talent show for 10 years.
May 10, 201411 yr The whole Carolynne v Rylan thing was a clear example of how he is not fit to judge Still haunts me to this day :drama: -x- Would love to see Demi complete the panel, I imagine she'd be great alongside Cheryl :wub:
May 11, 201411 yr But he's the life and soul of the show IMO, great TV and it wouldn't be the same without him. This actually reads like one of his comments :lol:. In fairness though, he may not have the best voice but he's got the likability factor and everywhere I go, girls ask about him, kids seem to love him. He reminds me of a young *random white man in his 80s* and I can definitely see him making the final.
May 11, 201411 yr This actually reads like one of his comments :lol:. In fairness though, he may not have the best voice but he's got the likability factor and everywhere I go, girls ask about him, kids seem to love him. He reminds me of a young *random white man in his 80s* and I can definitely see him making the final. :D! That pretty much is why I enjoy having him on the show though :kink:
May 16, 201411 yr I assume we should be finding out the final judge very soon? I'm thinking that Demi could definitely be a possibility for a few reasons. As well as what has been mentioned above... The initial reason she left X Factor USA was due to touring commitments (according to this) and her tour would have clashed with the US auditions as they start being filmed around now based on last year and Demi is still touring at the moment. However, her tour would be complete by the time the UK auditions begin filming as she only has a few shows left now (unless she announces some new shows). Also there seems to be a big promotional push for Demi in the UK with the release of 'Neon Lights' and being featured on the new single by The Vamps - could this be to coincide with a potential announcement about Demi joining the panel? Finally, Demi had already been rumoured as a potential UK judge back in March (according to this) so that shows that she isn't completely out of the picture. And I think Demi well-known enough now in the UK especially after 'Skyscraper' being used as the winner's single last year. It just seems quite a few things are falling into place for this to be a possibility :kink:
May 16, 201411 yr Louis, Simon and Cheryl on the same panel again! Wouldn't mind Demi as a judge tbh, I don't like her as a singer but she is a lot more relevant than Mel B and would attract younger viewers. Mel B would be brilliant too though
May 16, 201411 yr I don't even know the difference between Demi Lovato and Selena Gomez. Is the former the one who went to rehab?
May 16, 201411 yr I agree with Ryan that there are a few things pointing to Demi but I hope it's not her. She's a bit of a non-entity in the UK and not very interesting from what I've seen. She seems to have dined out on her victim status over the past few years and whenever I see her name mentioned anywhere, it seems to always be related to some sort of social commentary she's made against Twitter trolls/the industry rather than anything to do with her music. I get that she's got a fantastic voice but I've never thought her success has much substance. Also, the dynamics of a Simon, Cheryl, Demi, Louis panel would be a bit flat. They need a personality - Paloma would be ideal but she's unlikely to ever do it. Edited May 16, 201411 yr by Noahspike
Create an account or sign in to comment