Jump to content

Featured Replies

  • Replies 510
  • Views 22.8k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Best Music single, but still not exactly amazing for me (though I do like it).

 

Same opinion.

 

My Core3 remain. Papa Don't Preach, Express Yourself and Frozen (I think?)

If I had to pick my core top 5 (basically impossible).

 

1.Hung Up

2.Vogue

3.Like A Prayer

4.Hollywood

5.Frozen

I love Don't Tell Me, it's probably in my top 10 Madonna songs but I wouldn't like to even try and order it so maybe not!

this is my madge top 5

 

1 Frozen

2 True Blue

3 Crazy For You

4 Sorry

5 La Isla Bonita

Edited by jsilv

  • Author

You make me wanna hang my head down and cry

 

 

| 16 // Open Your Heart // True Blue // 8.10 (2: jakewild, 4: omie // 11: fgiboy, riser, 10: mr_aly, johnkm, luciano, randomfurlong, niallminogue, dandy, haus, mikemyers, joe.)

 

With that explosive "watch out!" to open the song, and glorious synthing drums, you know you're in for a delight. 'Open Your Heart' demands you do just that. Released as the fourth single from 'True Blue' and originally written for Cyndi Lauper, Madonna swept it up, changed it slightly and gave it her magical touch. A simple love song, but all the more special for this reason, it is undeniably care free and so warm and passionate. One of her most accessable and relatable songs ever, the song explores relationship innocence and naivety and is something we've all experienced whether it be the inability to open up to another, or the agonising pain of not having an open heart returned. Because of this, the song was a commercial success, reaching the top 10 around the world and securing a 5th US #1 as the world opened their hearts. The music video is another complex one, as Madonna plays an exotic dancer, watched on by glaring men and what must be a ~10(?) year old boy. The video demonstrates Madonna's prowess over her sexuality as opposed to subverting it like some might initially think, and it's a genius exploration of femininity and control. The song is an absolute delight and i can't even begin to fathom it receiving the (sparse) low scores that it did. Open your EARS, detractors.

 

An ALBUM next. Whatsitgonbe?

 

Seems like a correct placing to me, for impact purposes alone.
TUNE. I thought this would be closer to the top 10
  • Author

Turn to stone, lose my faith, and I'll be gone

 

 

| 05 // Music // 2000 // 8.03 (4: jakewild, 6: johnkm, joe. // 11: jay, 10: niallminogue, leww, cassandra, oliver, robswift, sweetcandy)

 

PQ5eTaz.jpg

 

Your 5th favourite Madonna album is her eighth studio one, and the first of the 21st century. Coming off the back of 'Ray Of Light', she had a lot to live up to. An album so deep and complex, followed by one called 'Music' almost suggests she lost all identity, but thankfully the album maintained a lot of magic and continued to cement her legacy as the biggest female pop star the world had ever seen. It began with a triumphant lead single that shot to #1 across the world, and was followed by a string of other hits. The album became a commercial force too rocketing to #1 across the globe, as well as being critically praised for its consistency and creativity and it went on to garner 5 Grammy nominations, winning one of them. To help spread the album further, Madonna performed at the MTV VMAs and took the album on the road with her wondrous 'Drowned World' tour in conjunction with her previous album. A theme that continued through some of the album's visuals, the album cover saw Madonna donning her best cowgirl outfit, but doesn't quite rank as one her best for me.

 

Madonna explains how the album is made up of different parts (much like many of her albums). Primarily it is about music and all the positives it brings, the ability to dance and enjoy and love yourself through it but there is also a deep rooted sense of love and loss in life. The sounds are largely hypnotic shown especially in the killer duo of 'Impressive Instant' and

which keep the energy up for the opening of the album and also merge its central concerns together.
brings the pace down considerably but the runaway lover seems to still be on the loose and the album's exploration of loss and travelling on lonely roads (as the visuals also express) are brought about wonderfully here. This is brought out again in the album's closing as
draws the album to a shuddering halt. Elsewhere on the album, the bewitching sounds of
show yet another experimental side to the album and once again harks back to earlier times in the artist's life. All in all a deeply personal yet at the same time universal album. Not quite as punchy as some of the dance that was to follow, not quite as damning as some of her darker stuff and not quite as fluid as the one that came before it, but it's a highly accomplished collection and deserves a top 5 place here.

 

-x-

16 | Open Your Heart

17 | Don't Tell Me

18 | Get Together

19 | Borderline

20 | Like A Virgin

21 | Music

22 | Holiday

23 | Live To Tell

24 | Die Another Day

25 | Justify My Love

26 | Cherish

27 | Nothing Really Matters

28 | Lucky Star

29 | You'll See

30 | Crazy For You

31 | Drowned World/Substitute For Love

32 | 4 Minutes

33 | Hollywood

34 | True Blue

35 | Give It 2 Me

36 | Burning Up

37 | Secret

38 | Rain

39 | Who's That Girl

40 | What It Feels Like For A Girl

41 | Human Nature

42 | Miles Away

43 | Nothing Fails

44 | Dress You Up

45 | American Life

46 | Erotica

47 | Deeper and Deeper

48 | Take A Bow

49 | I'll Remember

50 | Girl Gone Wild

51 | Oh Father

52 | Bedtime Story

53 | Masterpiece

54 | American Pie

55 | Don't Cry For Me Argentina

56 | Causing A Commotion

57 | Angel

58 | This Used To Be My Playground

59 | Love Profusion

60 | You Must Love Me

61 | Give Me All Your Lovin'

62 | Bad Girl

63 | Everybody

64 | Keep It Together

65 | Dear Jessie

66 | Turn Up The Radio

67 | Hanky Panky

68 | Fever

 

-x-

05 | Music

06 | Like A Virgin

07 | American Life

08 | Erotica

09 | Madonna

10 | Bedtime Stories

11 | Hard Candy

12 | MDNA

I own that album, but because someone lent it to me at the time and I never got round to giving it back (nor did they ask for it back) :lol:

 

'Impressive Instant' and 'Runaway Lover' are the two absolute best on here for me, the former is one of her finest works. Totally batshit crazy, I want to know what she had taken when she came up with it.

A SCANT few highlights aside, it GALLS ME to see that album so high. It's just so blah and lacking in substance, especially as a follow up to Ray Of Light.

I love Open Your Heart and definately my fave from the True Blue era, glad it's done so well here.

 

I guessed Music would be #5, great album Music (song) and Don't Tell Me, such classics Impressive Instant and Runaway Lover, such great tracks and Amazing and Gone such beautifulness, I even liked the addition of American Pie on there, which was quite random, but still loved it

  • Author
A SCANT few highlights aside, it GALLS ME to see that album so high. It's just so blah and lacking in substance, especially as a follow up to Ray Of Light.

I am struggling to find songs that AREN'T highlights in some way or another. I feel you were going through a breakdown or something when it dropped because i can't understand the hate. You can't deny the Impressive/Lover duo surely!?

 

I mean the highs are nowhere near the highs she gets in almost every other album, but there also aren't any damning lows and so for consitency's sake this is definitely in the top half for me.

The only tracks I'd ever listen to these days out of choice are Paradise and Impressive Instant. Nobody's Perfect and Runaway Lover are solid too, but very much 'good album track' solid, rather than f*** ME where did this come from good like Paradise and II.

 

I'll give you consistent though, it just happens to be consistently BLAH. For me, it sounds like the album of someone who has lost the passion for what they are doing. I know that is absolutely the case post 2008, but when it's sandwiched between two albums which have such a strong singular vision and purpose, even if it was slightly derailed with American Life it suffers immensely. I know it's probably not fair or right to judge it based on how good it is relative to everything else she's done, but surely that's the way everyone conducts every rate (I know I do), so on that basis it is very much my least favourite of all her albums. Solid, but uninteresting, which means I have virtually no desire to ever return to it.

... and it's quite possibly my favourite of her albums, ha. It contains two of her very best album tracks for me, and the singles were solid. Pleased that it's Top 5 at least! Maybe I have a bit of sentimentality towards this album because it's the first of hers I ever owned.

 

I've admitted this to Bal on more than one occasion, and he's told me off about it... 🐒 but I'm so surprised that 'Jump' is still in the running. I've never quite understood the love for it; I find it "ok" at best. Nowhere near Top 20 for me.

Agreed Jay. It's time for "Jump" to make a leap out of here before the top ten, it's already way too high.

 

( :kink: )

  • Author
I've admitted this to Bal on more than one occasion, and he's told me off about it... but I'm so surprised that 'Jump' is still in the running. I've never quite understood the love for it; I find it "ok" at best. Nowhere near Top 20 for me.

No one likes a bitter old man betty. I see your 'Rain' and 'Turn Up The Radio' down there and feel for you~

 

coffee_20.png

No one likes a bitter old man betty. I see your 'Rain' and 'Turn Up The Radio' down there and feel for you~

 

coffee_20.png

 

Gurl I'll accept 'Rain' (which should be SO much higher!), but don't you be making me out to be some sort of 'Turn Up The Radio' lover. wait_20.png I gave that the same score as Jump! http://i6.photobucket.com/albums/y243/Azzara/skype/skype-makeup.gif

 

Tyler knows where it's at!

I mean surely y'all can't prefer "Jump" to "Hung Up"??

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.