Jump to content

Featured Replies

  • Replies 78
  • Views 5.7k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

UGH. That is disgustingly low for 'Say Goodbye'! I know S Club are known for being best when doing their dancefloor smashes etc... but SG deserved top 10 at the very least! :cry: 'Some Girls' needs to die a death soon... ew.
  • Author
UGH. That is disgustingly low for 'Say Goodbye'! I know S Club are known for being best when doing their dancefloor smashes etc... but SG deserved top 10 at the very least! :cry: 'Some Girls' needs to die a death soon... ew.

 

First You, now Some Girls, Jonjo you're killing me :cry:

  • Author

14 07.5 Two In a Million

 

http://eil.com/images/main/S-Club-7-Two-In-A-MillionY-223984.jpg

 

Out of all the boys, you're none like the others :heart: Such a sweet song by S Club, led by Jo as with most of their ballads. Two In a Million was released as a double a-side with You're My Number One and made it their third top 2 single out of three. The song seems about right in terms of its position here, not one of my favourites but mainly due to how strong their discography is.

 

Chart Run: 5-6-2-3-8-17-29-35-33-48-59-x

Highest: 10.0 (Simon, Liamshikari27)

Lowest: 04.0 (Lee Wallace)

  • Author

13 07.5 Negotiate With Love

 

http://imgcache.qq.com/music/photo/album/42/albumpic_79942_0.jpg

 

Now THIS is an example of Buzzjack getting it WRONG! :o Negotiate With Love is one of my favourite Rachel tracks and the only one I properly love from the very overrated Come & Get It :ph34r: Should be top 10 at least :cry: Negotiate With Love was the first single from Rachel's second album and despite making the top 10, didn't make a huge impact on the chart. However, it spent 1 more week top 40 than the other two C&GI singles so the public clearly agrees with me :heehee: x

 

Chart Run: 10-20-31-40-47-70-x

Highest: 10.0 (JosephStyles, Ultraviolence1989, Regina, Martyn)

Lowest: 01.0 (fgi090505)

'Negotiate With Love' is a great track! Sophisticated sounding pop, good lyrically and should've done better (both here and in the chart).

 

They chose such a ridiculously busy week in 2005 that week though.

Love 'Negotiate With Love', dare I say it's quite avant-garde for a UK commercial pop song. I feel slightly concerned that we're fast approaching 10 years since Rachel released it. :snif:
Negotiate Wirh Love is incredible, as is all of that album <3 way too low here.
  • Author

12 07.8 Natural

 

http://eil.com/images/main/S-Club-7-Natural-179415.jpg

 

An S Club 7 single that sadly seems very forgotten in the long run, Natural was the first single of the group's to miss the top 2, peaking at #3 which is no bad thing of course. This was the first single released with Rachel on lead vocals (the only other being You) and didn't end up with any really low scores, nothing below a 4/10, so this goes to show again how good they were!

 

Chart Run: 3-10-14-26-37-33-37-49-57-70-72-75-73-x-73-56-71-x

Highest: 10.0 (Cremey, Jay, Martyn, Liam, Stuart25)

Lowest: 04.0 (Gezza, Aphrodite)

I am genuinely shocked at that! I had it down as a genuine contender for the win! :o
  • Author

11 08.0 So Good (same 11s, less 10s)

 

http://images.amazon.com/images/P/B0009R34QG.01.LZZZZZZZ.jpg

 

Another shocker now, expected So Good to be quite high! Can't say I'm gutted though, this is one of the weaker Rachel tracks for me (still great though). So Good was Rachel's last top 10 hit, over 9 years ago now! Wasn't much of a hit beyond getting the top 10 position though, with a swift exit from the top 40.

 

Chart Run: 10-17-29-48-57-68-x

Highest: 11.0 (Martyn, Stuart25)

Lowest: 02.0 (fgi090505)

  • Author

TOP 10

 

Bring It All Back

Don't Stop Movin'

Have You Ever

I Said Never Again (But Here We Are)

Never Had a Dream Come True

Reach

S Club Party

Some Girls

Sweet Dreams My LA Ex

You're My Number One

 

PREDICT

So good is so amazing. It was my absolute favourite song in the world when I was younger. I bought the cd physical version and blasted it out loud on my cd player in my back room like at least 10-15 times a day :wub:

Edited by Ultraviolence1989

  • Author
I have the CDs of So Good, and almost all Rachel singles! (literally missing one format of More More More which is quite annoying)

Oh no! Natural should be Top 10. :(

 

I'm pleased Have You Ever has made the Top 10. The scores it was getting didn't seem too good on the whole!

 

My ideal order would be this:

 

Don't Stop Movin'

Never Had a Dream Come True

Sweet Dreams My LA Ex

Some Girls

Have You Ever

S Club Party

Reach

Bring It All Back

I Said Never Again (But Here We Are)

You're My Number One (shouldn't be Top 10 really...)

  • Author

My ideal order:

 

Don't Stop Movin'

Sweet Dreams My LA Ex

S Club Party

Some Girls

Bring It All Back

Reach

Never Had a Dream Come True

Have You Ever

You're My Number One

I Said Never Again (But Here We Are)

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.