Jump to content

Featured Replies

Posted

http://www.popjustice.com/briefing/girls-a...o-worst/137294/

 

1. Call The Shots

2. Sound Of The Underground

3. Biology

[Miss You Bow Wow could have been in here if they’d done a single version]4. Untouchable

5. No Good Advice

6. The Promise

7. Sexy! No No No…

8. Something New

9. Something Kinda Ooooh

10. The Show

11. Can’t Speak French

12. Whole Lotta History

13. The Loving Kind

14. Wake Me Up

15. Long Hot Summer

16. Jump

17. Life Got Cold

18. Love Machine

19. I’ll Stand By You

20. See The Day

21. I Think We’re Alone Now

22. Beautiful ‘Cause You Love Me

 

Thoughts?

  • Replies 28
  • Views 3.2k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

In fact:

 

01 Untouchable (11)

02 The Loving Kind (10)

03 The Show (10)

04 Love Machine (09)

05 Sexy! No No No… (09)

06 Biology (09)

07 Call The Shots (08)

08 Jump (08)

09 Wake Me Up (08)

10 Sound Of The Underground (07)

 

11 Something Kinda Ooooh (07)

12 Something New (07)

13 No Good Advice (07)

14 I Think We’re Alone Now (07)

15 Long Hot Summer (07)

16 I’ll Stand By You (06)

17 Whole Lotta History (06)

18 Beautiful ‘Cause You Love Me (06)

19 Life Got Cold (05)

20 The Promise (04)

 

21 See The Day (04)

666 Can’t Speak French (00)

  • Author

POP MUSIC AT ITS VERY BEST

1 The Show

2 Something New

3 Call The Shots

4 Sexy! No No No

5 Untouchable

Still Standouts

6 No Good Advice

7 Biology

8 The Loving Kind

9 Can't Speak French

10 Whole Lotta History

11 Sound of The Underground

Great, still

12 The Promise

13 Wake Me Up

14 Something Kinda Ooh

Leaning towards mediocre

15 I'll Stand By Yew

16 Long Hot Summer

17 Love Machine

18 I Think We're Alone Now

19 Jump

Pretty shite

20 Life Got Cold

21 See The Day

22 BCYLM

Edited by Joe.

1. Something Kinda Ooooh

2. Something New

3. Sexy! No No No...

4. Call The Shots

5. Biology

6. The Promise

7. No Good Advice

8. The Show

9. Can't Speak French

10. Love Machine

11. Jump

12. Sound of the Underground

13. Wake Me Up

14. Whole Lotta History

15. Untouchable

16. The Loving Kind

17. Long Hot Summer

18. I'll Stand By You

19. Life Got Cold

20. See The Day

21. I Think We're Alone Now

22. Walk This Way

23. Beautiful Cause You Love Me

 

Everything in my Top 14 is essential. *.* 15-19 good. 20-23 "less good".

'Call The Shots' is SO ridiculously overrated, I really don't get how so many consider it their best when they have so many exciting pop songs in their repertoire.
I like all of Girls Aloud singles, even the ones that always get stuck near the bottom of lists, so I don't think I'm ever going to be happy with any single being too near the bottom. That Pop Justice list isn't too bad though. I mean, 'Jump', 'Love Machine' and 'The Loving Kind' would probably be higher for me, and I don't think 'No Good Advice', 'The Show' and certainly not 'Biology' would be that high, but there's nothing too offensive.

Love Machine is disgustingly low :drama: Not too bad a list and Call the Shots is wonderful so a worthy #1 :wub: My own list would likely look very different to that but I can't rly argue with it still.

 

My list:

 

1. Something New

2. Sexy! No No No...

3. The Show

4. Whole Lotta History

5. Something Kinda Ooooh

6. Love Machine

7. Call the Shots

8. The Loving Kind

9. Sound of the Underground

10. Can't Speak French

11. The Promise

12. Jump

13. Biology

14. Wake Me Up

15. Life Got Cold

16. I'll Stand By You

17. No Good Advice

18. Walk This Way

19. Untouchable

20. I Think We're Alone Now

21. Long Hot Summer

22. Beautiful 'Cause You Love Me

23. See the Day

 

The order changes every time I do this list though and I really do love all of these tracks in their own way :wub:

The Show is possibly their most underrated single I think :wub: Actually, Whole Lotta History is the most underrated, that doesn't get NEARLY enough love :cry:

Adam's GA Singles Rank v.3972

The Holy Trinity

1. Something New

2. Sexy! No No No...

3. Something Kinda Ooooh

 

Perfection

4. The Show

5. Wake Me Up

6. Call The Shots

7. Sound Of The Underground

8. Untouchable

9. Life Got Cold

10. No Good Advice

11. Biology

 

Brilliant

12. The Loving Kind

13. Can't Speak French

14. Jump

15. The Promise

16. Love Machine

 

MODELS, WAITING, WATCH ME GO AND WILD HORSES THO

17. Long Hot Summer

18. Whole Lotta History

 

Covers that aren't 'Jump'

19. I Think We're Alone Now

20. See The Day

21. I'll Stand By You

22. Walk This Way

 

I left my heart at the disco :snif:

23. Beautiful 'Cause You Love Me

11/10

01 Biology

02 Sexy! No No No...

03 Sound Of The Underground

04 Untouchable

 

10/10

05 Call The Shots

06 The Loving Kind

07 Can't Speak French

08 Something Kinda Ooh

 

9/10

09 No Good Advice

10 The Promise

 

8.5/10

11 See The Day (not even sorry)

12 I'll Stand By You

13 Long Hot Summer

14 The Show

15 Wake Me Up

 

8/10

16 Jump

17 Love Machine

18 I Think We're Alone Now

19 Life Got Cold

 

7/10

20 Whole Lotta History

21 Walk This Way

22 Beautiful 'Cause You Love Me

 

4/10

23 Something New (again not even sorry x)

Some people's opinions in this thread will be used as evidence FOR abolishing free speech
11 See The Day (not even sorry)

23 Something New (again not even sorry x)

 

YOU SHOULD BE!

 

Punishment: No Dan Osborne gifs for a month. :cool:

01. Biology

02. Sound Of The Underground

03. The Show

04. Call the Shots

05. The Promise

06. Love Machine

07. Sexy! No No No…

08. Wake Me Up

09. Something New

10. Untouchable

11. No Good Advice

12. Something Kinda Ooooh

13. The Loving Kind

14. Life Got Cold

15. Can’t Speak French

16. Jump

17. Long Hot Summer

18. Whole Lotta History

 

19. I’ll Stand By You

20. I Think We’re Alone Now

21. See The Day

22. Beautiful ‘Cause You Love Me

01 Biology

02 Sound Of The Underground

03 No Good Advice

04 Call The Shots

05 Sexy! No No No

06 The Show

07 Something New

08 The Loving Kind

09 Something Kinda Oooh

10 Love Machine

11 Wake Me Up

12 Whole Lotta History

13 Untouchable

14 Can't Speak French

15 Life Got Cold

16 The Promise

17 Jump

18 Long Hot Summer

19 I'll Stand By You

20 I Think We're Alone Now

21 See The Day

22 Walk This Way

23 Beautiful Cause You Love Me

 

Other than Love Machine being far too low and The Promise being far too high the PopJustice list isn't that far away from the truth.

Hell yeah!

- No Good Advice

- Biology

- The Show

- Untouchable

- Can't Speak French

- Sound Of The Underground

 

Yeah

- Sexy! No No No...

- The Promise

- Call The Shots

- Wake Me Up

- Something Kinda Ooooh

- The Loving Kind

- Love Machine

 

OK

- Life Got Cold

- Long Hot Summer

- Whole Lotta History

 

Let's give them all back to the original artists, they're not needed here

- Jump

- I Think We're Alone Now

- Walk This Way

- I'll Stand By You

- See The Day

 

No...

- Something New

 

Personal (not particularly positive) opinion aside, no artwork, no additional tracks, not even one tiny remix or anything, no promotion whatsoever = NOT a single

- Beautiful 'Cause You Love Me

The lack of Something New love here from some people upsets me :( It's CLASSIC Girls Aloud in my eyes, exactly what they're about. Bold, brashy and an incredible track.
The lack of Something New love here from some people upsets me :( It's CLASSIC Girls Aloud in my eyes, exactly what they're about. Bold, brashy and an incredible track.

That's the beauty of music, we hear the same thing, but our responses are so different :)

I'm fully aware that it's largely considered "typical Girls Aloud" (even the girls themselves said so when it was released), and I could give you reasons why I don't see it that way (if there's any interest), but it's just an opinion, and I don't want to convince anyone that I'm "right".

 

On the other hand, I still can't really comprehend when I hear a song I like, how come there's anyone in the world that doesn't realise just how fantastic it is :)

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.