I would have loved Keep Her as a single, but the era really had to move on! Maybe had Just Can't Get Enough not existed, but then I would have preferred Chasing Lights as a single.

Poor Jay.

 

I know he's a massive fan of opening up.

http://25.media.tumblr.com/tumblr_m9iosfF3gS1qjjf4ho3_1280.png

Oh YES at FIO being as low as it is. Awfully shouty and even if the girls didn't want it themselves, Kelly would never have taken it (coz it's shit).

Was catching up expecting to complain about Gentleman being BELOW Don't Let Me Dance Alone BUT FOREVER IS OVER? I'm having the week from hell as it is and that Forever Is Over falling out now hasn't helped! I LOVE how the girls asked for the track when they heard it being played at the label, you go Mollie King :wub:

omg all this FIO hate, welcome brothers :heart:

'Forever Is Over' KILLED their career. It was all far too moody and miserable and too soon after the fun and happy 'Chasing Lights' era.

40. Flashback



Score: 7,310
Highest Score: 10 x 2 (JSG, Totto)
Lowest Score: 3 x 1 (Tim)

Breaking into the top 40 is ‘Flashback’. The b-side to “Ego” was also the title track for the b-sides collection that came with the Finest Selection box set. It was co-written by the girls along with Hannah Robinson, who also wrote for the girls in the past with“I Can’t Wait” and “Why Me, Why Now”. I think it’s a bit overrated, to be honest. But how great do Frankie and Una sound?

Why are the girls working with Hannah Robinson when she just produces shit.

Oh no, I would have given 'Forever Is Over' an 11 had I remembered to do this. :( Gets waaaaay too much hate.

This one will hurt Lee a lot.


























... Tho it does hurt me a bit as well :'(























And I'm surprised Sean doesn't like this one!


























39. Do What You Want With Me



Score: 7,365
Highest Score: 10 x 2 (Jonjo, Lee)
Lowest Score: 3 x 1 (Sean)

This track, taken from the girls fourth (third?) studio-album ‘On Your Radar’, is a thumping dance song which incorporates elements of dubstep, and has a spectacular uptempo drum ‘n bass finale. Producer Jaz Rogers behind the track said of it: “we really tried to push the boat with it, sonically, style-wise, edge-wise, and come up with something to extend who The Saturdays are”. It was performed on the All Fired Up! tour in 2011, although a rather pregnant Una had to sit this one out due to the particularly """racy""" routine which saw each girl straddling and grinding upon their male dancers. Also, you might remember the effect of the live auto-tune on their voices throughout the whole song………………

 

 

 

 

 

 

38. Wish I Didn’t Know

 

 

Score: 7.404

Highest Score: 10 x 5 (Johnkm, AdamAloud, Tim, Cameron, Martyn)

Lowest Score: 2 x 1 (Mackenzie)

 

‘On Your Radar’ seems to be taking some sort of a cull here, poor it! Here is The sixth On Your Radar track to go ; it was co-written by the girls, predominantly (or so it seems) Una and Mollie since they are the only ones you can hear on the demo that leaked a few years back. What do you guys think of this hearfelt ballad? It has managed a spectular amount of five 10s which means some of you sure do appreciate it!

 

 

 

 

omg wtf is wrong with y'all. Wish I Didn;t Know is a fookin JAM and deserved top 20 lbr

OH HELL f***ING NO AT DO WHAT YOU WANT WITH ME FINISHING SO LOW.

I love Wish I Didn't Know. Damn you all!

Wish I Didn't Know is incredible.

 

 

 

 

 

 

37. Karma

 

 

Score: 7.442

Highest Score: 10 x 3 (Acidburn, Liam, JosephStyles)

Lowest Score: 2 x 1 (Totto)

 

The second Headlines track to get cut and sadly…it isn’t’Missing You’! Booooo. This little loud and agressive bop was written by Sats dream team Ina Wroldsen and Steve Mac, and was performed on the Headlines tour. The girls were shown rehearsing the rather violent choreography in one of their Behind the Headlines video diaries and Mollie, in particular, was clearly giving her all.

 

 

 

No way is Karma out already! :cry: I really enjoyed that one! Possibly my favourite album track by them </3

'Do What You Want With Me' is PHENOMENAL. HOW ON EARTH HAS IT FINISHED SO LOW? :\ Literally the worst thing to happen in this forum. You are all WRONG with that judgement! The gradual build up to THAT finale is life changing. It really should've followed 'All Fired Up' as the 3rd single, with 'My Heart Takes Over' as the 4th single. I really am gutted and fuming at that being so low. :snif:

 

'Karma' is great, but it's in it's position about where I expected it tbh.

36 (666). Missing You



Score: 7.481
Highest Score: 11 x 1 (Martyn)
Lowest Score: -1 x 1 (Cameron) (YASS CAMERON DRAG IT BABE!!!)

So let’s talk about this next elimination.
http://popcrush.com/files/2015/05/mariah-carey-i-dont-know-her.gif

That’s enough.

You're all awful people.

 

Also are we seriously not getting any commentary on one of their singles?