November 7, 20159 yr WOW at that performance from Louisa. Incredible, best one so far for sure :wub: 09.5 Louisa Johnson -- 08.5 Kiera Weathers 08.5 4th Impact 08.0 Ché Chesterman -- 04.0 Mason Noise -- Anton Stephans (unranked for now :') )
November 7, 20159 yr I don't like that Louisa is trying to be a pop star when she isn't one. Still, excellent performance. Her vocal runs need to be toned down, though, which will be an unpopular opinion. 10 Che 08 Louisa 08 Mason 07 Fourth Impact 04 Kiera 01 Anton
November 7, 20159 yr 4th Impact - I didn't really feel like that, I feel like they struggle unless they're belting it out as they were allowed to do in the chorus. The opening almost sounded like it was in the wrong key to me so yeah, probably the worst thing they've done so far. Not bad but I'm left feeling a bit "you can do better". 6.5/10 Mason Noise - I've thought from the beginning that his success in this will depend on the song choices, last week was spot on, that went absolutely nowhere. I don't think anybody could make that song a "moment", the dancing was embarassing aswell. Not cool, just... no. 4/10 Anton Stephans - I actually feel sorry for him. I don't like the guy and I've found him annoying throughout, but he can actually sing but that was just him shouting. One of the worst performances I've seen in the eleven series of this show, he's not a novelty act so I can't laugh, he's a good singer being annhilated. What the hell was Simon thinking?! 1/10 Keira Weathers - SO SO SO MUCH BETTER. I loved the direction they went with her there, it gave her a much better path to before and I thought she did a good job with it. I'm not sure the song choice did much to show off her vocals entirely due to how much instrumental there was but I enjoyed it a lot which has to count for a lot. 8.5/10 Che Chesterman - I'm not giving it a 10 because it wasn't a moment that grabbed me like THIS IS PERFECT... but I can't fault it. What a voice. 9.5/10 ---- Louisa Johnson - She's obviously fantastic and that was another great performance obviously. At times though, I felt like the whole song was just her belting and being powerful, in the words of Jessie J, it needed more "light and shade", some of it was oversung a tad. 9/10
November 7, 20159 yr If she can sing a song without ending up in Cuntina warbling and bellowing I'd be quite pleased to watch it. That was not the right style for her, once again. She's clearly a very good singer but she needs to work on her technique.
November 7, 20159 yr Louisa is defo the winner in the eyes of Simon and whoever works behind the scenes this year (let's see if they can make it happen they couldn't with Fleur). She gets an iconic song that had an updated production that didn't stray too far from the original but enough to make it different. She gave a good but not great vocal, but given her competition on the vocal side it was strides above most others in the comp.
November 7, 20159 yr Louisa Johnson - It was good fun and it was nice to see her have fun with a performance for once. Not her best vocal and I wasn't completely convinced the song suited her vocals completely. Still, a very good performance. - 08.0/10.0 Che Chesterman - 08.5 Louisa Johnston - 08.0 Kiera Weathers - 06.0 4th Impact - 05.0 Mason Noise - 05.0 Anton Stephan - 00.0
November 7, 20159 yr Seann -- warbling and too much theatric. 10 Che 08 Louisa 08 Mason 07 Fourth Impact 05 Seann 04 Kiera 01 Anton
November 7, 20159 yr Author Seann was so good, his best so far for me! I love the theatrics and staging. 10 Louisa 09 Seann 08.5 Che (scaling it down a bit) 08.5 Kiera 07 4th Impact 05.5 Mason 00 Anton
November 7, 20159 yr An improvement on last week for me, much less cruise ship (although still a bit too theatrical). Although, I still fail to see where he'd fit in within the current market. 09.5 Louisa Johnson -- 08.5 Kiera Weathers 08.5 4th Impact 07.5 Ché Chesterman 07.0 Seann Miley Moore -- 04.0 Mason Noise -- Anton Stephans (unranked for now :') )
November 7, 20159 yr It doesn't matter what Seann sings it just sounds like theatre stuff. He could really do with just toning everything down, do an Adele just stand behind a mic or sit on a chair and concentrate on the vocal and not going into broadway singing/overacting.
November 7, 20159 yr He would not sell but he is an amazing performer and singer. It's all too theatre, as has been said plenty of times.
November 7, 20159 yr It was good, but a bit too theatrical for me. 6/10 Louisa 7.5/10 Seann 7/10 4th Impact - 7/10 Che - 6/10 Kiera - 5.5/10 Mason - 5/10 Anton - 2/10
November 7, 20159 yr 4th Impact - I didn't really feel like that, I feel like they struggle unless they're belting it out as they were allowed to do in the chorus. The opening almost sounded like it was in the wrong key to me so yeah, probably the worst thing they've done so far. Not bad but I'm left feeling a bit "you can do better". 6.5/10 Mason Noise - I've thought from the beginning that his success in this will depend on the song choices, last week was spot on, that went absolutely nowhere. I don't think anybody could make that song a "moment", the dancing was embarassing aswell. Not cool, just... no. 4/10 Anton Stephans - I actually feel sorry for him. I don't like the guy and I've found him annoying throughout, but he can actually sing but that was just him shouting. One of the worst performances I've seen in the eleven series of this show, he's not a novelty act so I can't laugh, he's a good singer being annhilated. What the hell was Simon thinking?! 1/10 Keira Weathers - SO SO SO MUCH BETTER. I loved the direction they went with her there, it gave her a much better path to before and I thought she did a good job with it. I'm not sure the song choice did much to show off her vocals entirely due to how much instrumental there was but I enjoyed it a lot which has to count for a lot. 8.5/10 Che Chesterman - I'm not giving it a 10 because it wasn't a moment that grabbed me like THIS IS PERFECT... but I can't fault it. What a voice. 9.5/10 Louisa Johnson - She's obviously fantastic and that was another great performance obviously. At times though, I felt like the whole song was just her belting and being powerful, in the words of Jessie J, it needed more "light and shade", some of it was oversung a tad. 9/10 ---- Seann Miley Moore - Much better than last week, I loved the whole arrangement which made him feel like more than just a voice, which he fell into last week. The staging, the way he handled himself around the stage, it was very good for him to create a PERFORMANCE. I'm not completely wowed, but my favourite performance of his in a while. 9/10
November 7, 20159 yr Seann Miley Moore - Loved everything about that. He just radiates star quality. Incredible vocals and incredible performance, have no idea what Simon is going on about - the song suited him perfectly. - 10.0/10.0 Seann Miley Moore - 10.0 Che Chesterman - 08.5 Louisa Johnson - 08.0 Kiera Weather - 06.0 4th Impact - 05.0 Mason Noise - 05.0 Anton Stephan - 00.0
Create an account or sign in to comment