December 14, 20159 yr D’YER’MANG’ER: Mr Showbiz - Showbiz Christmas - 4 updubs Please reveal yourselves.
December 14, 20159 yr Bells are Christmassy, that's enough for me, It's a stunning song :wub: It is an insult to that song to call it a Christmas song. It is brilliant, amazong but NOT CHRISTMAS. It is existential. It is nothing about Chrisymas. At all. She only has one Christmas song, whixh I put in.
December 14, 20159 yr Well uh, those 8 updubs and 2 downdubs were... unexpected :P I just felt like sending another joke entry as I usually do in the spinoffs but I'll be happy to see if this actually does well :winner:
December 15, 20159 yr Still fuming a non-Christmas song,in either video or meaning, is being cheaply cast off as a Christmas song. Cheapest thing I've ever seen in BJSC. It also reduces a beautiful, metaphoric song on an ethereal, existential album to being about Christmas, which it is not. She has one Christmas song which was my entry. #nothappy Edited December 15, 20159 yr by FrostytheBeaver
December 15, 20159 yr #Justice4WhereAreYouChristmas? They are all Grinch's who do not appreciate the masterpiece of our generation.
December 15, 20159 yr VULKISSLETOE: Anjos & SUZY – Nesta Noite Branca - 0 updubs / 8 downdubs Most downdubs: Vulkissletoe (8)
December 15, 20159 yr Still fuming a non-Christmas song,in either video or meaning, is being cheaply cast off as a Christmas song. Cheapest thing I've ever seen in BJSC. It also reduces a beautiful, metaphoric song on an ethereal, existential album to being about Christmas, which it is not. She has one Christmas song which was my entry. #nothappy
December 15, 20159 yr SLEIGHPUPOK: Cast Of Shrek – Shrek The Halls - 11 updubs / 1 downdub http://www.acartoonchristmas.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/12/shrek-the-halls-christmas-special-donkey.jpg
December 15, 20159 yr It's an existential metaphoric song being reduced to christmas cheapness!! I'm kinda insulted tbh.
December 15, 20159 yr It's an existential metaphoric song being reduced to christmas cheapness!! I'm kinda insulted tbh. I didn't really think of it like that, do excuse me :lol: At the time I thought I was being a bit inspired actually, since it's not obviously Christmassy, but was indeed worried that maybe it wasn't Christmassy enough. I didn't mean to insult the song.
December 15, 20159 yr The veto panel thought it was Christmassy enough to be entered so it's Christmassy enough to be entered, if you disagree that much despite being a Vanessa Carlton fan don't point it? There's no need to put Mattias down for entering it just because you don't believe it fits in with the contest theme Michael :unsure: Deandria Hype though :cheer: Edited December 15, 20159 yr by SantasLindsleigh
December 15, 20159 yr Having not heard it, I'll say that I think sticking to too rigid a theme with holiday songs isn't great for getting good songs. Are you going to deduct my song for being blatantly more about Narnia than Santa, even though it mentions Christmas in the lyrics? Just like the Halloween contest ended up being a contest about the dark, the night and anything slightly horror related, I'm going to view this as a contest about winter, snow, aspects of traditional celebrations and anything related to that, lest listening to it all becomes a hell of supermarket jingles.
Create an account or sign in to comment