This was tough! I love both Britney and Katy, but I had to go with Britney this time.

1. Britney Spears – "Oops!...I Did It Again"

2. Katy Perry featuring Juicy J – "Dark Horse"

3. Girls Aloud – "Untouchable"

Super tough choice between Oops!... and Untouchable! Britney is the rightful winner of this thing but I think Untouchable has the edge over it for being such a perfect almost-end to the band that's interestingly quite different (maybe not structurally?) to everything else they'd done. I'm a total sucker for the post-trance sound which certainly helps.

 

Oops! is magical though, perfect video and an iconic song. I listened to the album for the first time recently and it's a shame that it's very much the template for a lot of the album tracks but it is also... a very good template.

 

Dark Horse is great but not close to the top 2 and not a real favourite of mine out of Katy's singles anymore. Definitely ahead of its time with the superior pre-chorus to the actual chorus ^_^

Edited June 26, 20196 yr by brokenrecords

voted for Dark horse

 

if it had been any other Britney song :/ Even back in the day I though Oops was a bad single

 

 

Britney

Untouchable

None of them are my favourite by each artist but I went for Oops, a classic.

I voted for Untouchable :wub: By far one of Girls Aloud's most underrated. Oops is my second place but all three are 10s

Untouchable & Dark Horse

I am Australian, what is Dark Horse :thinking:

 

In all seriousness, I gotta go for Oops...

Dark Horse

Oops I Did It Again :heart:

I'll go with Oops, but just barely. I feel like Dark Horse has already aged more in 5 years than Oops has in almost 20.

Toxic vs. Teenage Dream final incoming??

^I'm sure 'Teenage Dream' was used in Round 1.

Yeah it was, oops!

:o Wonder what'll be sent

ET is probably the best bet.

Katy are sending Save As Draft x

Ooh these are all actually good, I went narrowly with Dark Horse cos it is easily one of her best, the other two are very good but aren't quite up there with each artists' best.