October 16, 20195 yr Author I love 5H but wouldn't even recognize her if she walked past me on the street! The majority of viewers in th UK won't care about their two big hits a few years ago, and certainly won't know the one who never really did anything in the group :lol:
October 16, 20195 yr I guess you could argue it either way... yes those things may be true but they haven't signed FH, they've signed one fifth and not one of the most important fifths in the eyes of the public... from another country. Is it better than Rachel Hylton but you can see why people might think it a little weak.
October 16, 20195 yr OMG YES :heart: Dami and Samantha to get their coronation winners singles to smash over here please!!
October 16, 20195 yr OMG YES :heart: Dami and Samantha to get their coronation winners singles to smash over here please!! I would watch just for these two. Probably 2 of the best X Factor winners all around the World.
October 16, 20195 yr 5H harmony weren’t that big here Work From Home aside. They never managed a successful album did they? Their UK career really died as soon as Camila left and I imagine it was the same on a WW scale too. Camila was the star of that band and the only one who had anything about her. Demi said it on one of the early live shows and she was SPOT ON. So yeah if this was a US show Dinah would be a bigger pull but ask a UK person who Dinah Jane is they’ll likely have no clue.
October 16, 20195 yr I love 5H but wouldn't even recognize her if she walked past me on the street! The majority of viewers in th UK won't care about their two big hits a few years ago, and certainly won't know the one who never really did anything in the group :lol: Dinah always got the most solo’s and is arguably one of the better vocalists but queen of slaying for not doing anything *.*
October 17, 20195 yr I don't think you can really argue a member of Fifth Harmony is a barrel scrape for the UK but simultaneously not say a thing about Samantha Jade :lol:
October 17, 20195 yr Author I mean both of them are, to me getting random international people just feels like none of the big or memorable names from our own series would do it so they had to find a few others to fill it :lol: Which is fine, the international acts saved BGT Champions tbh, I guess they can't help it if the likes of Leona, Matt Cardle, Rebecca, Shayne Ward won't do it but when it's called All Stars you don't expect an XF Aus winner and "the one off Fifth Harmony" I guess it might end up being refreshing though having "out there" choices with another shot at the crown
October 22, 20195 yr Author Paula Abdul is judging this, randomly :lol: She was always good on Idol though so I'm not mad at it.
October 24, 20195 yr Could they really not get one of the old judges back to do it? Even like Mel B or Tulisa?!
October 24, 20195 yr I was genuinely looking forwards to this but now I think it just sounds like trash. I mean seriously one fifth of Fifth Harmony lol. Nobody even knows who they are bar Camilla and the one who duetted with Sam Smith... And then an Australian winner that again nobody knows :blink: I thought Leona was supposed to have signed up to this? Not here for X Factor from around the world tbh I want the UK ones, and if they can't get them back then don't bother doing it. There is plenty to choose from afterall come on... - Steve Brookstein - G4 - Shayne Ward - Andy Abraham - Chico - Leona Lewis - Ray Quinn - Leon Jackson - Rhydian Roberts - Same Difference - Alexandra Burke - JLS (or a member of JLS maybe rather than 5th Harmony aka Aston Merrigold) - Eoghan Quinn - Diana Vickers - Ruth Lorenzo - Joe McElderry - Olly Murs - Stacey Solomon - Jedward - Matt Cardle - Rebecca Ferguson - One Direction (I mean total no chance bu Louis maybe lol) - Cher Lloyd - Little Mix (again fat chance lol) - Marcus Collins - Amelia Lilly - James Arthur - Jahmene Douglas - Christopher Baloney (oops sorry Maloney) - Union J - Rylan Clark - Ella Henderson - Lucy Spraggen - Sam Bailey - Ben Haenow - Fleur East - Andrea Faustini - Stereokicks - Jake Quickenden - Louisa Johnson - Reggie and Bollie - Matt Terry - Saara Alto - Rak Su - Dalton Harris All the above are name / acts who came top 3, or did well after the show or are remembered... surely they can get a decent line up from the above. I mean I know they aren't going to get Olly, One Direction lads or Little Mix but surely they could have got a member of JLS rather than Fifth Harmony and some decent UK acts who have nothing to lose from doing it (Leona tbh sadly).
Create an account or sign in to comment