Jump to content

Albums Survivor - The Final. Rated R vs Loud 21 members have voted

  1. 1. Vote for your FAVOURITE!

    • Rated R
      12
    • Loud
      9

Please sign in or register to vote in this poll.

Featured Replies

Posted

After a tense semi final Good Girl Gone Bad left the survivor as BuzzJack’s third favourite Rihanna album.

 

There was just one vote in it!

 

Good Girl Gone Bad was Rih’s third studio album and was the era to turn her into a worldwide icon and house hold name. The albums lead single spent ten weeks at #1 in the UK and earned her a US #1 single too. The album itself would earn her a UK #1 and would sell in excess of 2 million copies. It’s her second highest seller in the UK slightly behind Loud. The album is the only Rihanna album to get a re release! It’s a fantastic pop album with so gems but third place is about right as I think she’s progressed since this record but it was definitely a huge step up from her first two albums and it’s probably the album what changed her life as it set the tone for the rest of her career.

 

So we’re now in the final round of our albums survivor.

 

Rated R and Loud remain and in order to end this on a positive and celebratory note I ask for you to choose your favourite!

 

The WINNER of Rihanna Album Survivor will be decided by you voters! With the poll closing on Saturday at 6pm.

 

 

Results so far

 

Round 1: 80% of 16 votes - Music Of The Sun

Round 2: 76.47% of 17 votes - A Girl Like Me

Round 3: 35.29% of 17 votes - Unapologetic

Round 4: 52.38% of 21 votes - Talk that Talk

Round 5: 50% of 20 votes - ANTI

Round 6 - Semi final 44.44% of 18 votes - Good Girl Gone Bad

  • Replies 19
  • Views 902
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

  • Author
I voted for Loud, but I can't see my vote.

 

Made this visible for you now!

 

Don’t know what happened there should be showing now though :)

  • Author
Omg it was 4 - 0 when I last checked, now 3 - 2 :/

 

Rated R had an accidental vote what was meant to be for Loud.

 

I’m finding it hard trying to be neutral now though. I really want Rated R to win this.

 

Loud is my second favourite. But Rated R is truly her magnum opus. An amazing atmospheric masterpiece from start to finish.

Both are some of the greatest albums of our time in all honesty.

 

Both are COMPLETELY different to each other and it's hard to compare them enough to vote in this...

 

but I think I'm gonna go for 'Rated R' as my favourite, right now. Honestly they both change so much and vary on the mood I'm in. But the correct top 2! Similar with positions 3 & 4 for me I voted GGGB against ANTI, but both of those are interchangeable in themselves depending on my mood!

 

So the correct top 4!

  • Author
Both are some of the greatest albums of our time in all honesty.

 

Both are COMPLETELY different to each other and it's hard to compare them enough to vote in this...

 

but I think I'm gonna go for 'Rated R' as my favourite, right now. Honestly they both change so much and vary on the mood I'm in. But the correct top 2! Similar with positions 3 & 4 for me I voted GGGB against ANTI, but both of those are interchangeable in themselves depending on my mood!

 

So the correct top 4!

 

Agree on a lot of this!

 

These are her two best albums for me as well yet they’re poles apart.

 

Loud is the one I’ve listened more of lately I always go to that album in warm weather but Rated R is my favourite as a whole piece from start to finish.

 

My third fave though is Unapologetic that’s my “gone too soon” on this rate. But most of the time I’ve been in agreement on the polls.

TTT stayed one round too long and Unapologetic went too soon though for me. It’s been a fun and surprising rate though. I really thought ANTI would’ve been in the final with one of Rated R or Loud! Happy yet shocked GGGB beat it!

Rated R is the best, far more cohesive and complex and her themes into darker content acknowledged with her assault make the record all the more vulnerable and oddly endearing. Cold Case Love, Russian Roulette and The Last Song are Rihanna at her emotional best. Each track is powerful (minus Stupid In Love) and hearing Mad House gives me chills to this day.

 

Loud is undeniably full of hits, but I feel it has aged more than Rated R. S&M is epic but it doesn't hold quite the raw appeal of Rude Boy, ironically both having writing credits by Ester Dean.

 

Loud is a great record, but Rated R was the album which made me fall in love with Rihanna.

Rated R by far, it was my favourite until Anti came along.

Loud is good but has always been an overrated one from her discography for me. That red hair tho :heart:

Omg I was so expecting ‘Loud’ to win! I mean it still might but I’m impressed at this taste, can we go out next Thursday at 8pm and have for Buzzjack x
Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.