Jump to content

Featured Replies

  • Author

OK... maybe a poll won't be needed? :lol:

 

I love MATM too! It's so slick and attention grabbing enough, imo. I prefer Make Me & Slumber Party, but they'd both bomb completely. At least MATM gives me hope that we could give up a fight? :lol:

  • Replies 334
  • Views 11.4k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

My favourite of the 4 songs named is Make Me, but sadly I don't see it being a safe choice!

 

Slumber Party is second favourite, but I'm even less confident in it </3 #everybodygiveitupforTinasha

 

Me Against the Music... third fave, but obviously the biggest in terms of commercial success and being recognisable. Seems like a solid choice.

 

Till the World Ends tends to do the best out of these 4 songs in Britney rates and other games, but of course that's with the original version. Not sure how popular or not the Nicki/Kesha version is nowadays, although I remember it being pretty loved in 2011! I'm not sure how I feel about using it.

 

 

I probably lean towards Me Against the Music, I don't feel HUGELY confident about it, but hopefully it would do what it needs to do!

Literally the exact same as Jay!! Favourite is Make Me, then Slumber Party - they are two that are near guaranteed points from me.

 

MATM is perhaps your best choice, but it's not a massive favourite of mine. TTWE is an incredible song... on its own and featureless - could the fact that the original is so well liked work in its favour? Idkk

The Till The World Ends remix isn’t on Spotify as well which is what a lot of people listen to discover the songs
Yeah I think it'd be difficult for the TTWE remix because a lot of people will be judging on the remix, not the song. I think a few people said they didn't like the Xtine remix of DWUW and obviously it didn't go out but it cost them a few votes potentially. I'd go Me Against The Music, I love it! <3
  • Author

What option would you prefer?

 

It's not an ideal round for Brit, but I'm thinking MATM has the most potential to do well. Plus it's actually really underrated as a track.

At this point I can't say one is better than the other if I am honest.

 

All I know is that MATM didn't age well and it sounds very outdated. It's the weakest link in her lead single discography for me.

 

And when it comes to underrated, I think Make Me is the one for that title, but then I am not sure how well that is welcomed within BJ members!!!

  • Author
At this point I can't say one is better than the other if I am honest.

 

All I know is that MATM didn't age well and it sounds very outdated. It's the weakest link in her lead single discography for me.

 

And when it comes to underrated, I think Make Me is the one for that title, but then I am not sure how well that is welcomed within BJ members!!!

All the possible choices are underrated! I prefer Make Me and Slumber Party but the general consensus on them isn't as strong as MATM when it comes to casuals/enticing for that extra vote, I think MATM (being the bigger hit) would be the most sensible/logical choice of the 3 </3

 

As for it ageing... well... I disagree :kink: It still sounds so fresh and slick today, imo. :heehee:

How these ended in last rate:

 

Make Me

Slumber Party

MATM

 

And is TTWE also being considered or is it being saved?!

  • Author

The original will be used in a round coming up, yes. But Nicki's opening verse has me worried that it'll be 4 stans that vote it and no one else :lol:

 

Rates are more fan/stan related. You very rarely get casual appeal voters! Loads of people who have been consistently voting in AF Idol, haven't taken part in her rate! They all finished very similarly, so the bigger hit, will have most appeal, no?

 

Had Make Me finished top 15 and the other 2 where they currently are, I'd agree and send MM!

IMPORTANT DISCOVERY:

 

JayAgainstTheMusic is 2 characters too long to become my next username :cry:

 

Therefore I FULLY throw my support behind Make Me, so I can be... JaykeMe :magic:

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

:kink:

 

Edit: I wasn't going to let a 16 character limit defeat me, I am now JꜽAgainstᵺeMusic :lol:

Songs Recap:

 

Round 1: Womanizer [Free choice]

Round 2: Gimme More [Lead single]

Round 3: Cinderella [songs without music videos]

Round 4: Stronger [Free choice]

Round 5: Pretty Girls [Worst single]

Round 6: I Wanna Go [songs that missed the UK Top 75]

Round 7: Unusual You [ballad album track]

Round 8: Everytime [singles to close an era]

Round 9: Oops!...I Did It Again [Free choice]

Round 10: (You Drive Me) Crazy (The Stop Remix) [A remix, bonus track or B-side]

Me Against The Music for SURE!

 

 

But I won’t lie Britneys collabs are all mid / bottom tier on her discography for whatever reason in a way what’s similar with Madonna her solo / non featured singles are always better than her collabs.

 

Best of luck though :)

  • Author

Tbf though mid-bottom tier of Brit's discography is like top 10 in most other artists discography...

 

 

:kink:

IMPORTANT DISCOVERY:

 

JayAgainstTheMusic is 2 characters too long to become my next username :cry:

 

Therefore I FULLY throw my support behind Make Me, so I can be... JaykeMe :magic:

:kink:

 

Edit: I wasn't going to let a 16 character limit defeat me, I am now JꜽAgainstᵺeMusic :lol:

 

 

How DARE you hoe! You should be Jaywillneverbethesameagain!!!

 

Ps I love me against the music, is Madonna forum considering that one? What happens then? The Nikki version of TTWE I hate think she ruins what is an amazing song!

How DARE you hoe! You should be Jaywillneverbethesameagain!!!

:lol: I now have a homage to both in my username, even though I'm not sure how many will realise that they're the initials of those two particular songs lol.

 

Ps I love me against the music, is Madonna forum considering that one? What happens then?

Madonna forum wouldn't have been able to use this song, because one of the rules is that the lead artists gets to claim a song because featured artists can't! Whereas if its a joint credit, it's a fight between the forums (for instance Lady Gaga got in there first with 'Rain on Me').

  • Author

HEY BRITNEYYYYYYY (forum)

 

 

Come support 'Me Against The Music' if you can!

 

COME HELP US <3

 

ROUND 11

 

Vote for 5 songs overall (so for example: Britney + 4 others!)

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.