I listened to the 5 songs a couple of days ago and was stumped over whether to vote for Madonna or Katy. I Don't Search I Find is a stand out moment from Madame X! I've finally decided though...

 

Lady Gaga - Gypsy (a song *.* )

Spice Girls - If U Can't Dance

Katy Perry - Act My Age

Funnily enough, even though I love Rihanna... Love the Way You Lie Pt. II has never really done it for me, and I continue to feel that way. The obviously familiar chorus is great, and the verses are well written. However there's something about the production and her vocals which seems too bland and lightweight, to me. Eminem is on form in the original version, but not so much on Pt. II. I'm interested to know what the Rihanna forum's second choice would have been? I think Cry and Farewell are much stronger. :wub:

Not a Rih mod but the other one people seemed to get behind was 'Cry', which deffo would've been my second choice at least. I don't think anything else would've gotten through, Borewell would've been my last choice ngl. Lost In Paradise maybe third?

Borewell

 

Cry to get its moment in AF Idol 3.0 please :wub:

 

P.S. There's 10 minutes to go until this round closes!

 

Cry to get its moment in AF Idol 3.0 please :wub:

 

P.S. There's 10 minutes to go until this round closes!

Name a worst song on Talk That Talk, I'll wait. x

Katy Perry - Act My Age

Lady Gaga - Gypsy

Madonna - I Don't Search I Find