The people who edit her Wikipedia pages don't seem to think it's a single, but I'm not sure what they're basing that on. Personally I feel like if a Carly song gets a music video after the album release, then that should be enough to classify it as a single! It's not like she gets much radio play, so there's not much else to go on other than a video. It also feels a bit strange for Too Much to be thought of as the last single from Dedicated (at least it seems strange to me).

 

I feel like if we're all comfortable with Want You In My Room being considered as a single, then it's a good option for a future round :heart:

Yeah I think save WYIMR and go with Gimmie Love, Comeback or Solo :wub:

 

I think the first two mentioned would do the best.

'Gimmie Love' is my favourite of those mentioned with 'Comeback' a strong 2nd!

LOVE Gimmie Love!

I think I might need to make a poll, I'm torn!

6 - Comeback - Jack, Jade, Jay, JosephStyles, Seven, Ultrafolklore

4 - Gimmie Love - George.keh, Jade, Jack, RobBot

2 - Higher - HausofGhibli, Rush

2 - Solo - George.keh, Jack

1 - Fever - George.keh

1 - Making the Most of the Night - WinterFreeze

 

[+ 5 - Want You in My Room - George.keh, Jack, RobBot, Rush, Seven - likely to be used in future round]

 

 

With Comeback and Gimmie More getting the most mentions and positive feedback, I'll make it a poll between those two.

 

 

Poll now added to the thread! Please vote for your preferred song to be sent in "Round 5: Free Album Track Choice" - Comeback or Gimmie Love?

It wasn't initially on my radar as a potential for this round, but now that it's been mentioned a few times I do feel like Gimmie Love could be a strong choice! I also feel like the mood of this track does offer something different to the previous 4 entries too, which is what I was hoping for in this round.

 

If Gimmie Love is sent, I'm not sure whether or not I can still fit Comeback into a future round. Let's see what the result of the poll ends up being! :cool:

Both are fab to be fair! Gimmie Love just gets it for me though as it was stunning seeing live!

Both are fab to be fair! Gimmie Love just gets it for me though as it was stunning seeing live!

Envious that you’ve seen her live! Definitely something I need to do someday :wub:

Omg what are these ugly results to the poll rn

COMEBACK

The only reason for not sending Comeback this round is that you should have sent it already xox

 

(not heard Gimmie Love tbf :kink:)

I love both but I think Gimmie Love is my favourite Carly album track so it’d make me very happy if it competed. I understand the reasons for Comeback too though!

I think I prefer Gimmie Love ever so slightly!

I hope that many of you will enjoy Gimmie Love in this round! :wub:

 

Other songs that were suggested for this round may still be used later on!

Results So Far:

Round 1: 1st, 31 votes out of 40 - Cut to the Feeling

Round 2: 3rd, 22 votes out of 32 - When I Needed You

Round 3: 4th (tied), 24 votes out of 39 - Super Natural (with Danny L Harle)

Round 4: 5th (tied), 18 votes out of 30 - Your Type

Round 5: 5th (tied), 16 votes out of 25 - Gimmie Love

 

Another Top 5, yay! :w00t:

 

~~~

 

Round 6's theme is: first single from an era!

 

Note: Call Me Maybe needs to be saved for a future round.

 

I Really Like You vs. Party for One - which should it be? Please let me know *.*

 

I Really Like You please!

Deffo I Really Like You