Jump to content

Featured Replies

Posted

AF Idol Spin-Off: Round 3 Reflection

Theme: Collaborations / Remixes

 

Thank you to the 39 voters who took part in this round! Jonjo and Jay have counted and verified the results. The EXTREMELY CLOSE AND NAIL-BITING results:

 

Pos / Points / Song (ties unbroken)

 

01 28 Coldplay feat. Rihanna - Princess of China

02 25 Gorillaz - 19-2000 (Soulchild Remix)

02 25 The Weeknd feat. Daft Punk - Starboy

04 24 Danny L Harle feat. Carly Rae Jepsen - Super Natural

04 24 KDA feat. Tinashe - Just Say

04 24 Röyksopp - What Else Is There? (Jacques Le Cont Radio Edit)

07 22 Michael Jackson & Janet Jackson - Scream

08 21 Mariah Carey feat. Miguel - #Beautiful

08 21 Tove Lo feat. Kylie Minogue - Really don't like u

10 19 Charli XCX feat. Kim Petras & Jay Park - Unlock It

10 19 Kelly Clarkson - Piece By Piece (Idol Version)

12 17 Hailee Steinfeld & Alesso feat. Florida Georgia Line & watt - Let Me Go

13 16 Pixie Lott feat. Pusha T - What Do You Take Me For?

14 13 Niall Horan & Maren Morris - Seeing Blind

15 8 tyDi & Jack Novak feat. Greyson Chance - Oceans

16 6 Rachel Stevens - Breathe In Breathe Out (Swat-Team Version)

 

That closeness :gaga:

 

Round 4: FREE CHOICE

 

Please confirm your song entries by 6pm on 27th July 2020. Round 4 will be going live for voting afterwards! Get discussing potential songs in the AF Hub threads and stream Easy by Troye Sivan now!

  • Replies 10
  • Views 492
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Pixie deserved so much better.

 

The Weeknd so close to number one, iconic that The Weeknd, Coldplay and Gorrilaz all flopped last round and slated this round!

slated this round!

Yes I think we should all slate this round and the results tbh x

:cheeseblock: The comeback. That winner. That top 3. So much :cheeseblock:

 

Going mainstream to get back on top - Just like Coldplay themselves in the 2010s :D

Fun fact, Charli was bottom 3, until the last 10 votes!

 

THAT COMEBACK!

I'm kind of surprised Tinashe did so well this round! That isn't shade, because I like Just Say and voted for it! :heart: It just seemed to me like it passed most people by when it was a single, so it's nice that it got positive attention in this.

 

I agree with you Rush re: Kelly Clarkson ( http://www.buzzjack.com/forums/index.php?s...t&p=6614584 ). I prefer the album version or radio mix! I do have appreciation for the Idol Version and I voted for it, but it's my least favourite version of the 3. Although I think we're definitely in the minority with this opinion. :kink:

 

The artists I'm representing: I'm very pleased to see Carly in the Top 5! Admittedly I wasn't particularly passionate or confident about sending Super Natural (I like it, but it's not a super Carly fave for me). However I couldn't overlook the support it received in the Carly thread, and I'm glad to see a lot of you enjoyed it! 8th is fine for Mariah - #Beautiful, it's one of my favourite songs of all-time and my #1 favourite song in this round by miles tbh!!

That moment when the votes for both of Joseph's artists combined would still only be enough for 14th :cheeseblock: :kink:

 

I'm glad that the sellout choice from Coldplay was worth it to get that bounce back from last round's disaster to this glorious victory. These results are overall great once again, second round in a row where 7 of my votes finished in the top 8, only Kim falling short this time and she was my 8th choice anyway!

 

Would 'Comeback' have done better for Carly? wejustdon'tknow.png

Excellent work for Gorillaz and Coldplay to slay that one :D But clearly a lot of good songs bunched up at the top, I broadly agree with that. Good stuff.
Hope y'all are ready for some low-key discoveries. This free choice is a lot more varied than I expected it to be! (i.e. not as many big hits being used!) EXCITED.

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.