Jump to content

Featured Replies

Posted

The Quintessential Male Artists Rate

 

 

 

my-love.jpgeminem-78.jpgEnrique-200x200.jpgrobbie-williams.pngusher-200x200.jpg

 

 

Hello,

 

First I want to thank you all 13 of you who participated and rated single discographies of what we considered Male Artists who ruled noughties.

 

Also I am planning to start the results tomorrow but in meantime you can speculate who will come on top, who will be in the bottom, which artist will have the most Top 10's etc. etc.

 

:cheer:

  • Replies 51
  • Views 1k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

  • Author
50 Eminem - Just Lose It avg. 5

Highest:9 (...readyforit, Doug)
Lowest: -1 (Bjork)




49 Robbie Williams - Radio avg. 5.03

Highest: 8 (Iceman501)
Lowest: 2 (Scene, gavindeejay)




48 Eminem - We Made You avg. 5.26

Highest:8.5 (Riser)
Lowest: 0 (Bjork)




47 Robbie Williams - Rudebox avg. 5.30

Highest: 9 (Doug, Iceman501)
Lowest: 0 (Nina West)




46 Justin Timberlake - Until The End Of Time avg. 5.46


Highest: 9 (...readyforit)
Lowest: 2 (Iceman501)




Bottom of the pile starts with 2 Eminem, 2 Robbie and 1 JT tracks. No big surprises to be quite frankly although Usher avoiding bottom 5 was not something I expected :kink:
  • Author

45 Robbie Williams - Bodies avg. 5.88

 

Highest: 8 (...readyforit, dandy*, Iceman501)

Lowest: 2 (Nina West)

 

 

 

44 Enrique Iglesias - Addicted avg. 5.88

 

Highest: 11 (Scene)

Lowest: 2 (Bjork)

 

 

 

43 Enrique Iglesias - Rhythm Divine avg. 6.15

 

Highest: 10 (...readyforit, Riser)

Lowest: 3 (Bjork, gavindeejay, Iceman501)

 

 

 

42 Usher - Love In This Club avg. 6.23

 

Highest: 10 (Iceman501)

Lowest: 3 (gavindeejay)

 

 

 

41 Enrique Iglesias - Do You Know? (The Ping Pong Song) avg. 6.30

 

Highest: 9 (Doug, Iceman501)

Lowest: 3 (Bjork, gavindeejay)

 

 

This section belongs to Enrique as he loses three songs at once and also Ushers loses his first track of the countdown. With that being said all the artists involved have a song in a bottom ten :kink:

Omg none of Enrique's songs should be this low! :drama: I suppose 'Do You Know' was a divisive one tbf, but still, 'Addicted' and 'Rhythm Divine' both beneath it? :(

 

I'm happy with 'Love In This Club' being Usher's lowest song though.

Omg not Usher performing the best so far. :tearsmile:

 

Poor Enrique! 'Addicted' should have finished top 10! :P I'm surprised it wasn't better received on this forum. It's like the antithesis of his 2010-11 electro-pop phase.

 

Justin's bottom track is no surprise... Robbie loses three duds which are no losses. Usher's LITC is not one of his highlights either.

 

The results are looking good so far besides Enrique appearing and 'Just Lose It' being bottom of the pile. :kink:

  • Author

40 Usher - U Don't Have To Call avg. 6.42

 

Highest: 11 (...readyforit)

Lowest: 4 (Scene, NickF1)

 

 

 

39 Justin Timberlake - Senōrita avg. 6.50

 

Highest: 8.5 (Riser)

Lowest: 3 (dandy*)

 

 

 

38 Enrique Iglesias - Be With You avg. 6.69

 

Highest: 10 (Addy!)

Lowest: 4 (Iceman501)

 

 

 

37 Justin Timberlake - Summer Love avg. 6.73

 

Highest: 10 (Addy!)

Lowest: 3 (Scene)

 

 

 

36 Eminem - The Way I Am avg. 6.84

 

Highest: 9 (Addy!, Iceman501)

Lowest: 3 (Bjork)

 

 

Ya'll keep doing Enrique dirrty like this :(...Be With You is one of his best and now you all made me curious to see what was the peak in UK chart. Summer Love is also a very great JT track so it's a shame to see losing it already!!!

Wtf at 'Senorita' being JT's second-lowest song. :o

 

Surprised there's no Robbie in this batch!

  • Author

35 Usher - Confessions Pt. II avg. 6.84

 

Highest: 9 (Nina West, ...readyforit, Riser)

Lowest: 5 (Addy!, Bjork)

 

 

 

34 Robbie Williams - Tripping avg. 7

 

Highest: 9 (Jester, Addy!, Iceman501)

Lowest: 4.5 (NickF1)

 

 

 

33 Usher - Pop Ya Collar avg. 7.11

 

Highest: 9.5 (Riser)

Lowest: 5 (Scene, Bjork, NickF1, Chez Wombat)

 

 

 

32 Usher - My Boo avg. 7.11

 

Highest: 10 (Bjork)

Lowest: 4 (Chez Wombat, dandy*)

 

 

 

31 Robbie Williams - Eternity avg. 7.26

 

Highest: 10 (Jester, Bjork)

Lowest: 5 (Scene, Nina West, dandy*)

 

 

this round is all about Usher V Robbie since only both of them appear in this list. Usher takes the biggest toll losing three tracks while Robbie loses two. Robbie's Tripping was a nice change of direction to his music but often he's been criticized for it!!!

Gutted I missed voting in this.

 

'Do You Know' would have been an 11 for me. WHAT A SONG! :wub:

  • Author

30 Eminem - Sing For The Moment avg. 7.38

 

Highest: 10 (NickF1)

Lowest: 5 (gavindeejay, Doug)

 

 

 

29 Enrique Iglesias - Could I Have This Kiss Forever avg. 7.42

 

Highest: 10 (Addy!, Bjork, Riser)

Lowest: 4 (Iceman501)

 

 

 

28 Usher - U Remind Me avg. 7.53

 

Highest: 10 (Jester, Addy!)

Lowest: 4 (Chez Wombat)

 

 

 

27 Robbie Williams - Supreme avg. 7.57

 

Highest: 10 (Addy!, NickF1)

Lowest: 5 (Scene, ...readyforit, Chez Wombat)

 

 

 

26 Usher - U Got It Bad avg. 7.57

 

Highest: 11 (Scene)

Lowest: 3 (Chez Wombat)

 

 

We start Top 30 with Eminem 'Sing For The Moment'. We also get a little bit of everyone with exception Justin T. Usher losing what I can say one of his best tracks 'U Got It Bad' is not something I agree, thought at least it deserves Top 20!!!

  • Author

25 Usher - Caught Up avg. 7.76

 

Highest: 10 (NickF1, Riser)

Lowest: 5 (Jester)

 

 

 

24 Robbie Williams - Somethin' Stupid avg. 7.84

 

Highest: 10 (Jester, Scene, Nina West)

Lowest: 5.5 (dandy*)

 

 

 

23 Robbie Williams - Kids avg. 7.92

 

Highest: 11 (Doug)

Lowest: 5 (...readyforit)

 

 

 

22 Enrique Iglesias - Not In Love avg. 7.96

 

Highest: 11 (NickF1)

Lowest: 3 (Iceman501)

 

 

 

21 Enrique Iglesias - Escape avg. 8

 

Highest: 11 (Jester, Nina West, Addy!, gavindeejay)

Lowest: 6 (...readyforit, Chez Wombat)

 

 

Justin and Eminem avoid this batch and once again proving how popular they're here!!! And both of those Enrique tracks deserved better :snif:

  • Author

And for Top 20 we have left following:

 

Eminem - Cleaning Out My Closet

Eminem - Like Toy Soldier

Eminem - Lose Yourself

Eminem - Stan

Eminem - The Real Slim Shady

Eminem - Without Me

 

Enrique Iglesias - Bailamos

Enrique Iglesias - Hero

Enrique Iglesias - Takin' Back My Love

 

Justin Timberlake - Cry Me A River

Justin Timberlake - Like I Love You

Justin Timberlake - LoveStoned

Justin Timberlake - My Love

Justin Timberlake - Rock Your Body

Justin Timberlake - SexyBack

Justin Timberlake - What Goes Around...Come Around

 

Robbie Williams - Feel

Robbie Williams - Rock DJ

 

Usher - Burn

Usher - Yeah!

 

 

I would have replaced few of Justin's and Eminem for some Enrique/Usher and Robbie's Supreme!!!

Not surprised that JT has the most songs remaining, but quite surprised that Eminem has the second-most!
  • Author

20 Usher - Burn avg. 8.03

 

Highest: 10 (Nina West, Doug)

Lowest: 5 (Bjork)

 

 

 

19 Eminem - Cleanin' Out My Closet avg. 8.03

 

Highest: 10 (NickF1, dandy*)

Lowest: 6 (Jester, Chez Wombat)

 

 

Top 20 starts with Ushers 'Burn' taken from his most successful album 'Confessions'. He has only one song left in this rate, his biggest hit 'Yeah' taken from the same album. Will that disappear soon as well, we will find out sooner or later ;). At #19 we have one of more serious Eminems track 'Cleanin' Out My Closet' inspired by his abusive childhood. He raps and vents his anger towards his mother. I always wondered what his mother had to say about it when she heard the song?

  • Author

18 Enrique Iglesias - Bailamos avg. 8.30

 

Highest: 11 (Doug)

Lowest: 5 (dandy*)

 

 

 

17 Justin Timberlake - Rock Your Body avg. 8.34

 

Highest: 10 (Scene, Nina West, Chez Wombat, Iceman501)

Lowest: 6 (...readyforit)

 

 

At #18 we lose another Enrique song 'Bailamos' and the one that it all started for him internationally and rose him to worldwide fame. #17 we find Justins 'Rock Your Body' but nothing to complain about it since he still has another six songs left in this countdown. I don't even think it deserved to be this high to be quiet frankly considering we lost so many better and memorable songs from other artists already, but oh well!!!

My preferred order would be:

 

Justin Timberlake - My Love

Enrique Iglesias - Takin' Back My Love

Justin Timberlake - SexyBack

Justin Timberlake - Cry Me A River

Usher - Burn

Eminem - Cleaning Out My Closet

Eminem - Stan

Usher - Yeah!

Justin Timberlake - What Goes Around...Come Around

Justin Timberlake - LoveStoned

Enrique Iglesias - Hero

Eminem - Lose Yourself

Eminem - Like Toy Soldier

Justin Timberlake - Like I Love You

Enrique Iglesias - Bailamos

Robbie Williams - Rock DJ

Robbie Williams - Feel

Justin Timberlake - Rock Your Body

Eminem - Without Me

Eminem - The Real Slim Shady

the best 3 songs left are Stan, Cry me a river and Feel

Some horrible Eminemsongs still in it's sad to see :/

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.