Just trying something out on here with a little pioll on the Double Shantay's of RuPaul's Drag Race. I'm only including the ones from the American season (not Allstars). There have been 14 double shantay's on this season alone. First started on Season 3 and even included the most recent Season 14.

But who do you guys think really won these lipsyncs, just choose from the polls above?

Carmen Carrera vs Yara Sofia - Hey Mickey (Spanish Version) (Season 3)
Phi Phi O'Hara vs Sharon Needles - It's Raining Men (The Sequel) (Season 4)
Alyssa Edwards vs Roxxxy Andrews - Whip My Hair (Season 5)
BenDeLaCreme vs Darienne Lake - Point of No Return (Season 6)
Cynthia Lee Fontaine vs Farrah Moan - Woman Up (Season 9)
Eureka vs Kameron Michaels - New Attitude (Season 10)
Eureka vs Aquaria - If (Season 10)
Brooke Lynn Hytes vs Yvie Oddly - Sorry Not Sorry (Season 11)
Heidi N' Closet vs Jackie Cox - Kill The Lights (Season 12)
Kandy Muse vs Symone - Boss (Season 13)
Jasmine Kennedie vs Jorgeous - Something's Got A Hold On Me (Season 14)

Carmen Carrera vs Yara Sofia - Hey Mickey (Spanish Version) (Season 3) - Interesting that the 2 Queens that spoke Spanish were in the bottom. Carmen clearly won by literally going to the judges table and stealing focus, Yara pulls out a flag and it wasn't even on camera.

Phi Phi O'Hara vs Sharon Needles - It's Raining Men (The Sequel) (Season 4) - This was a really good lip-sync & I know it was only a double save due to Willam's disqualification. They both had very different approaches to this song, Phi Phi was dancing manically everywhere & Sharon was delivering more attitude & maybe fit the tone of the song better, but the moment Phi Phi would have lost out is when her wig came off.

Alyssa Edwards vs Roxxxy Andrews - Whip My Hair (Season 5) - One of the most iconic lipsyncs of all-time, so this was a tough one as both Roxxxy and Alyssa delivered the goods. Roxxy perhaps edges out in front due to her doing the first ever wig reveal, which was a GAG moment. But Alyssa totally owns the 2nd half of the lipsync & both deserved to stay.

BenDeLaCreme vs Darienne Lake - Point of No Return (Season 6) - Darienne totally won this, Dela did well but she couldn't keep up with Darienne. But track record wise it made sense for Dela to stay as she had 2 wins by this point & this was Darienne's 2nd time in the bottom.

Cynthia Lee Fontaine vs Farrah Moan - Woman Up (Season 9) - Think we all know the only reason this was a double save was due to Eureka's injury as this is one of the worst lipsyncs of all-time. For a start the song was terrible by the infamous awful Mega Train Wreck. However I'd give the win to Farrah as she gave a very pop princess type performance while Cynthia was all over the place & that awful black bra & red panties wasn't cute.

Eureka vs Kameron Michaels - New Attitude (Season 10) - This was a fantastic lipsync, but Kameron won this, doing a lot more & used the stage really well.

Eureka vs Aquaria - If (Season 10) - The 2nd double save involving Eureka (interesting), but this time she clearly won this as Aquaria was way too erratic & actually fell during her performance which was edited out & plus if she went then the final 2 would have been Eureka vs Kameron (again), with the winner being totally obvious as Kameron just didn't have a good enough track record to win.

Brooke Lynn Hytes vs Yvie Oddly - Sorry Not Sorry (Season 11) - This was a hard one to pick as both were amazing. ONE OF THE GREATEST LIPSYNCS OF ALL-TIME.

Heidi N' Closet vs Jackie Cox - Kill The Lights (Season 12) - Heidi totally killed this, Jackie was very off-putting, didn't like her take on this at all.

Kandy Muse vs Symone - Boss - Despite what you think of Kandy, but season 13 would have been boring if she went as this point, even if she did lose to the almighty force that is Symone. (Season 13)

Jasmine Kennedie vs Jorgeous - Something's Got A Hold On Me (Season 14) - This was a good lipsync by the 2 undisputed assassings of this current season, both totally delivered.

Edited March 29, 20223 yr by Nina West

Carmen Carrera vs Yara Sofia - Hey Mickey (Spanish Version) (Season 3)

 

Phi Phi O'Hara ]vs Sharon Needles - It's Raining Men (The Sequel) (Season 4)

 

Alyssa Edwards vs Roxxxy Andrews - Whip My Hair (Season 5)

 

BenDeLaCreme vs Darienne Lake - Point of No Return (Season 6) - Darienne shoud have been sent home the week before tbh but she clearly won this

 

Cynthia Lee Fontaine vs Farrah Moan - Woman Up (Season 9) - honestly this was closer to a double sashay but Farrah won for sure

 

Eureka vs Kameron Michaels - New Attitude (Season 10) - one of the closest for me, but I'd go Kameron

 

Eureka vs Aquaria - If (Season 10) - they handed Aquaria the season win here, I mean she had to win the season but she flat out lost this lipsync and it wasn't even close

 

Brooke Lynn Hytes vs Yvie Oddly - Sorry Not Sorry (Season 11) - If I had to choose one that is a REAL double shantay where I genuinely can't choose who won, it would be this

 

Heidi N' Closet vs Jackie Cox - Kill The Lights (Season 12)

 

Kandy Muse vs Symone - Boss (Season 13) - I don't consider this a double shantay tbh, rather just pure riggory for Kandy Muse tbh, like Ru even said she lost the lipsync

 

Jasmine Kennedie vs Jorgeous - Something's Got A Hold On Me (Season 14)

Surprised how split some of these are! Especially some that I think are kinda definitive e.g. Dela vs Darienne

This is how I'd rank them =

1. Yvie Oddly vs Brooke Lynn Hytes – Sorry Not Sorry
2. Alyssa Edwards vs Roxxy Andrews – Whip My Hair
3. Kameron Michaels vs Eureka – New Attitude
4. Jasmine Kennedie vs Jorgeous – Something’s Got a Hold on Me
5. Phi, Phi O’Hara vs Sharon Needles – It’s Raining Men (The Sequel)
6. BenDeLaCreme vs Darienne Lake – Point of No Return
7. Heidi N’ Closet vs Jackie Cox – Kill The Lights
8. Kandy Muse vs Symone - Boss
9. Carmen Carrera vs Yara Sofia – Hey Mickey
10. Aquaria vs Eureka - If
11. Cynthia Lee Fontaine vs Farrah Moan – Woman Up

yvie vs. brooke is TRULY impossible to judge !