Jump to content

Featured Replies

Posted

Now that Taylor owns all her albums, we can take our pick as to which version of the songs you prefer! I've been going through and listening to each song back to back and putting my preferred version in my playlist, so I thought i'd do it as a 1v1 of each song to see which one you prefer!

  1. Mine vs Mine (Taylor's Version)

  2. Sparks Fly vs Sparks Fly (Taylor's Version)

  3. Back To December vs Back To December (Taylor's Version)

  4. Speak Now vs Speak Now (Taylor's Version)

  5. Dear John vs Dear John (Taylor's Version)

  6. Mean vs Mean (Taylor's Version)

  7. The Story Of Us vs The Story Of Us (Taylor's Version)

  8. Never Grow Up vs Never Grow Up (Taylor's Version)

  9. Enchanted vs Enchanted (Taylor's Version)

  10. Better Than Revenge vs Better Than Revenge (Taylor's Version)

  11. Innocent vs Innocent (Taylor's Version)

  12. Haunted vs Haunted (Taylor's Version)

  13. Last Kiss vs Last Kiss (Taylor's Version)

  14. Long Live vs Long Live (Taylor's Version)

  1. Ours vs Ours (Taylor's Version)

  2. Superman vs Superman (Taylor's Version)

  1. If This Was A Movie vs If This Was A Movie (Taylor's Version)

just copy the list into a reply and bold your preference, or just delete the one you like less!

  • Replies 2
  • Views 157
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

  • Author
  1. Mine vs Mine (Taylor's Version)

  2. Sparks Fly vs Sparks Fly (Taylor's Version)

  3. Back To December vs Back To December (Taylor's Version)

  4. Speak Now vs Speak Now (Taylor's Version)

  5. Dear John vs Dear John (Taylor's Version)

  6. Mean vs Mean (Taylor's Version)

  7. The Story Of Us vs The Story Of Us (Taylor's Version)

  8. Never Grow Up vs Never Grow Up (Taylor's Version)

  9. Enchanted vs Enchanted (Taylor's Version)

  10. Better Than Revenge vs Better Than Revenge (Taylor's Version)

  11. Innocent vs Innocent (Taylor's Version)

  12. Haunted vs Haunted (Taylor's Version)

  13. Last Kiss vs Last Kiss (Taylor's Version)

  14. Long Live vs Long Live (Taylor's Version)

  1. Ours vs Ours (Taylor's Version)

  2. Superman vs Superman (Taylor's Version)

  1. If This Was A Movie vs If This Was A Movie (Taylor's Version)

speak now is more of a mixed bag, several songs were definitely improved by the taylor's version, but some the new version didn't have the same emotion to it. Dear John was one i just couldn't pick, both versions are special in their own way, the original shows how she felt in the moment, while tv is her looking back at it from a now perspective, and i just couldn't decide!

  • 2 weeks later...
  1. Mine (Taylor's Version)

  2. Sparks Fly (Taylor's Version)

  3. Back To December

  4. Speak Now (Taylor's Version)

  5. Dear John

  6. Mean (Taylor's Version)

  7. The Story Of Us (Taylor's Version)

  8. Never Grow Up

  9. Enchanted (Taylor's Version)

  10. Better Than Revenge

  11. Innocent

  12. Haunted (Taylor's Version)

  13. Last Kiss

  14. Long Live (Taylor's Version)

  15. Ours (Taylor's Version)

  16. Superman (Taylor's Version)

  17. If This Was A Movie (Taylor's Version)

6 vs 11 for Taylor's Version

This was a lot more "even playing field" rather than me much preferring one version over the other. However, the Reclaimed Versions that work the most here are the more personal ones. But yeah I can take or leave both versions as I don't think they're too dissimilar to each other and again, I think TV wins just because her voice is much more mature/refined to the country/pop-rock sound.

It's going to be interesting listening to both versions of 1989 back to back for me. I feel like straight forward pop will be a bit more divisive. But we'll see! Also TV's of 'Enchanted', 'Haunted', 'Long Live' and 'Superman' are just... WHEW!

cheeseblock

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.