Mariah’s Christmases are not coming early. Nonetheless it’s a better result for this than in its previous outing in the #99 survivor when it only finished 8th. She may yet appear again.

5th: Mariah Carey - All I Want For Christmas Is You 14/30 votes

6th: All American Rejects - Gives You Hell 16/35 votes (46%)

7th: Goldtrix - It’s Love (Trippin’) 16/33 votes (48%)

8th: Hear’Say - Everybody 16/30 votes (53%)

9th: Wyclef Jean featuring The Rock and Melky Sedeck - It Doesn’t Matter 9/29 votes (31%)

10th: Jennifer Lopez featuring Fat Joe - Hold You Down 12/32 votes (38%)

Going for “Irreplacable” now

Probably Snow Patrol - I like all four of these (but love Nelly and Beyoncé).

Strong top 4 for me

Going with Beyonce

Gone for Nelly this time.

Gone for Avril Lavigne. It’s fine but I think the other three are better

On 08/07/2025 at 09:29, awardinary said:

  On 04/07/2025 at 10:06, awardinary said:

Beyoyo

Gone for Nelly Furtado this time.

Beyoncé now but very strong final 4!

Beyoncé

Nelly is my winner here but felt like a coin toss between the other 3 (I do like all of them), voted for Avril.