Jump to content

Featured Replies

Posted

With this headline cropping up today regarding the BBC heavily editing (and removing) episodes of Horrible Histories from iPlayer in light of some of the content being deemed unsuitable, it's reignited something inside me that's been really sad and disappointed for quite a while now that it feels like we're slowly heading down a path of media being erased from existence whenever some loud voices decide they're not happy with it or that it offends them.

Other examples (primarily looking at the BBC alone):

  • Huw Edwards being edited out of an episode of Doctor Who (meaning the episode was removed from iPlayer for some time before being added again)

  • An episode of Still Game being removed completely from BBC iPlayer after a guest actor in the episode was convicted of sexual assault

  • Sketches within episodes of That Mitchell and Webb Look being removed, with the BBC citing they 'don't work'

  • Sketches within episodes of Little Britain being removed

  • An episode of The Sarah Jane Adventures was withheld and edited before being added to BBC iPlayer due to cultural inaccuracies (despite the fiction of it all)

The BBC in particular seem to be a prime example of a business that are very reactionary, and only really sit up and take notice of things when it might look bad if they do nothing, or simply to appease some people. But where do we draw the line at making edits to TV shows, films, and other forms of media when you're never going to be able to please everybody, or there's always going to be somebody, somewhere that will find something that they don't like?

I say this as a fan of the show too (and being able to appreciate it as something that is very much of its time and could absolutely not be made today), but the fact that Gimme Gimme Gimme is still available in its entirety on BBC iPlayer, yet edits are made to other shows or episodes are removed completely purely because something happens or something is said to trigger it, really baffles me. Let's pat ourselves on the back for responding to concerns about x or y, but let's not actually do a deep dive into our catalogue on iPlayer and take the time to look at what might be perceived in 2026 as inappropriate...

What happens to Series 2 (and some of Series 1) of Doctor Who if anything further happens with Noel Clarke following allegations/charges brought against him? Will there be any consistency from the BBC?

Are there any other examples of this that people are aware of? Do you agree with decisions to heavily edit/remove media when it's deemed offensive or there are certain parts of it or people in them that are deemed inappropriate/have the potential cause upset?

  • Replies 1
  • Views 58
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

They could put an warning to say that it contains scenes and language of its time before the start of the programme.

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.