Jump to content

AF Idol 11-40 peak what should we send 43 members have voted

  1. 1. Please vote for your favourite

    • Talk that Talk
      8
    • All Of The Lights
      11
    • Can?t Remember To Forget You
      9
    • Bitch Better Have My Money
      10
    • Needed Me
      5

Please sign in or register to vote in this poll.

Featured Replies

Posted

A few options for this poll!

 

Rehab unfortunately has already been sent or that would’ve been sent!

 

But these were either rated highest on the last rate or have been released since the last rate.

 

Discuss!

Edited by Gerald

  • Replies 24
  • Views 2.5k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Personal Preference:

1. Talk That Talk

2. Bitch Better Have My Money

3. Can’t Remember To Forget You

4. All Of The Lights

5. Needed Me (still great)

 

Would do well in AFSC:

1. Talk That Talk (honestly think this I swear!)

2. Can’t Remember To Forget You

3. All Of The Lights

4. Bitch Better Have My Money

5. Needed Me

 

I can see the top 3 in my second list getting through, BBHMM would possibly be out and Needed Me even against a Mel C song that isn't hugely popular with her fanbase would even more so, although I'd say Bitch would probably stay.

Wait, Cheers (Drink to That) not even in contention? :o I thought that would be solid pick!

 

I don't have huge confidence in any song in the poll, honestly. Maybe Can't Remember to Forget You for the pop hoes. Bitch Better Have My Money is my favourite song but that could be very divisive.

Wait, Cheers (Drink to That) not even in contention? :o I thought that would be solid pick!

 

I don't have huge confidence in any song in the poll, honestly. Maybe Can't Remember to Forget You for the pop hoes. Bitch Better Have My Money is my favourite song but that could be very divisive.

I actually am surprised people aren't suggesting it but it didn't do particularly well in the last singles rate (although it wasn't far off BBHMM) and it's not a particularly remembered hit. I'm not complaining as I've never liked it :kink: After your post I listened again and I can only think of 4, maybe 5 songs in her whole discography that are worse imo, including album tracks oops

 

Yas at the BBHMM stanning *.*

BBHMM is my favourite but I voted AOTL coz I feel that's safer.
Surprised that 'Can’t Remember To Forget You' is leading - I thought that was regarded as a disappointing big name collab on the site!
After your post I listened again and I can only think of 4, maybe 5 songs in her whole discography that are worse imo, including album tracks oops

Oh wow...! It's not one of her very best singles, but in the context of her discography as a whole I'm sure I'd consider it mid-table at worst! Sounds perfect in the summer too. I certainly think it's better than some of the songs in this poll.

 

Kind of surprised Te Amo isn't in the mix too, love that one!

Oh wow...! It's not one of her very best singles, but in the context of her discography as a whole I'm sure I'd consider it mid-table at worst! Sounds perfect in the summer too. I certainly think it's better than some of the songs in this poll.

 

Kind of surprised Te Amo isn't in the mix too, love that one!

Tbf part of my annoyance comes from the fact they released it as a single instead of 'Skin' :kink: IMAGINE THE VIDEO :cheeseblock:

 

Unfaithful would easily be in my bottom 10 as well so it's not even my most unpopular Rih opinion :ph34r:

Edited by Andrew.

I am more worried than ever for us this round, help Rih out guys :'( I don't think we have any chance of beating Gaga or probably Madonna, so whether we're top 3 or not depends on the Spice choice.

 

The more I think about it (I wanna smash into pieces), I do wonder if despite the poll, it might be a risk that pays off to go for AOTL or even BBHMM. I assume you can only vote for two forums this round and posters who won't vote for a hip-hop song will already be going to Gaga/Madonna/Spice Girls, and more importantly as much as I love them I don't think CRTFY or maybe TTT would stand out amongst the other pop songs. I think TTT would more. AOTL/BBHMM would stand out amongst the crowd and the vast majority of the who like hip-hop/trap would go for it. Am I making ANY sense here x

 

 

  • Author

To reply to you Jay* Te Amo wasn’t in the mix as in the Rated R survivor poll it’s been getting some shade and that’s in the early rounds.

 

I really feel like All Of The Lights is the best choice

The more I think about it (I wanna smash into pieces)

 

! :melaniec: impact!

 

I do wonder if despite the poll, it might be a risk that pays off to go for AOTL or even BBHMM. I assume you can only vote for two forums this round and posters who won't vote for a hip-hop song will already be going to Gaga/Madonna/Spice Girls, and more importantly as much as I love them I don't think CRTFY or maybe TTT would stand out amongst the other pop songs. I think TTT would more. AOTL/BBHMM would stand out amongst the crowd and the vast majority of the who like hip-hop/trap would go for it. Am I making ANY sense here x

Bitch Better Have My Money, please *.* So much more interesting than AOTL. I still think CRTFY would hold its own though.

 

To reply to you Jay* Te Amo wasn’t in the mix as in the Rated R survivor poll it’s been getting some shade and that’s in the early rounds.

Who are these tasteless people :melb:

Surprised that 'Can’t Remember To Forget You' is leading - I thought that was regarded as a disappointing big name collab on the site!
Britney & Madonna teas!

 

LEARN RIRIRI FORUM

 

L E A R N

I don't like living in a world where Can't Remember to Forget You is considered disappointing :cry: That chorus pops off a bit!
I don't know if 'All Of The Lights' should even count as a Rihanna song, but it's my favourite song here by far!
Britney & Madonna teas!

 

LEARN RIRIRI FORUM

 

L E A R N

I don't like living in a world where Can't Remember to Forget You is considered disappointing :cry: That chorus pops off a bit!

Okay I'm now terrified x

 

Sorry for spamming this thread lmao but presuming the choices are Marry The Night, Loving You and one of Oh Father/Living For Love, I think even more it'd be very beneficial to go for AOTL or BBHMM. I listened to the Matt Cardle song and found it okay, quite mor but it got a higher average in the rate it was in than any of these songs. I can see Loving You appealing to those who don't usually like the pure pop choices (aka the straights x) and it'll have those votes as well as the Spice stans. Basically I think AOTL or Bitch would be able to appeal to those people and the people on here who love it, while I just don't see many including CRTFY in their votes over Gaga or Madge. It won't stand out as a pop song, while ATOL/Bitch would stand out. I feel like I'm repeating myself a bit but I don't think I made my point well last time oop.

 

I know Bitch would be divisive, but I recall that whenever it pops up in rates it always gets loads of high scores - it's dragged down in the average by some very low scores but it only matters how many people like it here.

 

Feel free to take no notice of what I say though I'm procrastinating from work :') What are you thinking mods?

CRTFY really didn't cry out for me for this round. I think it should be avoided, in all honesty.

 

I'd actually say you're safer going with Te Amo tbh :')

 

I won't vote for it, but it has it's fans and is at least a recognisable hit Rihanna song.

CRTFY really didn't cry out for me for this round. I think it should be avoided, in all honesty.

 

I'd actually say you're safer going with Te Amo tbh :')

 

I won't vote for it, but it has it's fans and is at least a recognisable hit Rihanna song.

I see your point and it could survive, but your reason for sending Te Amo would be mine for sending Bitch. I feel like it has more fans, just more haters but that doesn't matter so much. Te Amo, at least from what I've seen is mostly regarded as meh while Bitch is marmite, most people either love it or dislike it.

 

I'm an indecisive bitch though so *shrug* x

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.