Jump to content

Featured Replies

  • Author

Full Rate Results

 

01 Kelly Clarkson (9.32)

02 Leona Lewis (8.80)

03 Girls Aloud (8.60)

04 Alexandra Burke (8.02)

05 Will Young (8.00)

06 Liberty X (7.54)

07 Lemar (7.12)

08 Jordin Sparks (7.06)

09 Jennifer Hudson (6.86)

10 Shayne Ward (6.70)

 

11 Diana Vickers (6.04)

12 Carrie Underwood (5.98)

13 Joe McElderry (5.34)

14 Maria Lawson (5.30)

15 Laura White (5.20)

16 Hear'Say (5.00)

17 JLS (4.98)

18 Adam Lambert (4.96)

19 Zoe Birkett (4.90)

20 Susan Boyle (4.58)

 

21 Javine (4.52)

22 Gareth Gates (4.50)

23 Sinead Quinn (4.38)

24 Phixx (4.32)

25 Daughtry (4.22)

26 Jessica Garlick (4.22)

27 Sarah Whatmore (4.18)

28 Same Difference (3.94)

29 Alex Parks (3.88)

30 Michelle McManus (3.80)

 

31 Darius (3.78)

32 Clea (3.68)

33 Rosie Ribbons (3.48)

34 Rhydian Roberts (3.42)

35 Danity Kane (3.40)

36 David Archuleta (3.40)

37 Cheeky Girls (3.38)

38 David Cook (3.34)

39 David Sneddon (3.16)

40 O-Town (3.04)

 

41 Escala (2.92)

42 Leon Jackson (2.78)

43 G4 (2.72)

44 Girlicious (2.70)

45 Journey South (2.54)

46 Ainslie Henderson (2.46)

47 Alistair Griffin (2.38)

48 Ben Mills (2.12)

49 Paul Potts (2.08)

50 One True Voice (1.96)

 

51 James Fox (1.84)

52 Ray Quinn (1.48)

53 Andy Abraham (1.48)

54 Connie Talbot (1.32)

55 Sam & Mark (1.28)

56 Chico (1.20)

57 Jedward (1.12)

58 Steve Brookstein (1.12)

59 George Sampson (1.08)

60 MacDonald Brothers (0.70)

61 Eoghan Quigg (0.60)

  • Replies 151
  • Views 6.1k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Had I have got around to voting I would have given these

 

GA 11

Leona 4

Kelly 3

She may be a good singer but her material isn't as good as GAs.

No you're completely correct, it pisses over GA's

My comments on the Top 7 (where I last left off):

 

01 Kelly Clarkson (9.32) AMAZING! Since I saw her live in February, she has overtaken Britney to become my most favourite artist EVER! Admittedly I didn't like her 'Thankful' era, but luckily she was given the absoloutely amazing 'Since U Been Gone' and things turned around, drastically. 'Breakaway' is my all time favourite album. Glad she managed to beat the heavyweights Leona and Girls Aloud!

02 Leona Lewis (8.80) Definately my second favourite and a very deserving number 2 position

03 Girls Aloud (8.60) Awesome girl group. Although I'm very glad they weren't number 1 (as I would have predicted!)

04 Alexandra Burke (8.02) Has a hell of alot of potential, JLs maybe more successful "sales" wise, but she'll last longer.

05 Will Young (8.00) ERGH! He's had Two or Three amazing songs. All the rest are awful

06 Liberty X (7.54) Liberty X were a good group. I hate 'Just A Little' now though, so overplayed and bleh. 'Song 4 Lovers' remains an underrated classic!

07 Lemar (7.12) Earlier i said I wanted Shayne to be top male, I now retract that statement and apply it to Lemar. His material has always been very good (bar the meh 'Dance With U'. Very deserving of a top 10 position :)

 

Great results in the end in all honesty. Thanks so much for taking the time out to compile and organise this Jack. :D It's been a rather great countdown in all honesty!

Alexandra being so high is faintly ridiculous. Yeah she was fine on the X Factor, but other than that she's simply got one rather mediocre album behind her.

 

I'd have certainly placed her below the likes of Will Young and even Lemar.

Lemar has done quite well for himself and has lasted a long time, shame his current greatest hits album and his last studio album didnt do so well but he has the potential to be a good seller aswell.Hopefully a good strong song will get album sales going again.

Great top 3 although I would have swapped Leona and GA around.

 

Alexandra shouldnt have been so high imo even though I really like her, Will Young is probably deserving of the top 5 position.

 

Liberty X were a brilliant band imo, some great singles! shame 'X' didn't do so well.

Thanks for dooing the list, really good effort.Glad the best singers placed so high.Kelly Clarkson has far better songs than GA her singing voice alone is immense.Pleased for Alex Overcome is a really good debut album.

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.