Jump to content

X-Factor Chart Thread (I)

britster
in UK Charts

Featured Replies

Joe will best Pixie I think- although it depends on the material really, if its a cheesy love song that just sounds recycled, I think it will not be a cert for number 1- I do get a Leon Jackson vibe off him tbh and I dont think his career will be very long

Edited by chart wizard

  • Replies 993
  • Views 71.1k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Popular Days

That's a bit ridiculous considering you have no idea what Joe's single will be like. :huh:

 

It's less ridiculous than saying it will definitely be #1 when you have no idea what it'll be like.

Stop Crying Your Heart Out at #40 today. Obvi wont stay for whole week but how great is that, one small play on X Factor and its shot back up. :)
I don't really understand your post ... How would it be "unfair" to Joe ?

 

I do not in anyway mean that Joe deserves to get to No 1 but in the grand scheme of things if he performs on the same night as Robbie and Gary the attention and spotlight will be solely on them.Joe may have a good voice but he lacks charisma and any real star quality.It would be a shame if so early on he is an also ran like Leon.

Its more likely that Pixie Lott will get the live show performance with Joe as she releases the same week.Her song is really good but it is a ballad and she is not at her strongest singing them live.
Well Rob&Gary could do the trick but it is almost impossible Pixie will. I know we don't know the quality of Joe's single but in this case it DOES NOT matter. His first week sales are bound to be very strong and frontloaded as with every XF winner. Will he do a bleeding love score? Definitely not! Something like bad boys? Not much likely but who knows... Anyway with strong sales of 80-120k I doubt Pixie could be any competition to him. Honestly I am not blown away by Joe's voice. It sounds to me a bit like out of tune opera sometimes and his intonation is... annoying but that's just my opinion I guess. After the peak of XF with Leona people may expect more from the show than what is really possible. I doubt there are going to be anymore winners with international success, great album sales and songs toping US charts. I have nothing against Joe, if his song is better than Pixie's fair play to him but this is still 'a little' subjective.

Some of the tracks performed (i.e not background) on tomorrow's show

 

 

 

Fight For This Love - really crap/funny audition

Fight For This Love - good arrangement by a boygroup

I Who Have Nothing - really big audition like SuBo

Proud Mary

Wham Wake Me Up

Pixie Lott Cry Me Out

Lady Gaga Just Dance.

 

 

Edited by spkx

Is

Fight For This Love really crap/funny audition the song performed by the girls who were fighting?

 

 

 

And you say the other 'Fight For This Love' is performed by a boygroup? :naughty: :rofl:

 

Edited by Klumzee

No, it's performed by a real good looking bloke! He's a model but has a voice worse than cheryl's!

Songs Performed

61. Empire State of Mind (Part II) Broken Down - Alicia Keys

65. Bad Romance - Lady GaGa

117. Fight for This Love - Cheryl Cole

137. Empire State of Mind (feat. Alicia Keys) - Jay-Z

148. I (Who Have Nothing) - Tom Jones

226. Just Dance - Lady GaGa & Colby O'Donis

236. Cry Me Out - Pixie Lott

260. Empire State of Mind - Jay-Z & Alicia Keys

277. Bad Romance - Lady GaGa

515. You Know I'm No Good - Amy Winehouse

716. Just Dance - Lady GaGa & Colby O'Donis

731. Make You Feel My Love - ADELE

992. Beautiful Disaster (Live) - Kelly Clarkson

 

'I Like It' was again played in the background this week. It might climb a little like last week.

 

'Broken-Hearted Girl' and 'I'm Yours' were just performed on The Xtra Factor.

Empire state of mind highest is surprising- it was performed badly for about 5 seconds! :lol:

 

I think none will make much of an impact

Also,

Katy Perry - Hot N Cold #78

Tom Jones - I (Who Have Nothing) #87

Cheryl Cole - Fight For This Love #97

 

Gaga's nearly been in the top 75 for a year haha!

Cheryl cole has shocked me on how high it is.

Glad Pixie lot has went up 50places.

Performed on X Factor

[731] 23. Make You Feel My Love - ADELE :up:

[61] 61. Empire State of Mind (Part II) Broken Down - Alicia Keys :left:

[65] 63. Bad Romance - Lady GaGa :up:

[148] 82. I (Who Have Nothing) - Tom Jones :up:

[117] 93. Fight for This Love - Cheryl Cole :up:

[137] 139. Empire State of Mind (feat. Alicia Keys) - Jay-Z :down:

[515] 154. You Know I'm No Good - Amy Winehouse :up:

[226] 230. Just Dance - Lady GaGa & Colby O'Donis :down:

[236] 234. Cry Me Out - Pixie Lott :up:

[***] 246. Make You Feel My Love - ADELE :ne:

[260] 259. Empire State of Mind - Jay-Z & Alicia Keys :up:

[277] 269. Bad Romance - Lady GaGa :up:

[***] 381. Make You Feel My Love (Live At Hotel Cafe) - ADELE :ne:

[***] 396. Forever Is Over (Radio Edit) - The Saturdays :ne:

[***] 567. Make You Feel My Love - Adele :ne:

[716] 633. Just Dance - Lady GaGa & Colby O'Donis :up:

[992] 792. Beautiful Disaster (Live) - Kelly Clarkson :up:

[***] 828. Fight for This Love - Cheryl Cole :ne:

[***] 890. Proud Mary - Tina Turner :ne:

[***] 837. Forever Is Over (Radio Edit) - The Saturdays :ne:

 

Performed on Xtra Factor

51. Don't Stop Believin' - Journey

85. I'm Yours - Jason Mraz

135. Livin On a Prayer - Bon Jovi

378. Don't Stop Believin' - Journey

444. Mercy - Duffy

620. I'm Yours (Radio Edit) - Jason Mraz

715. So Sick - Ne-Yo

 

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
Go to topic listing

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.