Not that many stand-outs this year:

 

1 - Rebecca Ferguson by miles

2 - Cher Lloyd

3 - Mary Byrne

4 - TreyC Cohen

5 - Belle Amie

6 - Katie Waissel

 

Don't like any of the guys this year - Aiden was good earlier but I think he's had 2 weak performances

Edited October 28, 201014 yr by euro music

1 Cher Lloyd

2 John Adeleye

3 1Direction

4 Aiden Grimshaw

5 Storm Lee

6 F.Y.D

7 Nicolo Festa

8 Katie Waissel

9 Mary Byrne

10 Rebecca Ferguson

11 Belle Amie

12 Matt Cardle

01. Cher Lloyd / 03-04-09-05-01-

02. One Direction / 05-09-05-08-02-

03. Matt Cardle / 04-03-03-01-03-

04. Treyc Cohen / 02-04-04-04-

05. Mary Byrne / 08-05-06-09-05-

06. Aiden Grimshaw / 02-01-07-03-06-

07. Rebecca Ferguson / 07-07-02-02-07-

08. Katie Waissel / 12-13-13-06-08-

09. Paije Richardson / 06-08-10-09-

10. Belle Amie / 01-08-01-07-10-

11. Wagner / 16-14-12-11-

---

Nicolo Festa / 11-10-x

F.Y.D. / 09-12-x

Storm Lee / 10-14-11-

Diva Fever / 15-12-

John Adeleye / 06-11-10-11-

Week 4

 

01 Matt Cardle (1-1-)

02 Mary Byrne (3-2-)

03 Treyc Cohen (2-3-)

04 Cher Lloyd (8-4-)

05 Diva Fever (6-5-)

06 Belle Amie (7-6-)

07 Wagner (9-7-)

08 Rebecca Ferguson (5-8-)

09 Katie Waissel (4-9-)

10 Storm Lee (11-10-)

11 Paije Richardson (10-11-)

12 John Adeleye (12-12-)

13 One Direction (13-13-)

14 F.Y.D. (15-14-)

15 Nicolo Festa (16-15-)

16 Aiden Grimshaw (14-16-)

01 02 Cher

02 01 Matt

03 04 Wagner

04 03 Katie

05 06 Rebecca

06 05 One Direction

07 07 Aiden

08 08 Mary

09 11 Paije

10 09 Belle Amie

11 10 Treyc

Edited October 30, 201014 yr by chart wizard

One Direction (2-2-1-4-1)

Matt Cardle (6-8-4-3-2)

Rebecca Ferguson (5-5-3-1-3)

Cher Lloyd (1-1-5-6-4)

Aiden Grimshaw (4-4-2-2-5)

Mary Byrne (10-9-7-5-6)

Paije Richardson (10-11-9-7)

Belle Amie (3-3-6-7-8)

Katie Waissel (12-15-12-10-9)

TreyC Cohen (6-9-11-10)

Wagner (16-14-12-11)

 

F.Y.D (8-7)

Nicolo Festa (9-11)

Storm Lee (11-14-13)

Diva Fever (12-8)

John Adeleye (7-13-10-8)

THIS WEEKS

 

 

01. Cher Lloyd (8-6-12-10-1) :o

Av: 7

02. Mary Byrne (2-1-2-2-2)

Av: 2

03. Matt Cardle (1-2-1-3-3)

Av: 2

04. Rebecca Ferguson (5-12-8-6-4)

Av:7

05. Katie Waissel (11-8-3-1-5) *

Av: 6

06. Paije Richardson (X-10-7-5-6) *

Av: 7

07. One Direction (10-16-9-7-7)

Av: 10

08. Wagner (X-14-14-11-8)

Av: 12

09. Belle Amie (6-15-11-9-9)

Av:10

10. Treyc Cohen (X-9-6-8-10)

Av: 8

11. Aiden Grimshaw (12-5-13-12-11)

Av: 11

 

OUT

 

John Adelaye (4-7-4-4) Av: 5 out of 12

Diva Fever (X-11-10) Av: 11 out of 14

Storm Lee (7-4-5) Av: 6 out of 14

FYD (9-13) Av: 11 out of 16

Nicolo Festa (3-3) Av: 3 out of 16

1 - Rebecca Ferguson (1-1-2-1)

2 - Belle Amie (2-3-3-2)

3 - Cher Lloyd (9-4-9-3)

4 - Katie Waissel (5-2-1-4)

5 - Aiden Grimshaw (11-13-6-5)

6 - Wagner (8-6-7-6)

7 - Paije Richardson (3-7-4-7)

8 - Mary Byrne (4-5-5-8)

9 - Matt Cardle (6-8-10-9)

10 - Treyc Cohen (10-12-11-10)

11 - One Direction (16 [last] -14 [last] -12 [last] - 11 [last])

 

OUT

 

John Adeleye (12-9-8) :(

 

Belle Amie appearing in ANYONE's top two right now is quite frankly RIDICULOUS, especially after tonight. I can only assume it's the usual generic BJ obsession with anything with a vagina. There is simply no way in hell they have EVER been better than Matt, TreyC, Mary, Aiden or even One Direction.

many changes after Halloween night in my ranking :o

 

1. Cher

2. TrayC

3. Paije

4. Katie

5. Matt

6. Rebecca

7. Belle Ammie

8. One Direction

9. Mary

10. Aiden

11. Wagner

01 Cher (09-07-06-01)

02 Rebecca (01-01-03-02)

03 Katie (06-02-02-03)

04 Aiden (03-08-07-04)

05 TreyC (01-05-01-05)

06 Matt (07-04-05-06)

07 Mary (05-06-08-07)

08 One Direction (12-11-12-08)

09 Belle Amie (04-03-04-09)

10 Wagner (11-13-11-10)

11 Paije (08-12-09-11)

1. Rebecca (1-1-1-1-1-1-1)

2. Cher (2-5-3-3-3-3-3)

3. TreyC (2-2-2-2-2-2)

4. Mary (3-4-5-4-4-4-4)

5. One Direction (6-6-6-6-6-7-7)

6. Paije (8-8-7-5-5)

7. Matt (8-11-10-9-8-8-8)

8. Aiden (5-3-3-5-5-6-6)

9. Katie (11-13-13-12-10-11)

10. Wagner (12-11-11-9-9-10)

11. Belle Amie (7-14-12-13-11-10-9)

This week's ranking by me:

 

1. Aiden Grimshaw

2. Katie Waissel

3. Rebecca Ferguson

4. Cher Lloyd

5. Mary Byrne

6. One Direction

7. Treyc Cohen

8. Paije Richardson

9. Matt Cardle

10. Wagner

11. Belle Amie

---------LAST WEEK----------

Guilty pleasures.

 

1. Cher. (4-4-2-1) Simon was so right, it was like an artist coming back to promote their new album, awesome.

2. Matt. (3-3-3-2) Stipped, mellow, raw. Such an excellent intimate performer.

3. Katie. (9-8-5-3) GENIUS song choice, GENIUS performance. Everything about it was excellent, so pleased for her. Jungle Book. :heart:

4. Aiden. (5-1-4-4) Great performance again, would love to see something a bit more upbeat, something to invite us into his perfomance world.

5. Rebecca. (1-5-6-5) Much better, her best by far. Still waiting from a magic WOW moment from her though.

6. Mary. (2-2-1-6) The judges are right, great but now we need to see different dimensions to Mary.

7. One Direction. (15-7-7-7) Why don't I hate them? :mellow: I should but I actually really enjoy their performances. -_-

8. Wagner. (13-16-9-8) Still embracing the joke. :wub:

-- JOHN -- Not shocked he's gone. Still don't remember him. :mellow:

9. Belle Amie. (6-6-11-9) Stand By You? Really? That was their big "breakaway" moment. Oh DEAR girls.

10. Treyc. (10-9-8-10) I find her to be very self indulgent. -_-

11. Paije. (12-14-12-11) :zzz: sums it up.

 

OUT.

Nicolo (7-10-X)

FYD (11-12-X)

Storm Lee (16-13-14-X)

Diva Fever (5-11-8-X)

John (14-15-10-9-X)

 

(Numbers in bold = Last place)

 

Will update with new results after tonight... although I will see I REALLYYYYYYY want Treyc gone but i'd also settle for Paije going please. ^_^

Overall ranking after week 4:

 

01 (01) Rebecca Ferguson

02 (02) Matt Cardle

03 (03) Mary Byrne

04 (06) Cher Lloyd

05 (04) TreyC Cohen

06 (10) Paije Richardson

07 (07) Katie Waissel

08 (09) One Direction

09 (08) Aiden Grimshaw

10 (11) Wagner

 

OUT:

 

05 - Belle Amie

01 Cher Lloyd

02 Rebecca Ferguson

03 Katie Waissel

04 Paije Richardson

05 TreyC Cohen

06 Mary Byrne

07 Aiden Grimshaw

08 Matt Cardle

09 One Direction

10 Wagner

1. Cher. (4-4-2-1-1) Just STUNNING in so many ways. A breathtaking, forever memorable moment. Just bliss, I could watch/listen to that performance over and OVER. :wub:

2. Matt. (3-3-3-2-2) Great, consistant, solid. I think I may actually be in love with him. Whatever, loved the song. Loved the vulnerability.

3. Aiden. (5-1-4-4-3) Maybe wasn't the right thing to do with this song but I love that he makes his songs, his own. He needs to ignore the "oh your too intense" stuff because Cheryl wouldn't know a deep, honest, LIVE performer if it hit her in the face.

4. One Direction. (15-7-7-7-4) I say this every week but I don't get why I DON'T hate them. I'd never buy an album or anything but they are being given some FABULOUS/camp songs and i'm washed over with it all! ^_^

5. Mary. (2-2-1-6-5) I just... I dunno. I love her, and love the voice. And she is so grateful and humble with everything, but I just wouldn't pick up the phone for her. ALTHOUGH her rocking with Bon Jovi was immense. :wub:

6. Rebecca. (1-5-6-5-6) SO frustrating because I can just see there is magic waiting to happen with her with the right song but, it's just not quite there for me yet! :(

---OUT--- Belle Amie. This is high just because the others below were so poor last night, but they added nothing to the competition. -_-

7. Katie. (9-8-5-3-7) Last week, immense, authentic, fun. This week, dull, fake and boring. I'm GUTTED because of the expectation I had after last week. -_-

8. Wagner. (13-16-9-8-8) There's nothing to say, just take him with a pinch of salt.

9. Paije. (12-14-12-11-9) CAN NEVER REMEMBER HIS PERFORMANCES. I don't get why people RAVE about him.

10. Treyc. (10-9-8-10-10) Slinging $h!t in the face of the only judge giving her brilliant helpful feedback. Way to go love, you looked like a KNOB. :rolleyes:

 

OUT.

Nicolo (7-10-X)

FYD (11-12-X)

Storm Lee (16-13-14-X)

Diva Fever (5-11-8-X)

John (14-15-10-9-X)

Belle Amie. (6-6-11-9-7-X)

 

(Numbers in bold = Last place)

Edited November 1, 201014 yr by The Viper

Cher

Matt

One Direction

Belle Amie

Paije

TreyC

Mary

Rebecca

Katie

Aiden

Wagner

 

5/5, 4/5, 3/5, 2/5, 1/5

 

Cher did brilliant, nice to see a change of tone this week.

Matt's vocal was spot on as usual, and One Direction gave a decent performance.

 

Belle Amie. Snooze. A shame they didn't engage enough. They remained bland and forgettable, a tag that the nice John bloke couldn't shake either -

I did love their song choice for survival though.

Paije and TreyC are okay, Mary and Rebecca have been overrated, Katie's annoying factor has waned last few weeks (but her days on X Factor are limited I feel).

Aiden extracted the fun out of a classic and replaced it with shakey vocals and a heep of awkwardness. He's enjoying it I imagine, but it isn't portrayed enough. Like judges said, 'smile' ;].

Wagner's just Wagner.

 

01. Matt Cardle [2-1-1]

02. Aiden Grimshaw [3-2-2]

03. Cher Lloyd [16-5-3]

04. Paije Richardson [15-10-4]

05. One Direction [9-11-5]

06. Katie Waissel [12-3-6]

07. Rebecca Ferguson [7-7-7]

08. Wagner Carrilho [5-6-8]

09. Mary Byrne [4-4-9]

10. Treyc Cohen [14-8-10]

11. Belle Amie [7-12-11]

 

OUT

 

John Adeleye [13-9-OUT]

Diva Fever [10-OUT]

Storm Lee [1-OUT]

F.Y.D [6-OUT]

Nicolò Festa [11-OUT]

I don't do this on the regular but my latest ranking is:

 

1. Aiden [1-1] - I'm voting with my cock a little bit here. I'm starting to think he's singing the same song every week and trying to fool us by shouting out a different word in the chorus. That said, he is very talented, I love his intensity and he rawks with guyliner.

2. TreyC [4-2] - I think she 's a lovely bubbly person who deserves this opportunity and her voice, while nothing particularly unique, is definitely very good.

3. Cher [6-3] - I've been up and down with Cher but I think after that intense performance of 'Stay' she definitely ranks as one of my favourites.

4. Paije [3-4] - I have loved his powerful, soulful voice from day one. He's not a normal-looking popstar but America churned out Sean Kingston and he's totally talentless (bar 'Fire Burning') so we should be entitled to a porky popstar with an amazing voice.

5. Mary [2-5] - I still really like her voice but I'm starting to think one-trick pony now (yes, even after the Take That song which was nowhere near as good as her ballads.)

6. Katie [7-6] - Similar to Cher, I've been up and down with Katie but I do think, prize twat or not, she has something special - even if her voice IS weak.

7. Rebecca [5-7] - I love her voice but I don't think she's a popstar and she's lovely but rather dull as a person.

8. One Direction [8-8] - It pains me to place these so low when, if they were a couple of years older, I'd probably be their biggest loon. But I must vote on personality and voice and whilst they can all sing quite well individually, together I think they sound awful and beyond "cheeky little boys" there is no personality there.

9. Matt [12-9] - I find him DULL DULL DULL. He wins some respect for a good Britney cover though.

10. Wagner [9-10] - I'm a fan of a good novelty act but the joke has begun to wear thin now. Bat Out Of Hell wasn't hilariously awful, it was just awful.

11. Belle Amie [11-11] - OK voices, quite an impressive "look" (at least I thought) but overall just another karaoke girlband.