Jump to content

Featured Replies

It was Eivør Pálsdóttir - and you're right it is much better than the song entered.

 

Meanwhile this is a much better version of Trollabundin (without all that bloody weird grunting which really put me off the track)

Thanks :thumbup:

  • Replies 241
  • Views 25.3k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Excellent winner! :D

 

It possibly is my favourite song here but I already knew it so discounted it... even that left it remaining second in my votes though. :wub:

 

Surprised at my finish, easily my best yet. I love the Cicada track, it reminds me of Sally Shapiro which is no bad thing at all.

Ahh well, I'm glad my entry caused a bit of a stir rather than going completely unnoticed, shame it wasn't liked that much though. Glad some of you liked Neo :)

 

Thanks for hosting, Mark - an excellent job as usual. Very much looking forward to the next one :D

Ahh well, I'm glad my entry caused a bit of a stir rather than going completely unnoticed, shame it wasn't liked that much though. Glad some of you liked Neo :)

 

Thanks for hosting, Mark - an excellent job as usual. Very much looking forward to the next one :D

It was probably the most interesting entry. I didn't like the beginning at all but carried on listening and started thinking "I'm liking this".

Do you have the complete spreadsheet too? :D

Edited by Freeze

It was probably the most interesting entry. I didn't like the beginning at all but carried on listening and started thinking "I'm liking this".

 

I have to admit, the beginning is very rubbish, but I was hoping people would persist as the rest of the song, in my opinion, is immense. Glad you liked it :D

  • Author
Do you have the complete spreadsheet too? :D

Yeah I'll post it tomorrow, along with updated stats.

 

I'm also going to do a general discussion thread for the next one...

  • Author
I'm glad about the winner, very HEALTH in a way, my discovery for the comp as well. thanks for the 12 points Rabbit, glad you liked my track, be sure to check out the album it's from ('Ruff Guide To Genre Terrorism'), great band.

 

How odd you say that, when Harve sent me the song he said something along the lines of 'New Health'... I really liked your song, it's very different. I think I'll definitely check out their album.

 

 

Well done Harve and thanks Mark for doing this brilliantly as usual. :cheer:

 

At least I improved on last time and am glad found the song some new fans.

 

Looking forward to the next one already

 

 

Thanks! :D The song is great, was one of the most instant for me.

 

 

^ Just because your entry remains unknown doesn't mean you can't hype yourself up (Y). And i paid off too! :D Thanks for the votes everyone <3

 

 

It's a good job I allowed late votes! You'd have remained 4th if Casey hadn't voted and you'd had a points deduction...

 

Grats to Harve, Tyron and Thomsen and everybody else who did better than expected and thx to RabbitFurCoat for organizing the whole thing. :thumbup:

 

Not too happy with the overall result (the winner was actually the song I ranked last :lol:) but VERY happy with the top 10 for Hurt. Thx to everybody who gave it some points. :wub: Am I the best "newcomer"? :kink:

 

Can't wait for the next one, I have a big list of potential songs already.

 

 

You were indeed, one place ahead of the next best Tom.

 

Excellent winner! :D

 

It possibly is my favourite song here but I already knew it so discounted it... even that left it remaining second in my votes though. :wub:

 

Surprised at my finish, easily my best yet. I love the Cicada track, it reminds me of Sally Shapiro which is no bad thing at all.

 

It was one of only two songs I already knew as well, I thought about bumping it down to second but I only knew it from Ben's CD Swap and this made me like it more if anything. I did love 'Towers' though, it's not exactly my thing but it made me happy, it's so lovely! The Cicada song is a bit Sally now you mention it...

 

How odd you say that, when Harve sent me the song he said something along the lines of 'New Health'... I really liked your song, it's very different. I think I'll definitely check out their album.

 

It's a good job I allowed late votes! You'd have remained 4th if Casey hadn't voted and you'd had a points deduction...

I see Pictureplane as similar to HEALTH with a hint of Witch House (last.fm would agree with me), if i said this before Chris would be put way off.

 

Perhaps i shouldn't cut it so fine next time :/. Thanks for allowing late votes, and for hosting, which i should've said that the first time. HOW RUDE.

It was Eivør Pálsdóttir - and you're right it is much better than the song entered.

 

 

Meanwhile this is a much better version of Trollabundin (without all that bloody weird grunting which really put me off the track)

 

Hounds of Love is amazing although i liked Trøllabundin much more hence entered it.

 

This version is boring to be honest. :(

Managed to not be in the bottom five :D

 

Thanks for doing this Mark it was a lot of fun

So a third winner with that sort of female vocals. :(

 

 

For me it was all the 'bloody weird grunting' in Trollabundin that made it stand out. Otherwise it just sounds like a lot of other folk music.

 

Don't see the excitement over Hounds Of Love myself. It's OK

For me it was all the 'bloody weird grunting' in Trollabundin that made it stand out. Otherwise it just sounds like a lot of other folk music.

Exactly! It's the way she can handle her voice that makes the song so unique. :wub:

For me it was all the 'bloody weird grunting' in Trollabundin that made it stand out. Otherwise it just sounds like a lot of other folk music.

 

 

Agreed. I wouldn't have voted for it at all of it wasn't for the grunting.

  • Author
So a third winner with that sort of female vocals. :(

I'd say it's a completely different type of song to the previous two winners though.

Agreed. I wouldn't have voted for it at all of it wasn't for the grunting.

That's fine but I'd rather not have the sound of Serena Williams in my ears for half the song.

I'd say it's a completely different type of song to the previous two winners though.

Quite. I don't think it is directly comparable to previous winners at all and I'd say it's definitely the best winner to date.

 

And, excuse my rudeness for not saying so sooner, thanks for running this again - you did an excellent job as usual. :wub:

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.