Lets bring some activity back to this forum by having a rate for (imo) the greatest album of all time! (Well it's my favourite anyway :P)

 

http://2.bp.blogspot.com/_-BpF23RzxKE/SK-gmDLc1mI/AAAAAAAAKRQ/IvGBH2K1rGA/s1600/Kelly%20Clarkson%20-%20Breakaway(FanMade%20Album%20Cover).png

 

Cover from Coverlandia Blogspot!

 

RULES:

01. You may give a maximum of only ONE 11 and -1!

02. No more than THREE 10's and 0's.

03. Rates will end DATE TBC (You will have at LEAST 2 WEEKS anyway - but depending on how many votes I recieve from then it may be scheduled to change!)

 

The tracklisting:

 

01. 'Breakaway'

02. 'Since U Been Gone'

03. 'Behind These Hazel Eyes'

04. 'Because of You'

05. 'Gone'

06. 'Addicted'

07. 'Where Is Your Heart?'

08. 'Walk Away'

09. 'You Found Me'

10. 'I Hate Myself For Losing You'

11. 'Hear Me'

12. 'Beautiful Disaster' (Live) [bONUS TRACK]

13. 'Miss Independent' [bONUS TRACK]

14. 'Low' [bONUS TRACK]

Edited January 4, 201114 yr by Frank!

08.5 'Breakaway'

11.0 'Since U Been Gone'

10.0 'Behind These Hazel Eyes'

10.0 'Because of You'

10.0 'Gone'

09.0 'Addicted'

08.0 'Where Is Your Heart?'

09.5 'Walk Away'

09.0 'You Found Me'

09.0 'I Hate Myself For Losing You'

09.5 'Hear Me'

09.5 'Beautiful Disaster' (Live) [bONUS TRACK]

07.5 'Miss Independant' [bONUS TRACK]

09.0 'Low' [bONUS TRACK]

 

Amazing from start to finish! I know it looks like I'm coming across a tad loony, but we all have favourite ever albums, it just happens to be, that this one is mine :)

09/10 'Breakaway'

09/10 'Since U Been Gone'

10/10 'Behind These Hazel Eyes'

09/10 'Because of You'

10/10 'Gone'

11/10 'Addicted'

08/10 'Where Is Your Heart?'

09/10 'Walk Away'

06/10 'You Found Me'

06/10 'I Hate Myself For Losing You'

08/10 'Hear Me'

10/10 'Beautiful Disaster' (Live) [bONUS TRACK]

09/10 'Miss Independant' [bONUS TRACK]

09/10 'Low' [bONUS TRACK]

Edited January 9, 201114 yr by Tyler

10.0 'Breakaway'

11.0 'Since U Been Gone'

10.0 'Behind These Hazel Eyes'

10.0 'Because of You'

09.0 'Gone'

08.5 'Addicted'

09.0 'Where Is Your Heart?'

09.5 'Walk Away'

09.0 'You Found Me'

08.5 'I Hate Myself For Losing You'

08.0 'Hear Me'

09.5 'Beautiful Disaster' (Live) [bONUS TRACK]

09.0 'Miss Independant' [bONUS TRACK]

08.5 'Low' [bONUS TRACK]

 

I can't think of any better opening to an album - definitely my favourite anyway, and certainly one of my all time top five albums. It pains me not to give Beautiful Disaster a 10!

08 'Breakaway'

07 'Since U Been Gone'

11 'Behind These Hazel Eyes'

09 'Because of You'

08 'Gone'

09 'Addicted'

08 'Where Is Your Heart?'

10 'Walk Away'

08 'You Found Me'

09 'I Hate Myself For Losing You'

09 'Hear Me'

09 'Beautiful Disaster' (Live) [bONUS TRACK]

08 'Miss Independant' [bONUS TRACK]

08 'Low' [bONUS TRACK]

01. 'Breakaway' 8

02. 'Since U Been Gone' 11 :wub:

03. 'Behind These Hazel Eyes' 9

04. 'Because of You' 9

05. 'Gone' 8

06. 'Addicted' 8

07. 'Where Is Your Heart?' 4

08. 'Walk Away' 8

09. 'You Found Me' 7

10. 'I Hate Myself For Losing You' 5

11. 'Hear Me' 6

12. 'Beautiful Disaster' (Live) [bONUS TRACK] 8

13. 'Miss Independent' [bONUS TRACK] 8

14. 'Low' [bONUS TRACK] 7

07 - 'Breakaway'

08 - 'Since U Been Gone'

11 - 'Behind These Hazel Eyes'

10 - 'Because of You'

10 - 'Gone'

09 - 'Addicted'

04 - 'Where Is Your Heart?'

08 - 'Walk Away'

10 - 'You Found Me'

04 - 'I Hate Myself For Losing You'

08 - 'Hear Me'

06 - 'Beautiful Disaster' (Live) [bONUS TRACK]

07 - 'Miss Independent' [bONUS TRACK]

05 - 'Low' [bONUS TRACK]

 

 

I don't get the low marks for Where Is Your Heart at all... it's beautiful. :(

08 'Breakaway'

09 'Since U Been Gone'

11 'Behind These Hazel Eyes'

10 'Because of You'

09 'Gone' This needs a 10 damnit. :(

08 'Addicted'

10 'Where Is Your Heart?'

09 'Walk Away'

06 'You Found Me'

08 'I Hate Myself For Losing You'

07 'Hear Me'

10 'Beautiful Disaster' (Live) [bONUS TRACK]

09 'Miss Independant' [bONUS TRACK]

09 'Low' [bONUS TRACK]

 

Also happens to be one of my all time fave albums too. Pop perfection. ^_^

I'm with The Viper on the hate for Where Is Your Heart. ACTUALLY the best thing the woman has recorded. And so, purely to help it along, I shall vote even though I am far from a Clarkson loon.

 

 

 

09 'Breakaway'

09 'Since U Been Gone'

07 'Behind These Hazel Eyes'

-1 'Because of You' - I ABHOR this slush

03 'Gone'

03 'Addicted'

11 'Where Is Your Heart?'

09 'Walk Away'

06 'You Found Me'

08 'I Hate Myself For Losing You'

04 'Hear Me'

06 'Beautiful Disaster' (Live) [bONUS TRACK]

08 'Miss Independant' [bONUS TRACK]

08 'Low' [bONUS TRACK]

08 'Breakaway'

8.5 'Since U Been Gone'

10 'Behind These Hazel Eyes'

10 'Because of You'

9.5 'Gone'

11 'Addicted'

10 'Where Is Your Heart?'

9.5 'Walk Away'

08 'You Found Me'

8.5 'I Hate Myself For Losing You'

09 'Hear Me'

9.5 'Beautiful Disaster' (Live) [bONUS TRACK]

09 'Miss Independent' [bONUS TRACK]

9.5 'Low' [bONUS TRACK]

 

One of my best albums of all time too! Nothing lower than an 8

I don't get the low marks for Where Is Your Heart at all... it's beautiful. :(

 

Me either, one of my best!

08 'Breakaway'

11 'Since U Been Gone'

10 'Behind These Hazel Eyes'

09 'Because of You'

10 'Gone'

08 'Addicted'

07 'Where Is Your Heart?'

05 'Walk Away'

07 'You Found Me'

08 'I Hate Myself For Losing You'

07 'Hear Me'

09 'Beautiful Disaster' (Live) [bONUS TRACK]

09 'Miss Independant' [bONUS TRACK]

10 'Low' [bONUS TRACK]

7.5 'Breakaway'

10 'Since U Been Gone'

10 'Behind These Hazel Eyes'

11 'Because of You'

7.5 'Gone'

08 'Addicted'

8.5 'Where Is Your Heart?'

08 'Walk Away'

7.5 'You Found Me'

08 'I Hate Myself For Losing You'

7.5 'Hear Me'

09 'Beautiful Disaster' (Live) [bONUS TRACK]

07 'Miss Independant' [bONUS TRACK]

06 'Low' [bONUS TRACK]

09.5 Breakaway

10.0 Since U Been Gone

11.0 Behind These Hazel Eyes

06.0 Because of You

10.0 Gone

06.0 Addicted

07.5 Where Is Your Heart?

08.0 Walk Away

07.5 You Found Me

06.0 I Hate Myself For Losing You

07.0 Hear Me

07.0 Beautiful Disaster' (Live)

08.0 Miss Independent

06.0 Low

 

There's actually a fair bit of filler on there but it starts off in fantastic fashion. Are you going to included the bonuses (the last two anyway) when you do the countdown Jon? I wouldn't personally seeing as they're songs from the debut...

I have come to the conclusion 'Addicted' is my favorite Clarkson song after 'Sober'.

 

Amazing.

09. 'Breakaway'

-1. 'Since U Been Gone'

09. 'Behind These Hazel Eyes'

09. 'Because of You'

10. 'Gone'

10. 'Addicted'

05. 'Where Is Your Heart?'

09. 'Walk Away'

08. 'You Found Me'

09. 'I Hate Myself For Losing You'

11. 'Hear Me'

10. 'Beautiful Disaster' (Live) [bONUS TRACK]

08. 'Miss Independent' [bONUS TRACK]

09. 'Low' [bONUS TRACK]

 

I would like to point out that mine have been somewhat extrapolated, as otherwise they'd all be 9's after the 11 and 3 10's, and that's just no fun at all. I do like SUBG I just think it's ridiculously overrated when IMO there are much better tracks on the album.

I'm with The Viper on the hate for Where Is Your Heart. ACTUALLY the best thing the woman has recorded. And so, purely to help it along, I shall vote even though I am far from a Clarkson loon.

Yay. :wub:

 

And please, call me Matt. ^_^

Breakaway - 10

Since U Been Gone - 9.5

Behind These Hazel Eyes - 10

Because Of You - 11

Gone - 8.5

Addicted - 9.5

Where Is Your Heart? - 8

Walk Away - 8.5

You Found Me - 9

I Hate Myself For Losing You - 8

Hear Me - 9

Beautiful Disaster (Live) - 9.5 (would also be a ten tbh, but I have my 3!)

Ms Independent - 9

Low - 10

 

This is probably my fave album ever :wub: To think I bought it somewhat randomly from Sainsbury's bargain shelf! I'd been a fan for a couple of years but hadn't picked up any of her albums. I went in Sainsbury's to get The Saturdays' Chasing Lights, and on my way to the chart CD's spotted one lone copy of Breakaway discarded onto the wrong shelf! I picked it up and got a totally amazing album that is probs my fave ever for just £3! :o

Any more? *cough*JOAO & FRANK!*cough* :drama: