Dannii was the best on there tbf. Can't believe how she received NO recognition when Matt won however.

Dannii was the best on there tbf. Can't believe how she received NO recognition when Matt won however.

 

Who's Matt?

 

Kath

Gutted that Dannii has gone. She was the best judge imo, loon-ness for Cheryl aside. Louis is a fool and Tulisa doesn't come across well in any interview I've ever seen her in.

Dannii has been repeatedly stated to be by far the best mentor to the contestants and is by far the best judge.

 

 

BIG BIG BIG loss.

thats quite sad tbh :( Tulisa?! what a fail

 

this is turning out to be pretty shaky, just one original judge left and he's hardly everyone's favourite- not great :/

Dannii, Simon and Cheryl all out yet Louis stays? Surely the popularity will now divebomb, especially if Tulisa gets the job :lol:

Sorry but I think most of your are bigging up Danni far too much! Her spot will easily be filled (as will Cheryl's) ... the ONLY big seat to fill is Simon's ... and I fear ... as big as it is ... Barlow's arse isn't nearly big enough to reach the corners of that seat!

 

Kath

Dannii, Simon and Cheryl all out yet Louis stays? Surely the popularity will now divebomb, especially if Tulisa gets the job :lol:

 

Rich! As much as I think he is a dweeb - Louis (talentless as he is) is by far the most entertaining (barring Simon) of the X-F judges.

 

Kath

Sorry but I think most of your are bigging up Danni far too much! Her spot will easily be filled (as will Cheryl's) ... the ONLY big seat to fill is Simon's ... and I fear ... as big as it is ... Barlow's arse isn't nearly big enough to reach the corners of that seat!

 

Kath

 

agree with this. I think in terms of the show the other Louis, Cheryl and Dannii can be very easily replaced and forgotten about (see Sharon Osbourne). Simon Cowell to the mass media is basically an incarnation of God. I don't think it will matter at the end of the day. It's good anyway imo. The show was just becoming a competition about the judge's egos, not the contestants. And Dannii aside, none of them really put that much effort in to their acts (not just their favourite)...

Louis has been confirmed as returning yet so we could be looking at an all new panel.

Typical. Break the news whilst Dannii's fan (aka the gays) are distracted with Gay Christmas. I'll miss Dannii though, she was my bar my favorite of the panel and often the only one you didnt want to severly injure.

 

Tulisa from N-Dubz? Yikes. Dire.

Im disapointed at the news, Dannii was my favourite judge as i always thought she gave the most constructive comments from all the judges, and wasnt afraid to praise acts from the other judges categories, looks like its an all new x factor this year and it will be interesting to see who replaces dannii and cheryl, i cant see Tulisa been one though.

Bringing Sharon O back would absolutely stink of desperation and I honestly think half of the viewers would turn off. People aren't blind, it's all too apparent that she's a total piece of work and nobody wants to watch somebody like that week-in week-out. But then at this rate half of the viewers might turn off anyway. Simon Cowell seems to be on some crazy career suicide mission lately.

I personally believe Tulisa will be a pretty brilliant judge! I don't think she'll sit on the fence as much as Cheryl and we all know (well those who have seen 'Being N-Dubz' - Which is a big ratings winner for 4Music and T4 etc.) she actually WILL say what's on her mind. I think she's the perfect choice to replace one of the others and think people are jumping the gun far too quickly just because of the group she's associated with.

I think the Dannii leaving thing could be true, but the Tulisa thing might not.

 

I think Tulisa would be a good judge though. She seems like a nice girl (the other two always bully her, but she managed to keep her cool :lol:), and I think she'd draw in different viewers. And she's a better vocalist than any of the previous judges, so the Cheryl-haters should like her, since that's the main thing they whine about.

Charlotte Church and Elton John are needed ASAP.

I don't know why and there's no way in a million years it'd ever happen but they'd provide classic television.

Dunno if I will bother this year. On top of the odd *decent* contestant, me and my friends got our Saturday night fix praising the Minogue, wishing Cole and Walsh would get hit by large trucks and berating everything that came out of Cowell's mouth as 'fixed'.

 

 

Good times :(

Tulisa in = I won't be watching

 

Can't stand N Dubz. LOL at how they would always talk about X Factor and that people just "queue up" and become famous overnight

& How JLS, Cheryl, Leona and The Black Eyed Peas stopped them from getting to Number 1

 

I'm sure they wouldn't complain if it was them actually getting a slot

Tulisa really :o Please come back Sharon.

Boo.

 

X Factor is becoming more crap by the second...

 

Who the hell is Tulisa anyway? :S

Edited May 16, 201114 yr by Sabrewulf

Well the X Factor is quickly turning into a sinking ship. I fully expect to hear tomorrow that Louis Walsh has "quit" and is being replaced by Professor Green.

 

I'm against Tulisa simply because anything that provides more publicity for N-Dubz (and that FOUL undeveloped ape Dappy) is very much a bad thing. I'd LOVE Lily Allen to do it, but she's already spoken out against the idea so I guess not.