May 28, 201114 yr Career wise, of course she should, it's the best TV job she could get in the UK pretty much. I don't WANT her back because she is a talentless plank with nothing of worth to say about anything and has a real aura of c**t about her.
May 28, 201114 yr I voted Yes. As much as I was annoyed that she left the UK for the US, I still much prefer her to Tulisa and Kelly Rowland (the latter I think will be a complete bore) So I'm pretty torn, but for Entertainment value, Yes.
May 28, 201114 yr I voted yes, but only in preference to the other three names being touted at the moment.
May 28, 201114 yr Actually I voted No, if the other judges have been reinstated, why should she get her job back. She can host the X Factor Extra on ITV2, I think they are still looking for a presenter as Connie has left.
May 28, 201114 yr No, she left here for America to find something bigger and better. It didn't work out but that's the risk she took, we should we have to take her back?
May 28, 201114 yr I think "No", but not for the reason the poll says. I think she shouldn't because she'd be a bit of a laughing stock if she did, I reckon. The media would love it, and would constantly remind the public about it. Although I do think Cheryl is a good judge.
May 28, 201114 yr Actually I voted No, if the other judges have been reinstated, why should she get her job back. She can host the X Factor Extra on ITV2, I think they are still looking for a presenter as Connie has left. Matt Edmondson is the new presenter of The Xtra Factor.. I voted no.. She made her bed, she should have to lie in it.
May 28, 201114 yr Please God no-she has become a hopeless self centered judge who only cares about her own solo career.Her blatant favoritism of some contestants over others Diana/Joe/Cher is beyond a joke and not fair.
May 28, 201114 yr I think Girls Aloud's the only way she can fully rehabilitate herself really. She faces looking like she's crawling back with her tail between her legs if she goes straight back onto the UK panel...
May 28, 201114 yr No, she had a good thing going for her in X Factor Uk but she decided to leave for the US. She took the chance and it didn't pay off...so now she should have to deal with the results. The judges who are a part of X Factor UK should get the chance now. Edited May 28, 201114 yr by Sabrewulf
May 28, 201114 yr No, she should not come back to the UK X Factor after announcing she won't be on it a few weeks before.
May 28, 201114 yr Author Actually I voted No, if the other judges have been reinstated, why should she get her job back. She can host the X Factor Extra on ITV2, I think they are still looking for a presenter as Connie has left. OUCH! Stacey Soloman is one of the new Xtra Factor presenters.
May 28, 201114 yr I voted no.. She made her bed, she should have to lie in it. Completely agree, she should keep her head down and go back into the studio with Girls Aloud.
May 28, 201114 yr I think "No", but not for the reason the poll says. I think she shouldn't because she'd be a bit of a laughing stock if she did, I reckon. The media would love it, and would constantly remind the public about it. pretty much agree with this, it would look desperate and awkward, plus its unfair for her to get an automatic place back- she wanted to leave, its not fair if we let her back just in 'sympathy' I think a revamp would be the way to go for X Factor, even if the judges don't look the most exciting
May 28, 201114 yr I love how everyone's judging the new panel already. I think we should give them all a chance before we decide 100% whether we think it's going to be $h!t or not. (I personally feel K-Ro and Tulisa will surprise many people - If they are confirmed). Anyway, I think it'd be career suicide (as stated previously) if she decided to come back to UK X factor, full time. I think she should guest judge or something (like Katy Perry, Pixie Lott, Nicole etc.. did, but even then, so soon after and it's still a bit risky). I agree with those who say she should just get the wheels moving for Girls Aloud to reunite (Properly. New album and tour and everything)
May 28, 201114 yr I don't think it's that she shouldn't come back, I think it's they shouldn't have her back. I love her, but in all honesty she can't just p*** off and abandon the UK then come crawling back when it all goes wrong... I mean what if they've given someone else (like Tulisa or Kelly Rowland as rumours say) the job - why should they be sacked for Cheryl? On a kind of related note, I read a rumour on DS that she might be a mentor/judge on the UK version of The Voice - on BBC1.
May 28, 201114 yr I don't think it's that she shouldn't come back, I think it's they shouldn't have her back. I love her, but in all honesty she can't just p*** off and abandon the UK then come crawling back when it all goes wrong... I mean what if they've given someone else (like Tulisa or Kelly Rowland as rumours say) the job - why should they be sacked for Cheryl? On a kind of related note, I read a rumour on DS that she might be a mentor/judge on the UK version of The Voice - on BBC1. Oh please god no, she was supposedly a dire mentor on the X Factor, The Voice actually relies even more on that part. Oh and I voted no. She was too good for the UK and went to the US, she can't just crawl back after she got sacked. No, you make your bed and then you lie in it.
May 28, 201114 yr On a kind of related note, I read a rumour on DS that she might be a mentor/judge on the UK version of The Voice - on BBC1. there's a slight irony in her going for a show named 'The Voice' :kink:
May 29, 201114 yr I've also heard Dannii's name mentioned for The Voice, I don't think they'd both defect to BBC tbh :unsure: Anyway, apparently Chezza's been axed from UK XF as well (ie the producers were still up her ass but she didn't co-operate so she's out :o): http://www.digitalspy.co.uk/tv/s103/the-x-...-factor-uk.html If she doesn't get The Voice, her career is DEAD.
Create an account or sign in to comment