I prefer the Idol format too, it's part of why the series of American Idol just gone worked, along with the fabulous panel ofc! The annoying thing is the age limit is 28 for some reason...

It's US of A after all! They wouldn't let old people on air, as proved by many reality TV shows.

Odds movement, I know it's not a spoiler but just in case people moan about it being made predictable or whatever by me revealing it I'll spoiler it:

 

Some VERY odd movement with William Hill's odds today, Janet and Amelia still top 2, but MELANIE has moved up to 3rd :mellow: Jade has drifted WAY off and is now 14/1.... Wonder if they know something we don't? Imagine if Jade lost her place to Melanie? :o

 

Edited September 27, 201113 yr by Liаm

Odds movement, I know it's not a spoiler but just in case people moan about it being made predictable or whatever by me revealing it I'll spoiler it:

 

Some VERY odd movement with William Hill's odds today, Janet and Amelia still top 2, but MELANIE has moved up to 3rd :mellow: Jade has drifted WAY off and is now 14/1.... Wonder if they know something we don't? Imagine if Jade lost her place to Melanie? :o

 

Oh wow, very possible. I really don't see what

Melanie

has to offer what-so-ever. One of the worst in the catogery.

Apparently Melanie is through. The 4 girls are Janet, Misha, Amelia and Melanie according to Digital Spy forums :)

Top 4 Girls have supposedly leaked:

 

 

Liam, the odds were right! The 4 that has supposedly through are Amelia, Misha, Janet and Melanie. Have to say I am gutted Jade is not through, she was honestly my tip for winning the whole thing!

 

Glad to see that top 4 tbh, except for Melanie beating Jade :o I thought she'd win too, but I guess she had to be this year's 'shock' axing (like Amy Connolly in 2008), or maybe she really messed up and (unlike Cheryl with Cher :P) Kelly wasn't giving second chances - which I guess is fair enough. I expected Melanie tbh, seeing as she as high on the odds even before her 5 second audition was shown, it just seemed she's a 'chosen one' already! She's good but I really don't see any star quality in her, I'd like to be proved wrong but I doubt she'll be better than just 'good'.

Edited September 27, 201113 yr by Liаm

I'm surprised.

Jade is Scottish, fat, from the middle of nowhere, has a gran and sung Someone Like You-surefire winner I'd have thought. I've always thought she was a bit average. But she obviously won't impress Kelly at Judge's houses.

I'm surprised.

Jade is Scottish, fat, from the middle of nowhere, has a gran and sung Someone Like You-surefire winner I'd have thought. I've always thought she was a bit average. But she obviously won't impress Kelly at Judge's houses.

 

 

The only thing I can think of is that Jade will probably have a Cher moment and will let the pressure of the situation get to her. Kelly seemed massively keen on her, crying and her excited reaction whenever Jade came on, so I can't see why else she wouldn't be through.

 

LOL. If it's right that Jade didn't make it through I can lol at my dad - he predicted her to win and was all like "just remember I said it first" etc. :drama: Really want Jade through anyway, she's talented but at least Janet and Mischa are through :heart:

Fuck the girls, I'm more intrigued about who is going through in over 25s :(

Fuck the girls, I'm more intrigued about who is going through in over 25s :(

 

That's definitely the most interesting category, wasted on Louis of course. The girls are too hyped up to me, the boys have only about one or two with potential and the groups, well, they're the groups :lol:

 

This Melanie McCabe person must be VERY good as she's had so little screen time!

I'm surprised at Jade not through, but I guess that category is just so strong, there had to be one shock denial

 

There isn't even one good group this year. :manson: Even the "thrown into the food blender" groups are terrible...and FOUR of these have to make the live finals? :manson:

 

Just... :manson:

 

:(

 

I actually think Louis will do better this series than Tulisa who imo definitely has the weakest category.

Am actually glad 'Melanie' is ment to be through over jade, I dont know if you have all heared melanie's full audition, That they didn't show on the telly! But her verison of 'one night only' is pretty amazing! here is the audio for her FULL audition http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XaVIwS-POZg

Edited September 28, 201113 yr by SwaggerCher

Oh God YES! Melanie is brilliant and is being completely underrated/under used on the show! I'm happy she's through over Jade. They would just make Jade "Adele mk. II" and we really don't need another one of her at the moment, do we? :lol: I really hope Melanie gains a few more fans through the lives (if it's true) as I can see her having some real potential

Wow! A strong top 4 though for Kelly. Have any of the other category's leaked then? :o

I feel like I don't care madly enough about X Factor any more to not look at the spoilers....

 

and yet I still can't look at the spoilers. I guess I just have an aversion to being spoiled on anything.

 

 

Broke down and looked at the spoilers, funnily it actually only confirms the rumour I had heard already about Jade not making it. Sad about Jade, although Melanie would be my next choice for the final 4.

 

Edited September 28, 201113 yr by Sabrewulf

 

Is Melanie the cute little blonde irish girl who has a really strong voice? They havent shown much of her, but i think i like her from the little i've seen.

 

Edit: youtube'd her, it is the girl i'm thinking of :heehee: Not surprised she's through, Kelly loved her!

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LFEBSY8_wzk

 

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_n8rSONahLY

 

She's only 17!

 

Edited September 29, 201113 yr by Karma

Fuck the girls, I'm more intrigued about who is going through in over 25s :(

 

This. GOLDIE BETTER BE IN THERE.

 

(Srsly though, if Terry and Joseph aren't there's going to be hell to pay).