Nu Vibes, they didn't gel

 

Skinny Love :wub:

Flat and boring performance. There's no charisma and certainly no chemistry there. Who's idea of a good boyband is this. Delusional Tulisa.

 

3.7

Nu Vibe have no likeability at all! The performance was better than last week's, but I think I want them out first!

 

4.0 Nu Vibe

Just wondering who's gonna be the first over to sing? That pathetic Johnny? I miss Wagner. He was rubbish, weak vocals but very funny to watch to say the least. :(

Edited October 15, 201113 yr by Jason

Nu Vibe - Terrible, I kind of liked the version of 'With Or Without You' that they did but as Louis and Gary said - No Vibe for me. They sounded out of tune and just don't work together well at all.

LMAO @ Sami advocating obesity.

Sami Brookes - I Will Always Love You

 

Firstly, Sami sure likes saying "sweetheart" doesn't she. :lol:

 

Predictable song choice from Louis but compared to Nu Vibe she sounds brilliant. Pretty decent vocal performance but I wasn't 100% sold on it. 7/10

Sami - 6.5/10

Another Whitney Houston song choice? Oh dear, this is so predictable. <_< It wasn't as good as her audition but it was ok.

 

Sami - 6.5/10

Nu Vibe - 5.5/10

Edited October 15, 201113 yr by Jason

Sami - That was beautiful. There were some parts that I wished were even more emotional, like she could have done some more high notes in certain parts, but maybe she wasn't comfortable with that.

Sami Brooks ok-ish, middle of the road 5/10

Sami - Ugh Louis is totally wrecking Sami for me. She is NOT the next Mary Byrne. I wish she would do something youthful and fun...it's more her thing! 6.5/10

 

Sami was one of my favs coming into the live shows, but it's all becoming a bit meh now. :(

 

Sami - 6.5/10

Nu Vibe - 5/10

Sami: She has a very good voice. Not mad on the song choice though - she started off well and then delved into the Whitney impression. Boo. Pretty good overall though.

 

Rates 2011 (week 2)

7.0 Sami Brookes - I Will Always Love You

1.0 Nu Vibe - With Or Without You

Ugh patronising fat person comment.

 

It was a bit naff but then her "kareoke pub matriarch" shtick is always going to be there for me. Decent enough. No real emotion and very errr...pub

 

5.8

22 minutes in and we're already on the 2nd ad break...

That was a wonderful vocal performance from Sami yet again. She's starting to get really good. And, that was the most interesting performance I've seen from her. I loved that.

 

Rates

8/10 Sami

3/10 Nu Vibe

Janet going on as the first girl? VERY surprised about that.

1 song and adverts? Thanks ITV1 <_<

Sami was vocally fantastic, but it's easy to over-sing that song and she did that, still a better performance than last week too!

 

8.0 Sami

4.0 Nu Vibe

01 Sami - Sat here with such a smile on my face, sure it's a bit copycat and karaoke, but the bottom line is - she can sing it, and she can hit the notes. There's people like Janet and Sophie with quirky voices, it's refreshing to see a normal voice, who can just.. sing. 8/10

02 Nu Vibe - Whoever thought, let's have them sing with minimal instrumental at the start, was a good idea. It wasn't, it highlighted their flaws. You can tell they're five solo singers. Weak. 5/10

6.5 Sami ~ She's a total 'sweedart' and doesn't seem to have any pretense about being anything other than a decent but unremarkable karaoke singer.

4.0 Nu Vibe ~ Backing track stolen from Beautiful People. Every bit as mundane as that performance.