Yet again, Marcus delivers a super-boring performance, with a clichéd song choice. I really hope he fails to make the final, as he's by far the least deserving of the final four. 5/10

Stunning from Little Mix! A much better ballid performance than their 'Beautiful' last week, which felt a bit too karaoke, but I loved the new arrangement that they did to 'If I Were a Boy', and Perrie's vocals on the chorus were brilliant - Gary is off his head this week. 10/10

 

01. Little Mix 'If I Were a Boy' (10.0)

02. Amelia Lily 'I'm with You' (9.5)

03. Misha B 'Perfect' (9.0)

04. Little Mix 'You Keep Me Hangin' On' (9.0)

05. Amelia Lily 'Ain't No Mountain High Enough' (8.0)

06. Misha B 'Dancing In the Street' (6.5)

07. Marcus Collins 'Can You Feel It?' (5.0)

08. Marcus Collins 'My Girl' (5.0)

 

01. Little Mix (9.50)

02. Amelia Lily (8.75)

03. Misha B (7.75)

04. Marcus Collins (5.00)

Little Mix - Another strong performance, again It didn't blow me away but I still enjoyed it. I think they were the most consistent tonight. 8.5/10

 

(2nd Perf) Amelia - 9/10

---

(2nd Perf) Misha - 8.5/10

(1st Perf) Little Mix - 8.5/10

(2nd Perf) Little Mix - 8.5/10

(1st Perf) Misha - 8/10

---

(1st Perf) Amelia - 7/10

(1st Perf) Marcus - 6/10

---

(2nd Perf) Marcus - 4/10

 

------------------------------

 

(Overall) Little Mix - 17/20

(Overall) Misha - 16.5/20

---

(Overall) Amelia - 16/20

---

(Overall) Marcus - 10/20

 

Marcus to go please.

Edited December 3, 201113 yr by Sabrewulf

Continuing, Tulisa's speech was great!

 

Final ranking:

1. Amelia Lily - I'm With You

2. Little Mix - If I Were A Boy

3. Amelia Lily - Ain't No Mountain High Enough

4. Little Mix - Keep Me Hanging On

5. Misha - Perfect

6. Marcus - Can You Feel It?

7. Misha - Dancing In The Street

8. Marcus - My Girl

 

Little Mix and Amelia for final 2, Little Mix to win, Marcus to go out tonight.

 

And I'm done!

Marcus must stay :( Misha or Amelia to go.

Best: Amelia

 

Worst: Marcus

 

With Marcus mediocre vocal performances and Gary being an outright prick, Marcus has a strong chance of being voted out tomorrow. Although I hope Misha goes!

Edited December 3, 201113 yr by Lewymocha

Little Mix (If I Were A Boy) - Judges seem to be out to get the girls tonight, especially Gary (how he can say their vocals were bad and say Marcus was 'amazing is beyond me). Much better than the first, and overall the best performance of the night for me. Perrie absolutely smashed it and put every other living thing to shame. - 9.5/10.0

 

RATES:

Little Mix (If I Were A Boy) - 9.5

Misha B (Perfect) - 9.5

Amelia Lily (I'm With You) - 9.0

Marcus (My Girl) - 8.5

Misha B (Dancing In The Street) - 8.0

Amelia Lily (Ain't No Mountain High Enough) - 7.5

Little Mix (Keep Me Hanging On) - 7.0

Marcus (Can You Feel It) - 5.0

01 Amelia "I'm With You"

02 Little Mix "If I Were A Boy"

03 Little Mix "You Keep Me Hanging On"

04 Misha "Perfect"

05 Marcus "My Girl"

06 Marcus "Can You Feel It"

07 Misha "Dancing In The Street"

08 Amelia "Ain't No Mountain High"

 

Misha or Marcus to leave this week please. Misha preferably

 

and while we're at it.. Can we vote off the judges too ? Tulisa is the only one I can actually stand and that says a lot considering I wasn't keen on the idea of her being a judge in the first place

I really HATE to say this, but I think Gary Barlow has jeprodised Little Mix's chances of winning. That perf was just amazing, and then he had to say that... He only said that because he knows Marcus is in danger tomorrow night and wanted to make sure that little Mix were worse than him.

 

Oh, and Amelia is going to win now. UNFORTUNATELY.

If there's a bottom 2 tomorrow it must be between Marcus & Misha.

 

Little Mix and Amelia totally deserve to be in the finale. :dance:

RATES:

Little Mix (If I Were A Boy) - 9.5

Misha B (Perfect) - 9.5

Amelia Lily (I'm With You) - 9.0

Marcus (My Girl) - 8.5

Misha B (Dancing In The Street) - 8.0

Amelia Lily (Ain't No Mountain High Enough) - 7.5

Little Mix (Keep Me Hanging On) - 7.0

Marcus (Can You Feel It) - 5.0

 

Overall:

 

Misha B - 17.5/20.0

Little Mix - 16.5/20.0

Amelia Lily - 16.5/20.0

Marcus - 13.5/20.0

Misha B - F'kin Perfect || 10/10 || 'Rap like verses'.

I LOVE that this is spreading.

Well that was a rather disappointing semi final. :( I couldn't be arsed posting comments so tonight you get a nice little overall rate instead. :D

 

Amelia Lily - Ain't No Mountain High Enough 8/10

Amelia Lily - I'm With You 7/10

Little Mix - You Keep Me Hangin' On 6/10

Misha B - Dancing In the Street 6/10

Little Mix - If I Were A Boy 5/10

Marcus Collins - My Girl 5/10

Misha B - Perfect 4/10

Marcus Collins - Can You Feel It? 3/10

 

TOTAL

 

Amelia Lily = 15/20

Little Mix = 11/20

Misha B = 10/20

Marcus Collins = 8/20

 

I suspect Marcus suffered from nerves but his version of 'Can You Feel It?' was woeful. Then again, I thought Misha B completely oversang 'Perfect' to the point it lost its melody. :(

For me, in an ideal world Marcus would go tomorrow night... But I'm 95% certain it will be Misha.

What happened to Marcus he was at his worst. There would be no justice if Misha does no make it to Wembley none of the others can work a stage like her.

Tulisa and Gary were in a wretched mood. What happened to Survivor Liam-I thought Misha was trying to steal it from LM, best not to quote from DS.

I LOVE that this is spreading.

I remember, vaguely, Jark's original 13/10 'rap like verses' verdict on the song from when C&S was first released.

Kelly really is a miserable cow

 

Her face just then on Xtra Factor "Err how is that question for me?"

^ what was the question?

Ranking:

 

10/10

01 Misha - Perfect

02 Amelia - Ain't No Mountain High Enough

 

9.5/10

03 Little Mix - If I Were A Boy

 

9/10

04 Amelia - I'm With You

 

8.5/10

05 Misha - Dancing In The Street

06 Little Mix - You Keep Me Hanging On

 

 

6/10

07 Marcus - My Girl

 

 

 

 

4/10

08 Marcus - Can You Feel It

 

 

 

Despite it sounding dodgy on paper, Misha REALLY delivered with Perfect, I'm shocked it was the best of the night (Amelia wasn't far behind though!)

She did really well with ANMHE shockingly, soul isn't her bag and she so pulled it off, showed her versatility!

Little Mix delivered yet again with a ballad, what the hell was Gary on about? :wacko:

Amelia did justice to I'm With You, all the notes were right etc. but it wasn't quite the moment I expected...

Misha of course delivered as usual with Motown, it wasn't her best though and the dancers were distracting.

Little Mix were a little bit shaky in parts of You Keep Me Hanging On but it was pretty solid ^_^

 

 

Now Marcus... He can have a section of his own because he really did have an awful night... My Girl was really pitchy in places, but vocally soaring in others. Overall it was bad though, the performance as a whole just didn't work.

 

Then Can You Feel It was just SUCH a mess. It seemed like he couldn't be bothered to point where he was forcing it out, and vocally it was his worst since... well the start the live shows! I like him, it's a shame, but he really should go tomorrow. Positive - he looked SO fit tonight, get in my fucking bed Marcus!

 

 

------------------

Finally a Gary rant.

 

 

Honestly he is the worst judge I've seen in a LONG time, possibly ever, on a reality show. So incapeable of objectivity that he criticises Little Mix for a performance that was admittedly slightly off, yet still good, and then wetting over pitchy Marcus? -_- Then the needlessly nasty digs at Little Mix, it's because he's knows they'll win and he's jealous. He's so up himself that he thinks whoever he criticises, the public won't vote for... Well guess what Gary, dream on and FUCK OFF :)

 

 

Sorry, rant finished now.

Edited December 3, 201113 yr by Liаm

Kelly really is a miserable cow

 

Her face just then on Xtra Factor "Err how is that question for me?"

You really are quite ridiculous. The caller was speaking at Gary for the majority of the phone call, how on earth was Kelly meant to find the question hidden in there. And it's not as if Kelly said it in a "miserable" voice either... :rolleyes:

Misha Pefect so amazing my mum was almost crying hahaha voting loads for her