Wednesday at 11:301 day I much prefer picking our DNQ from previous years.Just now, gooddelta said:That's a good idea actually, maybe any DNQs from the decade to date? Rejects hasn't been held since then.I meant just for the 4 nations that didn't DNQ in 2026.
Wednesday at 11:321 day I didn't realise it had been so long since the last. I was mostly thinking in terms of making this an annual spin-off every December that gives all the DNQs of the year a moment of redemption. Could be a nice way to end the year and give a great song a second chance, rather than going backwards.
Wednesday at 11:371 day 3 minutes ago, Colm said:I much prefer picking our DNQ from previous years.I meant just for the 4 nations that didn't DNQ in 2026.Since it's been a while since the last Reject spin-off, wouldn't it be best for everyone to be able to choose an NQ from the lost years?
Wednesday at 11:381 day 5 minutes ago, blacksquare said:I didn't realise it had been so long since the last. I was mostly thinking in terms of making this an annual spin-off every December that gives all the DNQs of the year a moment of redemption. Could be a nice way to end the year and give a great song a second chance, rather than going backwards.If there are concerns about fairness, it could be that the entire list of 2026 DNQs is open to everyone, and then it is truly the 2026 Rejects Contest. Of course, if you sent the entry originally, then you get dibs.I have always wanted some kind of wrap up contest to celebrate the year in December, so I think that is mostly why I am pulling in that direction, but I understand not wanting that too
Wednesday at 11:411 day 2 minutes ago, blacksquare said:If there are concerns about fairness, it could be that the entire list of 2026 DNQs is open to everyone, and then it is truly the 2026 Rejects Contest. Of course, if you sent the entry originally, then you get dibs.I have always wanted some kind of wrap up contest to celebrate the year in December, so I think that is mostly why I am pulling in that direction, but I understand not wanting that tooOoh that's a really good idea actually! There would be many to choose from.
Wednesday at 11:451 day This looks like it's straying away from what I had in mind.I'll open this up for someone else to host. 🙃🙂 Edited Wednesday at 11:551 day by Colm
Wednesday at 11:571 day 14 minutes ago, Scene said:Ooh that's a really good idea actually! There would be many to choose from. I have the thread art direction in my head, an ugly splice of all the contests graphics this year Bald Martin sitting on Freezes recycling bin
Wednesday at 11:581 day 12 minutes ago, Colm said:This looks like it's straying away from what I had in mind.I'll open this up for someone else to host. 🙃🙂Maybe we can just stick to what you had in mind. It would be a shame for you to pass on your idea, I think we are just excited about it.
Wednesday at 12:041 day 2 minutes ago, gooddelta said:Maybe we can just stick to what you had in mind. It would be a shame for you to pass on your idea, I think we are just excited about it.Exactly thisI’m blinded by wanting an annual best of contest and cheering on all the DNQ songs of the year seemed like a great way of doing thatDon’t let my excitement ruin anything pls x
Wednesday at 12:071 day Apologies I was only adding my two cents - I'm very much for your spin-off idea Colm!
Wednesday at 12:091 day Limiting rejects to just this year does not sound appealing to me because that leaves me with just one option.Suffering from success. I have some bangers that DNQd in the past, I already have ideas. I vote that x
Wednesday at 12:111 day I don't want to force rules on anyone and it's really great that there's excitement. I didn't really expect this to take off so quickly. The competition is everyone's so the spin off rules should be decided by everyone. Edited Wednesday at 12:131 day by Colm
Wednesday at 12:141 day 3 minutes ago, pavi said:Limiting rejects to just this year does not sound appealing to me because that leaves me with just one option.Suffering from success. I have some bangers that DNQd in the past, I already have ideas. I vote that xMust be nice, my few DNQs are in the bin where they deserve to be x
Wednesday at 12:291 day In hindsight, my idea of opening it up to everyone and making it a 2026 DNQ contest only really benefits those who don't have many flops to choose from
Wednesday at 12:331 day I don't understand why the list of songs that have competed in BJSC isn't transferred to an Excel/Google spreadsheet. You could then easily search through it by sorting the results column and the edition number column, whereas manually extracting that information from the current list seems absolutely insane to me.A spreadsheet like that would also be useful in general. You could simply type in a song title to check whether it has already been entered, without having to scroll through the entire list. And if, like me, you don't keep track of points and results from every contest manually, you could just sort the country column, filter for your own country and have all your results neatly organised in one place.The same Google spreadsheet/Excel file could also have multiple sheets, with a separate list of songs for each contest on this forum (all in one place). And finally, even if the forum ever goes down, the list would still be stored in the cloud and remain accessible.
Create an account or sign in to comment