Wednesday at 10:531 day 1 minute ago, Colm said:I think they'll survive.They can do their own spin off with me, Bøtanikkä and Neliönoir.You should all pick a new song each that you think would definitely not make it out of a regular BJSC semi!
Wednesday at 10:541 day Just now, gooddelta said:You should all pick a new song each that you think would definitely not make it out of a regular BJSC semi!I dunno. I think a bit of exclusion wouldn't hurt us 😄
Wednesday at 10:561 day Just now, Colm said:I dunno. I think a bit of exclusion wouldn't hurt us 😄It hurts me I like this idea @gooddelta
Wednesday at 10:571 day 31 minutes ago, Colm said:I have been thinking about resurrecting the "rejects" competition.I'm not sure of all the regulations of older competitions but I would suggest that contestants submit one of their NQ entries from 2026 and we do a normal fine from those.I do miss the Rejects, it made DNQs feel slightly less deflating as you knew there was another time for them to shine down the line, and let people in the other semi hear them who might have missed them at the time.I remember Mary Keanes Introduction by Daithí came top three in the rejects in 2017 and I was elated as was certain it had fallen into the wrong semi, and most of its voters in Rejects were not people in the original semi who finally got to hear it.I liked it more than TBO personally, because winners and hits have had their time to shine. And in fact, it felt deflating if your winner/runner up then finished last in TBO, and not much like a celebration!
Wednesday at 10:581 day So here for a rejects spin-off! Wouldn't oppose allowing NQs from yesteryear too.
Wednesday at 11:081 day 7 minutes ago, Colm said:I'm happy to host in December?I’m pro Spod to host if Nelly are included If not then Rich would be better suited
Wednesday at 11:131 day Might be good to allow anything you feel unjustly flopped in another site contest as well. (Otherwise we only have 1 DNQ and everyone’s just heard it oops.)
Wednesday at 11:131 day 4 minutes ago, blacksquare said:I’m pro Spod to host if Nelly are includedFine
Wednesday at 11:131 day Just now, Julian_ said:Might be good to allow anything you feel unjustly flopped in another site contest as well. (Otherwise we only have 1 DNQ and everyone’s just heard it oops.)But your fan base loves that NQ
Wednesday at 11:201 day can we count bottom five in the final as a reject (so I can get some justice for Jump Source)
Wednesday at 11:211 day 6 minutes ago, Julian_ said:Might be good to allow anything you feel unjustly flopped in another site contest as well. (Otherwise we only have 1 DNQ and everyone’s just heard it oops.)Well you need to start flopping more frequently.
Wednesday at 11:211 day 2 minutes ago, blacksquare said:I’m pro Spod to host if Nelly are includedIf not then Rich would be better suited 9 minutes ago, Colm said:Rich to host then ☠️Not my family missing out on presents two years in a ROW.
Wednesday at 11:221 day Could I guess be extended to DNQ or your otherwise lowest placed entry of the year, to cover everyone. Or your choice from your bottom three performing entries. Edited Wednesday at 11:231 day by gooddelta
Wednesday at 11:251 day 1 minute ago, gooddelta said:Could I guess be extended to DNQ or your otherwise lowest placed entry of the year, to cover everyone. Or your choice from your bottom three performing entries.I think we should keep it to genuine rejects, perhaps those with 1 DNQ or none can choose any DNQ from the year? Then every DNQ is getting genuine representation. It could be quite interesting if a nation ends up with multiple rejects in the same contest.The confirmation spreadsheet would catch any double confirmations, and it would just default to the nation that sent it originallyIt’s a small prize for the more consistent nations of the year, rather than being something blatantly unfair
Wednesday at 11:281 day 5 minutes ago, gooddelta said:Could I guess be extended to DNQ or your otherwise lowest placed entry of the year, to cover everyone. Or your choice from your bottom three performing entries.Or previous years?
Wednesday at 11:291 day Just now, Colm said:Or previous years?That's a good idea actually, maybe any DNQs from the decade to date? Rejects hasn't been held since then.3 minutes ago, blacksquare said:I think we should keep it to genuine rejects, perhaps those with 1 DNQ or none can choose any DNQ from the year? Then every DNQ is getting genuine representation. It could be quite interesting if a nation ends up with multiple rejects in the same contest.The confirmation spreadsheet would catch any double confirmations, and it would just default to the nation that sent it originallyIt’s a small prize for the more consistent nations of the year, rather than being something blatantly unfairYes, or this. Edited Wednesday at 11:301 day by gooddelta
Create an account or sign in to comment