June 11, 201411 yr It's as if Mel B is trying to get on every talent show possible! That's the only thing that's putting me off, she should be a great judge but it's as if we're getting the leftovers :lol:
June 11, 201411 yr People are moaning that they have 4 judges that cant sing..... IMO when Cheryl sings live she has a good voice...she is no Mariah Carey (but she has never said she was) And Mel B CAN! She was on the Today Show in America last year to sing her single 'For Once In My Life' and she did VERY good IMO e0PkzgaoJ_4
June 11, 201411 yr I'm so pleased that Mel's got the job. :wub: She's certainly got the experience and credentials, thanks to being a judge on numerous different shows over the past few years. I just hope British viewers give her a chance! The online reaction to her confirmation seems to be quite mixed.
June 11, 201411 yr Caroline has confirmed her Xtra Factor exit :( GUTTED https://twitter.com/carolineflack1/status/476832182829584384 Maybe Sara Cox is presenting it?
June 11, 201411 yr Sarah-Jane Crawford is supposedly her replacement. :unsure: Just youtubed her :) she is actually good and has a wad of experience under her belt! Im excited to see how she does but i will miss Caroline ALOT! YhW_Opf8fEU
June 12, 201411 yr Thank god for that! Is it just me who absolutely cannot STAND Caroline Flack? I could tolerate her for Olly but I didn't bother much when Matt was presenting with her. From what I've seen/heard of Sarah, she's really good, I'd be fine with her taking up the role.
June 12, 201411 yr Sarah-Jane has officially been announced as Caroline's replacement :D Very random I guess but I'm happy with that.
June 12, 201411 yr Leona Lewis, Alexandra Burke and Melanie C have all expressed approval re: Mel B being the new judge! :wub:
June 12, 201411 yr Mel will need to step it up from her X Factor AU stint, she was good up till judges houses/lives then it all fell apart with bad selection of contestants and songs.
June 12, 201411 yr ...said no one... EVER. As I've already said, I have NEVER come across someone in my life who dislikes Sara Cox up until now. BAFFLED, some people here don't know PROPER NICENESS
June 12, 201411 yr We have CHERYL for niceness. We need someone like Mel B to be tough and brutally honest *.*
June 12, 201411 yr I think Mel B is a great choice. I loved her guest judge appearances so having her full time should be amazing especially in the auditions where she can be 'mean' to people who deserve the criticism
June 12, 201411 yr Oh, I can see why Mel B would be better at judging - but Sara for Xtra Factor SURELY?
June 12, 201411 yr Sarah Jane Crawford sounds like a good Xtra Factor host from that video of her earlier in the thread. Better than Caroline Flack anyway, I never watched Xtra Factor with her on it.
June 12, 201411 yr I've seen Sarah Jane on a few stuff before and I think she will be good on Xtra Factor although I will miss Caroline .
Create an account or sign in to comment