June 29, 201411 yr Missing You is incredible :wub: certainly in my top 5 Sats singles, should be a lot higher here imo. Caught In a Moment is stunning too <3
June 29, 201411 yr Oops at 'Wings' I expected top 20 easily for 'Wings' - looks like 'Move' will be performing best on here! Poor 'Not Giving Up' :(
June 29, 201411 yr Author The top 50 will be revealed tomorrow! Here they are in alphabetical order: All Saints - Black Coffee All Saints - Never Ever All Saints - Pure Shores All Saints - Rock Steady Girls Aloud - Biology Girls Aloud - Call The Shots Girls Aloud - Love Machine Girls Aloud - No Good Advice Girls Aloud - Sexy! No No No… Girls Aloud - Something Kinda Ooooh Girls Aloud - Something New Girls Aloud - Sound Of The Underground Girls Aloud - The Loving Kind Girls Aloud - The Promise Girls Aloud - The Show Girls Aloud - Untouchable Little Mix - DNA Little Mix - Move Little Mix - Salute Spice Girls - 2 Become 1 Spice Girls - Goodbye Spice Girls - Say You'll Be There Spice Girls - Spice Up Your Life Spice Girls - Stop Spice Girls - Viva Forever Spice Girls - Wannabe Spice Girls - Who Do You Think You Are Sugababes - About You Now Sugababes - Change Sugababes - Denial Sugababes - Easy Sugababes - Freak Like Me Sugababes - Hole In The Head Sugababes - In The Middle Sugababes - Overload Sugababes - Push The Button Sugababes - Red Dress Sugababes - Round Round Sugababes - Stronger Sugababes - Too Lost In You Sugababes - Ugly The Saturdays - All Fired Up The Saturdays - Disco Love The Saturdays - Ego The Saturdays - Higher (ft. Flo Rida) The Saturdays - Issues The Saturdays - Notorious The Saturdays - Up The Saturdays - What About Us (ft. Sean Paul) The Saturdays - Work Any surprises in the top 50? What's everyone predictions for the top single for each girl band?
June 29, 201411 yr Despite the opinion of most people Missing You will always be one of my favourite singles by The Saturdays, so I am gutted it has gone out. I can't help but think had it stayed at number 1 from the midweeks people would look back on it and not have turned on it. Sad about About A Girl. I think if this was done in a few years time Not Giving Up would be higher.
June 29, 201411 yr Work and Issues don't deserve top 50! Very surprised at Wings early exit - BUT DNA STAYS? :huh:
June 29, 201411 yr Okay, well Not Giving Up beating Wings is quite the disgrace. There's nothing to NGU whatsoever. :(
June 29, 201411 yr Very shocked at 'Wings' so low :o I mean, it's not aging too well for me but it's still such a good pop song.
June 29, 201411 yr Okay, well Not Giving Up beating Wings is quite the disgrace. There's nothing to NGU whatsoever. :( !!!!!!!!!!! RUN INTO THE DART. http://media.giphy.com/media/Zhq33zPH8wbPq/giphy.gif
June 29, 201411 yr I like Wings, it's just Move's presence a year later just really makes it look bad (though it's better than DNA and Salute surely?). Missing You is bad, not offensively so, but autotune combined with an already dull ballad is just...bleh. (Also, Now Rate results plus for those who care) Edited June 29, 201411 yr by Chez Wombat
June 29, 201411 yr I like Wings, it's just Move's presence a year later just really makes it look bad (though it's better than DNA and Salute surely?). Missing You is bad, not offensively so, but autotune combined with an already dull ballad is just...bleh. (Also, Now Rate results plus for those who care) http://static.fjcdn.com/pictures/Nobody_626af1_1765509.jpg
June 29, 201411 yr SOMETHING NEW TO WIN My faves per girl group: All Saints - Rock Steady Girls Aloud - Something New Little Mix - Salute Spice Girls - Spice Up Your Life Sugababes - About You Now The Saturdays - Notorious All of them are my faves per group anyway, bar Salute. How Ya Doin'? robbed :cry:
June 29, 201411 yr Lee, I understand my slight of Not Giving Up hits you where it hurts but there's no need to insult Chez like that. !!!!!!!!!!! RUN INTO THE DART. http://media.giphy.com/media/Zhq33zPH8wbPq/giphy.gif However, I'm so glad you're back. :heart:
June 29, 201411 yr Lee, I understand my slight of Not Giving Up hits you where it hurts but there's no need to insult Chez like that. However, I'm so glad you're back. :heart: It hit me so hard out of nowhere - I was starstuck up in the air . My eyes are wide open now though. TRAITOR.
June 29, 201411 yr Despite the opinion of most people Missing You will always be one of my favourite singles by The Saturdays, so I am gutted it has gone out. I can't help but think had it stayed at number 1 from the midweeks people would look back on it and not have turned on it. Sad about About A Girl. I think if this was done in a few years time Not Giving Up would be higher.I actually think a similar thing to 'My Heart Takes Over'. I swear that when it premiered, people were predicting it to do well, due to the time of year (winter ballad etc..) and were loving it/thinking it would be a great single, but then when it did as poorly as it did in the charts, that's when people turned their backs on it, it seemed. Undeservedly so. Such a huge, power ballad. It deserved so much more! Gutted it didn't make the top 50 here, but at the same time it is about 10 places higher than I thought it'd get, so I'm taking whatever I can! I will never get this forums mad obsession with 'Can't Speak French'!? :huh: That's a B-Side sort of track if ever I heard one! Poor 'Black Jack'/'Girl Overboard', robbed from being a single. 'Little Me' is very nice and the message behind it is great, but it's just a little too safe, for me. Such a big soft spot for 'Wake Me Up' too! Then of course, the epic and timeless classic, 'Too Much'. 'About A Girl' is one of the better Suga 4.0 singles, but I prefer 'Get Sexy' (and about 3 or 4 other tracks from 'Sweet 7' Yes. 'Sweet & Amazing' is included in that! :ph34r: :wub:) 'Missing You' gets far too much schtick. It's a great song that's aged very well, I think. 'Wings' is magnificent and is truly how a girl group should make their debut today! Very surprised to see it beaten by both 'DNA' & 'Salute', though! :o 'Caught In A Moment' is lovely. I have it on CD single somewhere <3 And finally 'Not Giving Up' it's a good song and was worthy of being a single (the single mix :wub:) but it's a tad overrated.
June 29, 201411 yr Seriously! If This Is Love & My Heart Takes Over both out :cry: If This Is Love is my fave Sats Single ever And MHTO is in my top 5! Such an injustice! I actually had MHTO pegged for the top 10 on release week :drama: Oh and a special mention to the Catfights & Spotlights era. Flawless album! Edited June 29, 201411 yr by JSG
June 29, 201411 yr I will never get this forums mad obsession with 'Can't Speak French'!? :huh: That's a B-Side sort of track if ever I heard one! Poor 'Black Jack'/'Girl Overboard', robbed from being a single. :o http://i.imgur.com/OWj29dS.gif :( I could perhaps understand the wish for it to have been kept as an (excellent) album track, but a song like that was never going to be considered as B Side only worthy! I'd disagree with your feeling that there's a mad obsession with the song on this forum. The impression I get is that it's not too well liked across the forum, which is reflected by it not being within the top half of Girls Aloud singles here, and it not making the Top 15 of the 2008 ROTD (which if I'm correct will make it one of the only Girls Aloud singles not to either be an Auto-qualifier or make it through the playoffs! :o ) P.S. I'm shocked that 'Wings' isn't in the Top 50!
June 29, 201411 yr I actually think a similar thing to 'My Heart Takes Over'. I swear that when it premiered, people were predicting it to do well, due to the time of year (winter ballad etc..) and were loving it/thinking it would be a great single, but then when it did as poorly as it did in the charts, that's when people turned their backs on it, it seemed. Undeservedly so. Such a huge, power ballad. It deserved so much more! Gutted it didn't make the top 50 here, but at the same time it is about 10 places higher than I thought it'd get, so I'm taking whatever I can! I agree tbh, I've had similar thoughts (and the same kinda thing for "Unconditionally") but maybe it's just because I love those songs so much..:unsure: Completely agree about "Can't Speak French" too! I just find it so annoying and easily the worst GA single (ahead of "The Promise" :ph34r:)
June 29, 201411 yr Quite surprised at 'Wings' and 'Not Giving Up' missing the top 50. Pleasantly so with the former, I've really tried but I just can't get into it that much. The latter I initially thought was overrated when everyone was demanding it be released as a single, but the single mix added a nice little touch to it. 'Caught In A Moment' is lovely, and I'd say probably their most underrated single? Heidi sounds brilliant on it. 'Missing You' has some fairly nice lyrics I guess, but otherwise it's just a bit tedious. I've never understood why people hold 'About A Girl' in such high regards either. It sounds just as generic as the rest of the 'Sweet 7' material. I really like pretty much everything that's left now, but I'd choose 'Ugly', 'Easy', 'The Promise', 'Issues' and 'What About Us' to go next.
Create an account or sign in to comment