Jump to content

Should've been a single! 22 members have voted

  1. 1. Which of these songs stand out as missed single opportunities?

    • Girl Overboard
      10
    • Graffiti My Soul
      2
    • Miss You Bow Wow
      2
    • On The Metro
      15
    • Wild Horses
      1

Please sign in or register to vote in this poll.

Featured Replies

Posted

http://25.media.tumblr.com/tumblr_mc59sa3w3f1roh2gxo1_500.gif

 

Your final 5:

 

Girl Overboard

Graffiti My Soul

Miss You Bow Wow

On The Metro

Wild Horses

 

Which one is the leader of the pack? *.* You decide!

 

Remember, the theme is Should've been a single. There's no limit to how many you can vote for, but maybe it'd be best to select no more than 3 choices.

 

This final round will be open until 23:59 on Tuesday 30th August, so be quick. The song with the most votes will go forward as Girls Aloud's entry in the contest!

 

--------------------

 

Here are the other nominated songs and how many nominations they received!

 

6 Close to Love

5 Black Jacks

4 Models

3 Put Your Hands Up (Nadine)

3 Screw You (Cheryl)

3 Waiting

3 Watch Me Go

2 Cinderella's Eyes (Nicola)

2 Control Of The Knife

2 Every Now and Then

2 Girls Allowed

2 Love Is Pain

2 Love is the Key

2 Rain On Me (Cheryl)

2 Rolling Back The Rivers In Time

2 Stand Up (Cheryl)

2 Swinging London Town

2 Waiting (Cheryl)

1 A Million Lights (Cheryl)

1 Androgynous Girls

1 Big Brother

1 Crazy Fool

1 Deadlines and Diets

1 Fix Me Up

1 Fling

1 Ghetto Baby (Cheryl)

1 I'm Falling

1 Memory Of You

1 Revolution In The Head

1 Say It Out Loud (Nicola)

1 Sexy Den A Mutha (Cheryl)

1 Some Kind of Miracle

1 You Freak Me Out

 

As for the number of nominations the Top 5 received, I'll reveal that information after this poll has closed. ;o #mysterious

  • Replies 11
  • Views 1.6k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

It was tough between Girl Overboard and On the Metro but I went for the latter, purely because what got released instead (ie. Beautiful Cause You Love Me) was less good by quite a margin. I can't moan at any of the Tangled Up singles, I'd have just rather had Girl Overboard as a fourth single on top of them!

 

I mean, you can't say that starting with Sound of the UNDERGROUND and finishing with On the METRO wouldn't have been totally iconic.

  • Author
I mean, you can't say that starting with Sound of the UNDERGROUND and finishing with On the METRO wouldn't have been totally iconic.

PRECISELY, such a missed opportunity! :snif: And what an explosive end to their singles run it would have been! *.*

I managed to narrow it down to 3, 'Girl Overboard', 'Graffiti My Soul' and 'On The Metro'. They all really should've been singles.
It was tough between Girl Overboard and On the Metro but I went for the latter, purely because what got released instead (ie. Beautiful Cause You Love Me) was less good by quite a margin. I can't moan at any of the Tangled Up singles, I'd have just rather had Girl Overboard as a fourth single on top of them!

 

I mean, you can't say that starting with Sound of the UNDERGROUND and finishing with On the METRO wouldn't have been totally iconic.

I agree with this. Girls Aloud have had a fantastic string of singles so it's hard to say one song should have been released instead of another, in regards to their studio albums that is. I love 'Beautiful Cause You Love Me' but it clearly didn't resonate with fans and it was well-established at the time that 'On the Metro' was the favourite. I've never even picked up on the similarities of those two titles but you are quite right that would have been a great way to package their singles discography together.

 

However, personal taste tells me 'Every Now and Then' > 'On the Metro'.

 

'Girl Overboard' very much sounds like a single but the three that were chosen were perfect so I can't say it was a missed opportunity as such. They could have released it as a fourth single but the download market was picking up by this point and they'd have risked ending their Top 10 streak earlier.

 

Surprised 'Miss You Bow Wow' was such a popular choice. I mean, I absolutely love it, but it's not what I'd expect people to get behind. I suppose it is a throwback to their earlier pop material following the more mature three singles from Out of Control.

'On The Metro' slaying :yahoo: Lets hope the rest of Buzzjack like it! :kink:

Edited by ___∆___

Voted girl over board because it's actually one of my favourite girls aloud tracks. I did also like can't speak French very much but there was something about girl overboard & where I was in my life back then that connected with me. I also thought on the metro was great which looks set to win - would have made a great video.
Went for 'On The Metro' and 'Girl Overboard'! It is baffling why they left us with 'Beautiful Cause You Love Me' when they could have gone out with a BANG with 'On The Metro'. Then 'Girl Overboard' has always struck me as a huge highlight from Tangled Up that would have made a good single #4.
Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.