I really like this. It's quite credible and better than perfect illulison.

I must be the only person who prefers Perfect Illusion as beautiful as this is, give me that chaos gaga I love.

Edited October 8, 20168 yr by Mackenzie

This song is really starting to tug on my heartstrings. I actually think it could work as a single, especially the way it seems to be holding up on iTunes, or at least another song from the album of a similar vein. Regardless, I need a live performance of this!

If radio took to it then I agree it could work as a single, it's simple and I think that would be refreshing from her.

Definitely! It does feel like she's become less "showy" this era so some simple ballads that are elevated by her voice would complement that well whilst still being special enough to be recognisable as Gaga and different to any other radio-friendly ballad.

Here's that performance you wanted, Liam :P

 

https://www.facebook.com/10376464573/videos...53935796915095/

 

This song is SO beautiful. I'm pleased to see this is holding up for her! :o

Thank you! It really is a song she can put her all into whilst maintaining its melody and gentleness.

Isn't the reason it's holding up is because Million Reasons is an instant grat for Joanne? :unsure:

Instant grats now only appear on the iTunes chart solely for actual purchases of the song rather than album pre-orders affecting its position. That feels like a really badly written sentence but hopefully you'll get the gist of what I'm saying! :P

Yes it does, thanks!!

 

I'm surprised it's holding on slightly better than Perfect Illusion even with minimal airplay too! It could work as a single later on perhaps (but please give me a pop jam Gaga I'm so thirsty for it)

Have you heard Ayo? It is a JAM!!

No Michael! I've been trying to hold out on listening to any leaks and gig performances so I get the full experience whenever the album releases!

Ayo is another Fypsy.

 

She released Perfect Flop when she has a Gypsy quality song right there.

 

Tshh tshh.

This is no where as good as 'Gypsy'. PI >>>>

 

This is nice. And pretty forgetful at the same time. It's a 7/10 on a good day.

No, Ayo, not this.

Still need to hear that. I was questioning your sanity last night! Lmfao.

(So nothing's changed basically)

I wish this was the second single, it's a really understated beauty and I feel as though Heart FM and the like would get back on board with her with a song like this.

 

Probably the best Gaga song I've heard since Do What U Want.

I do think this would be the best option for second single. Is 'A-Yo' absolutely conclusively confirmed as the second single?

This is starting to run away from the rest of the album for me, especially with the SNL performance :wub: I can't believe I wasn't feeling this at first, it's so simply beautiful and I defintiely think it's the best choice for next single. A-Yo would just flop entirely and I know that nothing really has a chance to smash or anything but as has been said this would at least stand a chance at attaining a fair bit of airplay.