Posted October 2, 20177 yr With their potentially imminent reformation (that will not happen but WE CAN DREAM) what better time to look back on one of the defining girl groups of the 00s? We had one in 2013 but it's interresting to seee how things have changed and how the solo From stripper anthems like Buttons to sweet ballads like Stickwitu, Nicole and her backing dancers gave it all but what's heir best song in the eyes of Buzzjack? Or will a solo anthem from Nicole trump ll? :o (I'm leaving out the irrelavant solo ones so it's really just Nicole and a few tracks from Ashley/Kim but oh well) RULES: - Please try and rate most of them, the links are there for a reason. I get that the others will be a bit more obscure so if you leave out like Ashley and kimberly's stuff it's not the end of the world. - You can use any score from 1 to 10, including decimals, but not 0.5 or 10.5. - You can use ONE 11 or ONE -1 for the group singles, and one more of each for the solo singles, but these are optional. - you have until 17th October to rate these, plenty of time to listen and reminiscence! Pussycat Dolls: xx xx xx xx xx xx xx xx xx xx xx Solo: xx xx xx xx xx xx xx xx xx xx xx xx xx xx xx xx xx xx
October 2, 20177 yr Author Pussycat Dolls: 10 Don't Cha (ft. Busta Rhymes) 09 Stickwitu 09 Beep (ft. will.i.am.) 11 Buttons 09 I Don't Need a Man 08 Wait A Minute (ft. Timbaland) 09 When I Grow Up 06.5 Whatcha Think About That? (ft. Missy Elliot) (the missy rap is ICONIC tho) 10 I Hate This Part 10 Jai Ho (A.R. Rahman & Nicole Scherzinger ft. Pussycat Dolls 09.5 Hush Hush; Hush Hush Solo: 05 Come To Me (w/ P Diddy) (Nicole) 06 Whatever U Like (ft. T.I.) (Nicole) 07 Baby Love (Nicole) 07 Scream (w/ Timbaland & Keri Hilson) (Nicole) 09.5 Heartbeat (w/ Enrique Iglesias) (Nicole) 10 Poison (Nicole) 11 Don't Hold Your Breath (Nicole) 07.5 Right Here (Nicole) 10 Wet (Nicole) 09.5 Try With Me (Nicole) 07 Boomerang (Nicole) 07 Your Love (Nicole) 08 Run (Nicole) 03 On the Rocks (Nicole) 06.5 Clockwork (Ashley) 08 Woman Up (Ashley) 09 Stars In Your Eyes (w/ Her Majesty & The Wolves) (Kimberley) 10 Candy (w/ Aggro Santos) (Kimberley)
October 3, 20177 yr Pussycat Dolls: 08.5 Don't Cha (ft. Busta Rhymes) 09.0 Stickwitu 10.0 Beep (ft. will.i.am.) 07.0 Buttons 11.0 I Don't Need a Man 08.0 Wait A Minute (ft. Timbaland) 09.0 When I Grow Up 06.0 Whatcha Think About That? (ft. Missy Elliot) 09.0 I Hate This Part 07.5 Jai Ho (A.R. Rahman & Nicole Scherzinger ft. Pussycat Dolls) 06.5 Hush Hush; Hush Hush --- Solo: 10.0 Come To Me (w/ P Diddy) (Nicole) 10.0 Whatever U Like (ft. T.I.) (Nicole) 08.5 Baby Love (Nicole) 07.0 Scream (w/ Timbaland & Keri Hilson) (Nicole) 07.5 Heartbeat (w/ Enrique Iglesias) (Nicole) 10.0 Poison (Nicole) 10.0 Don't Hold Your Breath (Nicole) 11.0 Right There (Nicole) 08.5 Wet (Nicole) 07.5 Try With Me (Nicole) 10.0 Boomerang (Nicole) 08.0 Your Love (Nicole) 09.0 Run (Nicole) 10.0 On the Rocks (Nicole) xx Clockwork (Ashley) xx Woman Up (Ashley) xx Stars In Your Eyes (w/ Her Majesty & The Wolves) (Kimberley) 07.5 Candy (w/ Aggro Santos) (Kimberley) Holy f***. Nicole's practically flawless. I f***ing love her. OTR in particular is far too under appreciated. I find it really addictive!
October 3, 20177 yr Pussycat Dolls: 4.0 Don't Cha (ft. Busta Rhymes) -- grossly overrated and how this was their biggest worldwide hit I have no idea 8.5 Stickwitu -- the middle-8 is perfection 10.0 Beep (ft. will.i.am.) -- should've done better in the US 11.0 Buttons -- their best, should've outperformed Don't Cha and probably would've had it not been the fourth single 9.0 I Don't Need a Man -- guilty pleasure 8.5 Wait A Minute (ft. Timbaland) -- another one that deserved better 8.5 When I Grow Up -- hasn't aged well 6.5 Whatcha Think About That? (ft. Missy Elliot) -- why was this even released? nearly derailed the entire era in the US 9.0 I Hate This Part -- this fortunately saved it 8.0 Jai Ho (A.R. Rahman & Nicole Scherzinger ft. Pussycat Dolls) -- when everything started to fall apart -1.0 Hush Hush; Hush Hush -- an absolute atrocity Solo: 9.0 Come To Me (w/ P Diddy) (Nicole) -- love this track, quintessential 2006 8.0 Whatever U Like (ft. T.I.) (Nicole) -- had the makings to be a hit 6.0 Baby Love (Nicole) -- snooze fest, how did this outperform WUL? 8.0 Scream (w/ Timbaland & Keri Hilson) (Nicole) -- Nicole's verse is lush 6.5 Heartbeat (w/ Enrique Iglesias) (Nicole) -- I expected a much better result from these two collaborating 9.5 Poison (Nicole) -- I remember losing my mind when I heard the snippets 11.0 Don't Hold Your Breath (Nicole) -- best PCD solo single now and forever 9.5 Right Here (Nicole) -- another bop 8.0 Wet (Nicole) -- and another one, albeit forgettable 6.0 Try With Me (Nicole) -- unnecessary release 8.5 Boomerang (Nicole) -- love it but too campy 9.5 Your Love (Nicole) -- #2 on sales, never forget 3.5 Run (Nicole) -- boring 6.5 On the Rocks (Nicole) -- slightly less boring 7.0 Clockwork (Ashley) -- better than Baby Love 8.0 Woman Up (Ashley) -- so good Meghan Trainor had to have it 8.5 Stars In Your Eyes (w/ Her Majesty & The Wolves) (Kimberley) -- such a tune and loved the video 7.5 Candy (w/ Aggro Santos) (Kimberley) -- you know Nicole was fuming that this made the Top 5 And I know it wasn't included but Bottle Pop would get an 8.5.
October 3, 20177 yr Ugh. Buttons is going to win, isn't it? Now that's the definition of overrated imo. :(
October 3, 20177 yr Pussycat Dolls: 09.0 Don't Cha (ft. Busta Rhymes) 08.0 Stickwitu 09.5 Beep (ft. will.i.am.) 10.0 Buttons 10.0 I Don't Need a Man 10.0 Wait A Minute (ft. Timbaland) 09.0 When I Grow Up 07.5 Whatcha Think About That? (ft. Missy Elliot) 11.0 I Hate This Part 09.5 Jai Ho (A.R. Rahman & Nicole Scherzinger ft. Pussycat Dolls 08.5 Hush Hush; Hush Hush Solo: 06.5 Come To Me (w/ P Diddy) (Nicole) 06.0 Whatever U Like (ft. T.I.) (Nicole) 07.5 Baby Love (Nicole) 09.0 Scream (w/ Timbaland & Keri Hilson) (Nicole) 07.0 Heartbeat (w/ Enrique Iglesias) (Nicole) 09.0 Poison (Nicole) 08.5 Don't Hold Your Breath (Nicole) 08.5 Right Here (Nicole) 08.0 Wet (Nicole) 09.0 Try With Me (Nicole) 04.0 Boomerang (Nicole) 07.5 Your Love (Nicole) 07.0 Run (Nicole) 01.0 On the Rocks (Nicole) 04.5 Clockwork (Ashley) 05.0 Woman Up (Ashley) 04.0 Stars In Your Eyes (w/ Her Majesty & The Wolves) (Kimberley) 06.0 Candy (w/ Aggro Santos) (Kimberley) It is really hard to rate the solo singles on the same rate as all the PCD singles. Normally I would have been tempted to give songs like 'Poison' a 10 and I would have definitely considered doing something close with 'Don't Hold Your Breath' etc. if it was just a solo rate, but the PCD were so iconic and next level that I've had to somewhat mark them down.
October 3, 20177 yr Ugh. Buttons is going to win, isn't it? Now that's the definition of overrated imo. :( It's the stripper anthem of our generation, embrace it
October 3, 20177 yr Pussycat Dolls: 08 Don't Cha (ft. Busta Rhymes) 10 Stickwitu 10 Beep (ft. will.i.am.) 10 Buttons 10 I Don't Need a Man 09 Wait A Minute (ft. Timbaland) 08 When I Grow Up 07 Whatcha Think About That? (ft. Missy Elliot) 11 I Hate This Part 09 Jai Ho (A.R. Rahman & Nicole Scherzinger ft. Pussycat Dolls) 08 Hush Hush; Hush Hush Solo: 09 Come To Me (w/ P Diddy) (Nicole) 09 Whatever U Like (ft. T.I.) (Nicole) 08 Baby Love (Nicole) 08 Scream (w/ Timbaland & Keri Hilson) (Nicole) 06 Heartbeat (w/ Enrique Iglesias) (Nicole) 10 Poison (Nicole) 11 Don't Hold Your Breath (Nicole) 08 Right Here (Nicole) 09 Wet (Nicole) 09 Try With Me (Nicole) 07 Boomerang (Nicole) 08 Your Love (Nicole) 06 Run (Nicole) 07 On the Rocks (Nicole) 07 Clockwork (Ashley) 07 Woman Up (Ashley) 05 Stars In Your Eyes (w/ Her Majesty & The Wolves) (Kimberley) 08 Candy (w/ Aggro Santos) (Kimberley) What a discography :wub:
October 3, 20177 yr Pussycat Dolls: 11 Don't Cha (ft. Busta Rhymes) 09 Stickwitu 07 Beep (ft. will.i.am.) 07 Buttons 08 I Don't Need a Man 06 Wait A Minute (ft. Timbaland) 07 When I Grow Up 07 Whatcha Think About That? (ft. Missy Elliot) 06 I Hate This Part 06 Jai Ho (A.R. Rahman & Nicole Scherzinger ft. Pussycat Dolls) 08 Hush Hush; Hush Hush Solo: 09 Come To Me (w/ P Diddy) (Nicole) 04 Whatever U Like (ft. T.I.) (Nicole) 03 Baby Love (Nicole) 04 Scream (w/ Timbaland & Keri Hilson) (Nicole) 04 Heartbeat (w/ Enrique Iglesias) (Nicole) 05 Poison (Nicole) 06 Don't Hold Your Breath (Nicole) 06 Right Here (Nicole) 04 Wet (Nicole) 04 Try With Me (Nicole) 04 Boomerang (Nicole) 03 Your Love (Nicole) 03 Run (Nicole) 01 On the Rocks (Nicole) 01 Clockwork (Ashley) 01 Woman Up (Ashley) 02 Stars In Your Eyes (w/ Her Majesty & The Wolves) (Kimberley) 02 Candy (w/ Aggro Santos) (Kimberley)
October 3, 20177 yr Pussycat Dolls: 11 Don't Cha (ft. Busta Rhymes) 10 Stickwitu 09 Beep (ft. will.i.am.) 10 Buttons 08 I Don't Need a Man 06 Wait A Minute (ft. Timbaland) 08 When I Grow Up 07 Whatcha Think About That? (ft. Missy Elliot) 09 I Hate This Part 10 Jai Ho (A.R. Rahman & Nicole Scherzinger ft. Pussycat Dolls) 05 Hush Hush; Hush Hush Solo: 07 Come To Me (w/ P Diddy) (Nicole) 03 Whatever U Like (ft. T.I.) (Nicole) 04 Baby Love (Nicole) 08 Scream (w/ Timbaland & Keri Hilson) (Nicole) 08 Heartbeat (w/ Enrique Iglesias) (Nicole) 10 Poison (Nicole) 10 Don't Hold Your Breath (Nicole) 09 Right Here (Nicole) 07 Wet (Nicole) 02 Try With Me (Nicole) 06 Boomerang (Nicole) 06 Your Love (Nicole) 04 Run (Nicole) 01 On the Rocks (Nicole) 03 Clockwork (Ashley) 05 Woman Up (Ashley) 06 Stars In Your Eyes (w/ Her Majesty & The Wolves) (Kimberley) 07 Candy (w/ Aggro Santos) (Kimberley)
October 4, 20177 yr Pussycat Dolls: 10 Don't Cha (ft. Busta Rhymes) 10 Stickwitu 05 Beep (ft. will.i.am.) 11 Buttons 08 I Don't Need a Man 07 Wait A Minute (ft. Timbaland) 09 When I Grow Up 05 Whatcha Think About That? (ft. Missy Elliot) 09 I Hate This Part 08 Jai Ho (A.R. Rahman & Nicole Scherzinger ft. Pussycat Dolls) 10 Hush Hush; Hush Hush Solo: 05 Come To Me (w/ P Diddy) (Nicole) 06 Whatever U Like (ft. T.I.) (Nicole) 09 Baby Love (Nicole) 09 Scream (w/ Timbaland & Keri Hilson) (Nicole) 06 Heartbeat (w/ Enrique Iglesias) (Nicole) 08 Poison (Nicole) 09 Don't Hold Your Breath (Nicole) 06 Right Here (Nicole) 08 Wet (Nicole) 08 Try With Me (Nicole) 08 Boomerang (Nicole) 05 Your Love (Nicole) 10 Run (Nicole) 08 On the Rocks (Nicole) 07 Clockwork (Ashley) 07 Woman Up (Ashley) 06 Stars In Your Eyes (w/ Her Majesty & The Wolves) (Kimberley) 06 Candy (w/ Aggro Santos) (Kimberley)
October 4, 20177 yr Pussycat Dolls: 07 Don't Cha (ft. Busta Rhymes) 08 Stickwitu 003 Beep (ft. will.i.am.) 02 Buttons 08 I Don't Need a Man 05 Wait A Minute (ft. Timbaland) 07 When I Grow Up 09 Whatcha Think About That? (ft. Missy Elliot) 09 I Hate This Part 10 Jai Ho (A.R. Rahman & Nicole Scherzinger ft. Pussycat Dolls) 11 Hush Hush; Hush Hush Solo: 04 Come To Me (w/ P Diddy) (Nicole) 03 Whatever U Like (ft. T.I.) (Nicole) 04 Baby Love (Nicole) 05 Scream (w/ Timbaland & Keri Hilson) (Nicole) 07 Heartbeat (w/ Enrique Iglesias) (Nicole) 11 Poison (Nicole) 10 Don't Hold Your Breath (Nicole) 06 Right Here (Nicole) 08 Wet (Nicole) 09 Try With Me (Nicole) 08 Boomerang (Nicole) 07 Your Love (Nicole) 08 Run (Nicole) 07 On the Rocks (Nicole) 05 Clockwork (Ashley) 05 Woman Up (Ashley) 06 Stars In Your Eyes (w/ Her Majesty & The Wolves) (Kimberley) 05 Candy (w/ Aggro Santos) (Kimberley)
October 4, 20177 yr Pussycat Dolls: 10 Don't Cha (ft. Busta Rhymes) 07 Stickwitu 11 Beep (ft. will.i.am.) 03 Buttons 08 I Don't Need a Man 09 Wait A Minute (ft. Timbaland) -1 When I Grow Up 05 Whatcha Think About That? (ft. Missy Elliot) 04 I Hate This Part 08 Jai Ho (A.R. Rahman & Nicole Scherzinger ft. Pussycat Dolls) 01 Hush Hush; Hush Hush Solo: 05 Come To Me (w/ P Diddy) (Nicole) 01 Whatever U Like (ft. T.I.) (Nicole) 01 Baby Love (Nicole) 01 Scream (w/ Timbaland & Keri Hilson) (Nicole) 07 Heartbeat (w/ Enrique Iglesias) (Nicole) 08 Poison (Nicole) 10 Don't Hold Your Breath (Nicole) 01 Right Here (Nicole) 02 Wet (Nicole) 05 Try With Me (Nicole) 07 Boomerang (Nicole) 08 Your Love (Nicole) (your love makes me feel like WHAT? :jameela:) 02 Run (Nicole) 01 On the Rocks (Nicole) 06 Clockwork (Ashley) 06 Woman Up (Ashley) 06 Stars In Your Eyes (w/ Her Majesty & The Wolves) (Kimberley) 07 Candy (w/ Aggro Santos) (Kimberley)
October 4, 20177 yr Pussycat Dolls: 09 Don't Cha (ft. Busta Rhymes) 08 Stickwitu 07.5 Beep (ft. will.i.am.) 10 Buttons 09.5 I Don't Need a Man 06 Wait A Minute (ft. Timbaland) 10 When I Grow Up 11 Whatcha Think About That? (ft. Missy Elliot) 09.5 I Hate This Part 09 Jai Ho (A.R. Rahman & Nicole Scherzinger ft. Pussycat Dolls) 08.5 Hush Hush; Hush Hush Solo: 06.5 Come To Me (w/ P Diddy) (Nicole) 07.5 Whatever U Like (ft. T.I.) (Nicole) 07 Baby Love (Nicole) 08 Scream (w/ Timbaland & Keri Hilson) (Nicole) 09.5 Heartbeat (w/ Enrique Iglesias) (Nicole) 08 Poison (Nicole) 08.5 Don't Hold Your Breath (Nicole) 11 Right Here (Nicole) 09 Wet (Nicole) 07.5 Try With Me (Nicole) 06 Boomerang (Nicole) 04.0 Your Love (Nicole) 06 Run (Nicole) 05 On the Rocks (Nicole) -1 Clockwork (Ashley) 05 Woman Up (Ashley) 04 Stars In Your Eyes (w/ Her Majesty & The Wolves) (Kimberley) 09 Candy (w/ Aggro Santos) (Kimberley)
October 9, 20177 yr PCD: 09 Don't Cha (ft. Busta Rhymes) 05 Stickwitu 07 Beep (ft. will.i.am.) 09 Buttons FT SNOOP DOGGY DOGG 06 I Don't Need a Man 05 Wait A Minute (ft. Timbaland) 05 When I Grow Up 07 Whatcha Think About That? (ft. Missy Elliot) would be lower without Missy’s rap 11 I Hate This Part 10 Jai Ho (A.R. Rahman & Nicole Scherzinger ft. Pussycat Dolls) 10 Hush Hush; Hush Hush Solo: 02 Come To Me (w/ P Diddy) (Nicole) 02 Whatever U Like (ft. T.I.) (Nicole) 05 Baby Love (Nicole) 00 Scream (w/ Timbaland & Keri Hilson) (Nicole) 06 Heartbeat (w/ Enrique Iglesias) (Nicole) 09 Poison (Nicole) 10 Don't Hold Your Breath (Nicole) 6 years later, this still doesn’t feel like a #1 single, as much as I love it :lol: 11 Right Here (Nicole) 10 Wet (Nicole) 06 Try With Me (Nicole) The standard album was excellent and then she brought it down with this 07 Boomerang (Nicole) 10 Your Love (Nicole) 03 Run (Nicole) 04 On the Rocks (Nicole) 04 Clockwork (Ashley) 07 Woman Up (Ashley) So cheesy, could’ve been a hit by a bigger/better singer 01 Stars In Your Eyes (w/ Her Majesty & The Wolves) (Kimberley) ...whereas this is just pure cheese. I don’t think I’ve heard it before 08 Candy (w/ Aggro Santos) (Kimberley) I’m in complete disagreement with Davidson - if this were PCD only, “Don’t Cha” and “Buttons” would be 10s but some of Nicole’s songs (particularly the singles from the original version of ‘Killer Love’) are much better.
October 9, 20177 yr 09 Don't Cha (ft. Busta Rhymes) 07 Stickwitu 08 Beep (ft. will.i.am.) 08 Buttons 08 I Don't Need a Man 07 Wait A Minute (ft. Timbaland) 09 When I Grow Up 10 Whatcha Think About That? (ft. Missy Elliot) 10 I Hate This Part 09 Jai Ho (A.R. Rahman & Nicole Scherzinger ft. Pussycat Dolls) 11 Hush Hush; Hush Hush 04 Come To Me (w/ P Diddy) (Nicole) 02 Whatever U Like (ft. T.I.) (Nicole) 04 Baby Love (Nicole) 05 Scream (w/ Timbaland & Keri Hilson) (Nicole) 10 Heartbeat (w/ Enrique Iglesias) (Nicole) 08 Poison (Nicole) 08 Don't Hold Your Breath (Nicole) 07 Right Here (Nicole) 09 Wet (Nicole) 09 Try With Me (Nicole) 06 Boomerang (Nicole) 06 Your Love (Nicole) 07 Run (Nicole) 03 On the Rocks (Nicole) 03 Clockwork (Ashley) 03 Woman Up (Ashley) 04 Stars In Your Eyes (w/ Her Majesty & The Wolves) (Kimberley) 06 Candy (w/ Aggro Santos) (Kimberley)
October 9, 20177 yr I Hate This Part is one of the best girl band ballads/midtempos there is! Would love it to walk this or at least be top three.
October 9, 20177 yr Sad to see such little appreciation for Stars In Your Eyes. Sounds very dated now, but it was actually quite a tune when it was released in 2010.
Create an account or sign in to comment