Which of the three Disney girls do you think is the most relevant in the UK music scene?

Demi by FAR. Sorry Not Sorry has been big here and she's had some hit collabs - whereas Younger Now and Fetish both flopped hard.

Demi so far. Despite Miley has the higher peaks, Demi has more longevity and TOP 10's... and Selena is quite a non factor.

Which of the three Disney girls do you think is the most relevant in the UK music scene?

 

I think you knew when you made this that your fave Demi would win in a landslide on the poll. :lol:

 

It is really obvious Demi is the most relevant at the minute in the UK out of the three.

Edited October 5, 20177 yr by HissingSparkler

If you asked the question a couple years ago it would have been miley hands down but ATM demi she has stayed more consistent. miley is still relevant but less than she was a few years whereas demi although not hugely more relevant than she was a few years ago it is enough for her to overtake miley by staying consistent

 

although selena has had some moderate hits I don't think she has ever really been up there like miley and Demi in the uk

Right now, Demi. But as a whole it is obviously Miley.

Demi by FAR. Sorry Not Sorry has been big here and she's had some hit collabs - whereas Younger Now and Fetish both flopped hard.

That’s a bad comparison...

 

You’re using a lead single and comparing it to 2nd and 3rd singles.

 

Demi is biggest of all, yes, but Miley had a #11 hot recently and Selena has a few hits

Demi at this point - though I'd argue the other two are more famous, it's just that their most recent material hasn't really caught on the way 'Sorry Not Sorry' did (though 'Malibu' and 'Bad Liar' were decent sized hits) as it's not as radio/streaming friendly, and Demi has also cleverly kept her name out with dance features too.

Selena and Demi are equal in that they are only as big as there last hit and overall in terms of album sales and relevance they are both miles behind Miley.

Miley is resetting her career RN, so I think she will get her relevance back.

In terms of album sales Demi is going to debut higher than Miley this week. Miley may have historically had better album sales but at the moment that is far from the case.

 

If anything Miley has proved that she is only as big as her last hit, I suppose you could say that about most people though such is the pop music industry.

Miley will be most relevant until the others can grab UK number 1 singles.

 

She's really missed a trick by not following up with some killer material hasn't she? "Malibu" was dull as dishwater. Haven't even bothered with the rest of the singles.

It's weird how Selena has been huge in the US with numerous huge hits but does barely anything in the UK!

You’re all kidding yourselves if you think Demi is more musically relevant here than Miley!

 

Miley has two number ones and Wrecking Ball is one of most iconic pop songs from the 2010s. Instantly recognisable lyrics and video. She’s a household name. Just because her current era is a bit of a flop doesn’t mean she’s not a huge star still.

 

Demi gets okay-sized hits but ask the average person to name a Demi song and they would seriously struggle. I think most would struggle to pick her out of a line up too. She’s nowhere near a household name.

 

Selena is nothing here lol.

I would have to say Selena. I think she's most capable of staying relevant for the longest & churning out the top 40 hits more than the others, although it has been a purple patch for Demi this year too admittedly.

You’re all kidding yourselves if you think Demi is more musically relevant here than Miley!

 

Miley has two number ones and Wrecking Ball is one of most iconic pop songs from the 2010s. Instantly recognisable lyrics and video. She’s a household name. Just because her current era is a bit of a flop doesn’t mean she’s not a huge star still.

 

Demi gets okay-sized hits but ask the average person to name a Demi song and they would seriously struggle. I think most would struggle to pick her out of a line up too. She’s nowhere near a household name.

 

Selena is nothing here lol.

I'm glad somebody agrees with me... and I think you nailed Demi well there too.

I'm really impressed with Demi, before 'Sorry Not Sorry' I was pretty much certain her solo music career had hit the kerb. It's something of an impressive turnaround, I hope she can keep it up!

Miley is definitely the most well known! Not even close.

Demi and Selena have both gained popularity and become more well known here but Miley like someone else said is a household name and is instantly recognized for many reasons e.g her tongue, wrecking ball. The others haven’t had that exposure yet.

 

Miley by a considerable margin. She's a household name. Demi might be having a better era but all her eras put together don't even beat Miley's Bangerz era alone for relevance. That's without even counting Miley's older songs.

 

Selena and Demi are much of a muchness to me.

I’ve always thought Selena and Demi were about the same in the UK, their success seems to really vary with each release. Wish Selena was having the success Demi’s having this time around, her material is so much better.

 

Miley’s by far the most known/liked out of the three here, even if this new album isn’t doing well for her.