13 number ones. Which gets you in your groove and which leaves you frozen? (I'll see myself out)

 

Into the Groove

Papa Don't Preach

True Blue

La Isla Bonita

Who's That Girl?

Like a Prayer

Vogue

Frozen

American Pie

Music

Hung Up

Sorry

4 Minutes

 

BEST: Frozen

WORST: Who's That Girl? (Well, it's a total and utter non-event really isn't it?)

Edited October 11, 20186 yr by Tawdry Hepburn

BEST

La Isla Bonita

Like a Prayer

Hung Up

Papa Don't Preach

Sorry

Into the Groove

True Blue

Vogue

4 Minutes

Frozen

American Pie

Music

Who's That Girl?

WORST

 

Ready to be hounded for my placing of "Frozen" 👀

Into the Groove best

4 minutes least

 

WTG from ciao Italian is stunning !!!

Best - Papa don't preach :wub: (also adore True Blue)

 

Worse - Who's that girl (closely followed by 4 Minutes)

My Ranking =

1. Like a Prayer
2. Into the Groove
3. Papa Don’t Preach
4. Frozen
5. Vogue
6. La Isla Bonita
7. Hung Up
8. 4 Minutes
9. Sorry
10. Music
11. True Blue
12. American Pie
13. Who’s That Girl

1. Like a Prayer

2. Hung Up

3. Frozen

4. Papa Don’t Preach

5. Vogue

6. La Isla Bonita

7. Sorry

8. 4 Minutes

9. Into The Groove

10. True Blue

11. American Pie

12. Music

13. Who’s That Girl

1 True Blue

2 Into The Groove

3 Who's That Girl

4 Papa Don't Preach

5 Like a Prayer

6 Vogue

7 La Isla Bonita

8 Hung Up

9 Sorry

10 Frozen

11 American Pie

12 Music

13 4 Minutes

1. Vogue

2. Papa Don't Preach

3. La Isla Bonita

4. Who's That Girl?

5. Frozen

6. Into the Groove

7. Music

8. Like A Prayer

9. 4 Minutes

10. Hung Up

11. Sorry

12. True Blue

13. American Pie

FAVOURITE

Hung Up

Sorry

Vogue

Frozen

Like a Prayer

Papa Don't Preach

La Isla Bonita

Music

Into the Groove

True Blue

4 Minutes

Who's That Girl?

American Pie

LEAST FAVOURITE

 

A fab list of #1s; I enjoy all of these songs, with that Top 7 all being 10/10 moments for me.

'Like a Prayer' >>>>>> Everything else.

 

 

I have a soft spot for 'Who's that girl' even though it's not one of my favourites. It remindes me of an unfinished demo version of 'La Isla bonita.' The middle- 8 elevates the song, I suppose Madonna could release anything at that stage and get to No.1.

 

 

 

Edited October 18, 20186 yr by Danny89

Yeah, I was looking at the list and 'Who's That Girl', as well as 'American Pie', stood out as songs that were helped to #1 by the huge eras that came shortly before.

This is tough but I think:

 

BEST: Frozen

WORST: Who's That Girl?

 

 

Like A Prayer (Best) Hung Up a close second.

4 Minutes (Worst)

Favourite - American Pie ("Like A Prayer" still great, but overplayed to death)

Worst - Papa Don't Preach (her worst 80s single, together with "Fever"), also I dislike Hung Up, Music and 4 Minutes.

Sorry being her lowest selling UK #1 is a travesty :cry:

Sorry being her lowest selling UK #1 is a travesty :cry:

I know right? :cry: Wish that could be as fondly remembered as Hung Up is. It's probably one that people may think "oh yeah, I loved this one!" if it were played to them.

Fave: Like a Prayer

Least Fave: Who’s That Girl

I know right? :cry: Wish that could be as fondly remembered as Hung Up is. It's probably one that people may think "oh yeah, I loved this one!" if it were played to them.

 

I agree.

One of my very closest friends isn’t a huge Madonna fan but she’s always stanned Sorry.