Jump to content

Melanie C - 'Melanie C'

-Jay-
in Spice Girls

Featured Replies

I think a Top 20 placing is pretty much guaranteed. It'll chart the w/e/ 15th October - for the comparative chart in 2019, the #20 sold 3.5k and, with all things considered, it would be very underwhelming if it didn't even clear that. The #10 sold 6.6k and I think Mel could achieve that. I mean, Emma Bunton did with her last album.
  • Replies 643
  • Views 82.9k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Popular Days

Yeah Emma managed 6.6k and reading through the thread I recall a few fans being put off buying by the fact it was mostly covers? Melanie C's singles have done better than Emma's as well. I know the market has declined even more since then but I'd be surprised if she didn't at least do Louise numbers, and looking at album sales recently that should be enough top 10.
  • Author

Watch her get to #11 like Emma and Louise :sarah:

 

I would certainly be happy with Melanie charting anywhere in the Top 20 and of course Top 10 would be the cherry on the cake. :wub:

She deserves a top5 at least. Not only she’s worked hard all this time, but she’s honestly the only Spice who really cares about music and the only one really talented.
She deserves a top5 at least. Not only she’s worked hard all this time, but she’s honestly the only Spice who really cares about music and the only one really talented.

Please delete yourself from this forum and never come back x

Please delete yourself from this forum and never come back x

 

Why? I’ve supported most of the Girls during their solo careers, aka I’ve spent my money to buy their records. Emma and Mel B being my other faves.

 

But why not being honest? Mel B is lazy AF, and this bothers me. Emma is so average with her music and lacks of personality. Victoria is doing something different, where she’s so talented. Geri can’t sing or dance.

 

Let’s say - and I correct myself - they’re all talented in different fields, but when it comes to music, and it’s my opinion, the only one I can take seriously is Melanie C.

I wish she put the original version of High Heels on and not the remix. There was probably room for both!!

 

 

Why? I’ve supported most of the Girls during their solo careers, aka I’ve spent my money to buy their records. Emma and Mel B being my other faves.

 

But why not being honest? Mel B is lazy AF, and this bothers me. Emma is so average with her music and lacks of personality. Victoria is doing something different, where she’s so talented. Geri can’t sing or dance.

 

Let’s say - and I correct myself - they’re all talented in different fields, but when it comes to music, and it’s my opinion, the only one I can take seriously is Melanie C.

 

 

Maz was joking :lol:

 

I actually agree with you in regards to her being the only one who deserves it the other girls are all talented in different way but give up way too easily. Melanie is the only one who has persevered and is truly passionate about being a singer.

Mel is the only one who has really persevered with her solo career so id love her to get that 3rd top 10 album, but even a good top 20 would be good for her,
I wish she put the original version of High Heels on and not the remix. There was probably room for both!!

 

Agreed - don’t understand why they left the original version off. I’ve preordered the deluxe from amazon.

  • Author
I think a Top 20 placing is pretty much guaranteed. It'll chart the w/e/ 15th October - for the comparative chart in 2019, the #20 sold 3.5k and, with all things considered, it would be very underwhelming if it didn't even clear that. The #10 sold 6.6k and I think Mel could achieve that. I mean, Emma Bunton did with her last album.

Further to this - Version of Me sold 4,084 copies to reach #25, which looking back seems quite impressive given that physically it only had one CD. So I would be very surprised if she sold less than that with her new album, considering all the formats on sale this time - as well as the increase in airplay support and there seeming to be more goodwill towards Melanie C as an artist these days!

 

In the comparative chart last year, 4,084 would have been enough for her to chart at #16. The Sea sold 3,735 in its first week and that would have seen her chart at #17. So I think you're right that Top 20 is guaranteed at the very least this time. :heart:

Further to this - Version of Me sold 4,084 copies to reach #25, which looking back seems quite impressive given that physically it only had one CD. So I would be very surprised if she sold less than that with her new album, considering all the formats on sale this time - as well as the increase in airplay support and there seeming to be more goodwill towards Melanie C as an artist these days!

 

In the comparative chart last year, 4,084 would have been enough for her to chart at #16. The Sea sold 3,735 in its first week and that would have seen her chart at #17. So I think you're right that Top 20 is guaranteed at the very least this time. :heart:

 

Out of interest what would Beautiful Intentions and This Time’s sales have seen her at last year???

  • Author
Out of interest what would Beautiful Intentions and This Time’s sales have seen her at last year???

8,970 - Beautiful Intentions (would have been #7)

 

Unfortunately we never found out This Time's sales, they were estimated as 4,500 - enough for #16!

Do we think she will do a tour bundle ?
Do we think she will do a tour bundle ?

 

She definitly should!

I'm holding off ordering anything, I'm not desperate for this album and it seems like the bundles won't sell out. There will be an inevitable black Friday or half price sale in November so I just have to keep restraint.

 

The blue vinyl looks beautiful though that is a tempter.

Go to topic listing

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.