Jump to content

AF Idol 2.0 • Kylie and Dannii Discussion Thread

Liam.k.
in Kylie and Dannii Minogue

Featured Replies

Is Kids eligible ?

 

This can’t be in worst 5 songs !!!

  • Replies 576
  • Views 19.5k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Popular Days

Just going back to these, as I think I'd be pushing it with 'Kids' lol, what would people say is the best option?

 

My favourite is 'All I See' and it doesn't seem to evoke as strong negative opinions as the other two, it's more considered a badly-chosen single rather than a bad song.

Agree about all i see, its def a badly picked single and i think when fans know how much better there was on the album made it worse, but as an album track its not bad. I was gonna cancel has plenty of hate. Celebration as i said i like it but many just see it as a cheap and quick cover.

Kylie can send Kids, it was a joint credit so you guys have as much right to it as Robbie & TT! If it was bottom 3 it should be in your consideration I'd say.
  • Author
Kylie can send Kids, it was a joint credit so you guys have as much right to it as Robbie & TT! If it was bottom 3 it should be in your consideration I'd say.

Thank you! If that's the case then is everyone happy with me sending 'Kids'?

I can’t believe you all hate it !! I am considering leaving this forum lol!

 

Kids will sail through !!

  • Author

I've now been told 'Kids' is ineligible because it has to be a rate of all her singles, not separated into decades.

 

So 'All I See', 'Celebration' and 'I Was Gonna Cancel' are our options.

I dont think i was gona cancel would work at all, it gets a lot of hate and i think more than most of her other less liked songs.

'All I See' is a great song, how was that so low! (Granted, it's the MIMS-featuring version I've always known, but I presume the original is the same minus him.)

 

I know 'I Was Gonna Cancel' is, like, poison ivy among her fans, but I always really liked it. It was my favourite single / song I heard from that album.

 

Refreshing myself on 'Celebration' and... yeah I'd agree with the person above who referred to it as a cheap and quick cover.

  • Author
'All I See' is a great song, how was that so low! (Granted, it's the MIMS-featuring version I've always known, but I presume the original is the same minus him.)

Yeah they're basically the same song! I've been listening to 'All I See' a fair bit recently and I've definitely been too harsh on it in the past.

 

'I Was Gonna Cancel' did get a couple of 7s in the rate, could potentially do well in this?

Well I can’t see us passing this round guys haha

I can, it's only a single elimination and have you seen some of the choices that other AFs have been left with? :lol:

I can, it's only a single elimination and have you seen some of the choices that other AFs have been left with? :lol:

 

:kink: I need to go and have a look :lol:

Let’s be honest if we put “I was gonna cancel” though I would be questioning our tastes 😂 and I certainly wouldn’t support Kylie out of loyalty for that choice.

We could potentially be in this situation shortly.

For me to vote this song if it goes through would require some absolute awful songs from other forums.

Rudebox from Robbie Williams would be an example of a song worse than I Was Gonna Cancel or if the Madonna forum submitted Human Nature or songs from Madame X.

If All I See is submitted,it is a much different situation.

 

Go to topic listing

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.