Jump to content

Featured Replies

  • Replies 644
  • Views 27.3k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Mama is their worst single for me by far oop but y'all know the general reception to the Spice singles better than me :kink:
Holler was bottom 3 of a rating? Which one??? I didn't know that was an option I was thinking send Mama but if Holler is available then that could be a better choice?
  • Author

I am fairly confident that Holler hasn’t ever been bottom 3 in a rate/survivor here, unless someone remembers differently and can show me which thread? Holler is fairly popular with the fan base. It’s mainly the casuals on BuzzJack who don’t often visit this forum that seem to have more of a downer on it!

 

Mama is their worst single for me by far oop but y'all know the general reception to the Spice singles better than me :kink:

Almost every forum is in the position of having to send one of their worst, so you don’t know yet whether Mama is going to end up being one of the “best worst songs” in the list!

 

Their Bottom 3 moments in rates etc are usually Headlines, Let Love Lead the Way and Mama. Funnily enough Mama is the one that usually comes last in Spice Girls forum activities. But across the forum as a whole I would be pretty surprised if there’s more love for Headlines and LLLTW?

Mama is their worst single for me by far oop but y'all know the general reception to the Spice singles better than me :kink:
Judging by a lot of your other choices for the forums (THREADS :deadbanana:)... I don't think it's just the general reception to the Spice singles that we know better than you :')

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

:kink:

Yeah I think Mama is the most obvious choice to send here, if Holler was bottom three in a rating then I'd be happy to send that too but I actually think (sadly) Mama might even fare better then Holler!
  • Author
omg I am finally getting my wish granted. I even wanted Mama to be sent last round :lol:

:cheer: !

I was looking at the last singles rate and somehow scrolled past Headlines coming last :drama:

 

Judging by a lot of your other choices for the forums (THREADS :deadbanana:)... I don't think it's just the general reception to the Spice singles that we know better than you :')

:kink:

66f3196e40bb5b1798d1c7f3d06381d0eab0b144.gif

Wait, what's the criteria this time?
Mama is at least from an era fondly remembered by everyone. Holler/LLLTW were post-Geri while Headlines was a bit of nothingy song.
Wait, what's the criteria this time?

 

 

A song that came bottom three in a song rate

 

We have bascially

 

- Mama

- Let love lead the way

- Headlines

 

Out of those three LLLTW is my favourite, and Mama is my least however I think Mama would probably do the best out of those three.

Hhhmmmm I think LLLTW might be a good shout.
  • Author
A song that came bottom three in a song rate

Just to clarify, that's the criteria, but the actual theme is "Worst Single"!

 

I don't have much confidence in BuzzJack members being here for Let Love Lead the Way? :(

 

If we go by the "Ultimate Girl Group" rate that took place in 2016:

 

106. Spice Girls - Mama (Average Rating 6.71)

142. Spice Girls - Let Love Lead The Way (Average Rating 5.43)

153. Spice Girls - Headlines (Friendship Never Ends) - Average Rating 4.9

 

http://www.buzzjack.com/forums/index.php?s...t&p=5521977

 

 

More recent than that, 2018... Let Love Lead the Way did ever so slightly better than Mama, but only by 3 points.

 

130 | Spice Girls – Let Love Lead The Way | 68pts

134 | Spice Girls – Mama | 65pts

197 | Spice Girls – Headlines (Friendship Never Ends) | 24pts

 

http://www.buzzjack.com/forums/index.php?showtopic=210656

 

 

 

I'm not sure. Evidently none of the three are all that popular, but Mama surely benefits from being a 'Spice' single, a #1, probably the most recognisable song.

LLLTW is the better song

Mama is more well known

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.