Hello and welcome to the ultimate and full Taylor Swift discography rate :cheer: This has been something we've wanted to run for a while and with Taylor doing nothing to promote folklore + lockdown pt. 2, when's a better time to start this then now :cheer:

 

This is going to be the ultimate task of rating everything in Taylor's discography (thanks v. much to the Britney forum for their way of hosting their ultimate way cos we're gonna adopt that concept cos it worked so well!!). I really really hope there'll be interest and participation in this as we're gonna put so much effort into it!! <3 <3

 

It would be amazing if somebody would host album listening sessions for the albums in the next couple of weeks? We'll try host but between my uni work & RFI's time differences, its hard for us to host a session at a good time when people would turn up! So please if someone wants to host an album listening session it'd be amazing, especially for the albums y'all are less familiar with!

 

I hope y'all join us on this journey through Taylor's 8 albums from country superstar to world domination :cheer: The first part will consist of Taylor Swift, Fearless, Speak Now & the Xmas EP, aka the albums y'all don't know that well which is why were starting here so you have as much time as possible to get round to them! Part 2 will be Red, 1989 & Rep and Part 3 will conclude with lover, folklore & all the non-album singles

 

RULES:

- You go through the list of songs down below and rank every track from a 0 - 10 (0 being awful - 10 being amazing).

- Please rate each track on their album versions. Any singles/remixes will be added to a separate section towards the end (I don't 'think' that applies for anything in part one)

- You are allowed no more than 6 scores of 11 for your absolute favourites across the all the three parts to this rate so make sure you know when u wanna use them!

- You are allowed no more than 1 score of -1 for your absolute least favourite across all three parts to this rate

- Scores of .5 ARE allowed, but NO 10.5 or -00.5.

- For any song you are not familiar with please DO NOT GIVE IT A SCORE, leave it as xx.x --> however please listen to all songs in this rate, it's lockdown, y'all got time!!

- Any rates by the time it closes that doesn't have at least 90% of the songs rated, will be NULL AND VOID

- The deadline for rating these 3 albums will be Monday 28th December 2020; 11:59pm (BST) --> this is a tentative deadline for all three parts, I'm kinda hoping we get enough participation to close by then!

 

 

Have fun & LETS GET RATING :cheer: :heart: :

there are spotify links under the final tracklist so y'all can listen to the albums easily

 

xx.x Tim McGraw

xx.x Picture To Burn

xx.x Teardrops On My Guitar - Radio Version

xx.x A Place In This World

xx.x Cold As You

xx.x The Outside

xx.x Tied Together With A Smile

xx.x Stay Beautiful

xx.x Should've Said No

xx.x Mary's Song (Oh My My My)

xx.x Our Song

xx.x I'm Only Me When I'm With You

xx.x Invisible

xx.x A Perfectly Good Heart

xx.x Teardrops On My Guitar - Pop Version

 

xx.x Last Christmas

xx.x Christmases When You Were Mine

xx.x Santa Baby

xx.x Silent Night

xx.x Christmas Must Be Something More

xx.x White Christmas

 

xx.x Jump Then Fall

xx.x Untouchable

xx.x Forever & Always - Piano Version

xx.x Come In With The Rain

xx.x SuperStar

xx.x The Other Side of The Door

xx.x Fearless

xx.x Fifteen

xx.x Love Story

xx.x Hey Stephen

xx.x White Horse

xx.x You Belong With Me

xx.x Breathe (ft. Colbie Caillat)

xx.x Tell Me Why

xx.x You're Not Sorry

xx.x The Way I Loved You

xx.x Forever & Always

xx.x The Best Day

xx.x Change

 

xx.x Mine

xx.x Sparks Fly

xx.x Back To December

xx.x Speak Now

xx.x Dear John

xx.x Mean

xx.x The Story Of Us

xx.x Never Grow Up

xx.x Enchanted

xx.x Better Than Revenge

xx.x Innocent

xx.x Haunted

xx.x Last Kiss

xx.x Long Live

xx.x Ours

xx.x If This Was A Movie

xx.x Superman

 

^all songs available on the above links expect Ours, If This Was A Movie & Superman. Ours is on spotify if you search for it, the other two aren't but are available on YouTube!

ahh I'm SO excited for this!! I really hope participation is good <3

06 Tim McGraw

09 Picture To Burn

09 Teardrops On My Guitar - Radio Version

06 A Place In This World

06 Cold As You

06 The Outside

07 Tied Together With A Smile

07 Stay Beautiful

09 Should've Said No

08 Mary's Song (Oh My My My)

10 Our Song

07 I'm Only Me When I'm With You

07 Invisible

06 A Perfectly Good Heart

09 Teardrops On My Guitar - Pop Version

 

07 Last Christmas

08 Christmases When You Were Mine

06 Santa Baby

05 Silent Night

06 Christmas Must Be Something More

06 White Christmas

 

06 Jump Then Fall

07 Untouchable

08 Forever & Always - Piano Version

07 Come In With The Rain

07 SuperStar

07 The Other Side of The Door

08 Fearless

08 Fifteen

09 Love Story

06 Hey Stephen

09 White Horse

10 You Belong With Me

07 Breathe (ft. Colbie Caillat)

07 Tell Me Why

06 You're Not Sorry

07 The Way I Loved You

08 Forever & Always

08 The Best Day

06 Change

 

09 Mine

08 Sparks Fly

10 Back To December

09 Speak Now

05 Dear John

09 Mean

09 The Story Of Us

07 Never Grow Up

11 Enchanted

07 Better Than Revenge

06 Innocent

07 Haunted

07 Last Kiss

08 Long Live

09 Ours

08 If This Was A Movie

09 Superman

08.0 Tim McGraw
09.0 Picture To Burn
09.0 Teardrops On My Guitar - Radio Version
07.0 A Place In This World
08.5 Cold As You
07.5 The Outside
06.5 Tied Together With A Smile
06.0 Stay Beautiful
08.5 Should've Said No
09.0 Mary's Song (Oh My My My)
10.0 Our Song
08.0 I'm Only Me When I'm With You
07.0 Invisible
06.0 A Perfectly Good Heart
09.0 Teardrops On My Guitar - Pop Version

06.0 Last Christmas
07.0 Christmases When You Were Mine
05.0 Santa Baby
05.0 Silent Night
06.5 Christmas Must Be Something More
04.5 White Christmas

07.0 Jump Then Fall
07.0 Untouchable
08.5 Forever & Always - Piano Version
07.5 Come In With The Rain
06.5 SuperStar
06.0 The Other Side of The Door
10.0 Fearless
09.0 Fifteen
11.0 Love Story
08.0 Hey Stephen
09.0 White Horse
10.0 You Belong With Me
07.5 Breathe (ft. Colbie Caillat)
08.5 Tell Me Why
07.0 You're Not Sorry
07.0 The Way I Loved You
08.0 Forever & Always
09.0 The Best Day
06.0 Change

10.0 Mine
08.5 Sparks Fly
10.0 Back To December
09.0 Speak Now
07.0 Dear John
10.0 Mean
09.0 The Story Of Us
06.0 Never Grow Up
08.5 Enchanted
09.0 Better Than Revenge
07.0 Innocent
08.0 Haunted
07.0 Last Kiss
08.0 Long Live
09.0 Ours
08.0 If This Was A Movie
08.0 Superman

fab to see a couple rates already! :wub:

HYPE!

 

Listening through the debut now (with Joseph) and going to be submitting rates for all of these :wub: I know the last 4 albums and Speak Now very well, but not so much the other stuff. Excited for this :dance:

Oh this is a good concept! I don't know any of these albums already but I'll try to find time to listen to them at some point before the deadline ^_^

ahh fab to see you guys interested in participating!! :heart:

 

I'm gonna start my millionth re-listening again this weekend *.*

07.5 Tim McGraw

08.5 Picture To Burn

08.0 Teardrops On My Guitar - Radio Version

07.5 A Place In This World

07.0 Cold As You

08.0 The Outside

08.5 Tied Together With A Smile

07.0 Stay Beautiful

10.0 Should've Said No

08.5 Mary's Song (Oh My My My)

09.0 Our Song

08.0 I'm Only Me When I'm With You

07.5 Invisible

07.0 A Perfectly Good Heart

08.0 Teardrops On My Guitar - Pop Version

 

07.0 Last Christmas

05.0 Christmases When You Were Mine

05.5 Santa Baby

05.0 Silent Night

07.0 Christmas Must Be Something More

06.0 White Christmas

 

09.5 Jump Then Fall

07.0 Untouchable

07.5 Forever & Always - Piano Version

06.0 Come In With The Rain

07.0 SuperStar

07.5 The Other Side of The Door

09.0 Fearless

08.5 Fifteen

10.0 Love Story

07.5 Hey Stephen

07.5 White Horse

09.5 You Belong With Me

09.0 Breathe (ft. Colbie Caillat)

08.0 Tell Me Why

09.5 You're Not Sorry

07.5 The Way I Loved You

08.5 Forever & Always

07.0 The Best Day

07.5 Change

 

09.5 Mine

09.0 Sparks Fly

11.0 Back To December

10.0 Speak Now

07.5 Dear John

09.5 Mean

10.0 The Story Of Us

09.5 Never Grow Up

11.0 Enchanted

11.0 Better Than Revenge

09.5 Innocent

10.0 Haunted

08.0 Last Kiss

09.0 Long Live

07.0 Ours

08.0 If This Was A Movie

07.5 Superman

07.5 Tim McGraw

06.5 Picture To Burn

08.5 Teardrops On My Guitar - Radio Version

06.5 A Place In This World

04.0 Cold As You

04.0 The Outside

06.0 Tied Together With A Smile

03.0 Stay Beautiful

06.5 Should've Said No

04.0 Mary's Song (Oh My My My)

06.0 Our Song

05.0 I'm Only Me When I'm With You

06.5 Invisible

05.5 A Perfectly Good Heart

08.0 Teardrops On My Guitar - Pop Version

 

07.5 Last Christmas

04.0 Christmases When You Were Mine

03.0 Santa Baby

04.0 Silent Night

05.5 Christmas Must Be Something More

05.0 White Christmas

 

07.0 Jump Then Fall

04.0 Untouchable

05.0 Forever & Always - Piano Version

03.0 Come In With The Rain

04.0 SuperStar

03.0 The Other Side of The Door

07.0 Fearless

07.0 Fifteen

09.0 Love Story

06.0 Hey Stephen

06.5 White Horse

11.0 You Belong With Me

07.0 Breathe (ft. Colbie Caillat)

06.5 Tell Me Why

06.0 You're Not Sorry

06.0 The Way I Loved You

07.0 Forever & Always

06.5 The Best Day

06.0 Change

 

09.5 Mine

09.5 Sparks Fly

10.0 Back To December

08.0 Speak Now

06.0 Dear John

08.0 Mean

09.5 The Story Of Us

09.0 Never Grow Up

09.5 Enchanted

08.0 Better Than Revenge

07.5 Innocent

08.5 Haunted

07.5 Last Kiss

08.0 Long Live

07.0 Ours

07.0 If This Was A Movie

06.0 Superman

continue rating guys! :cheer:

I'm gonna be listening and rating now!!

 

If anyone else wants to join me in listening to these albums in prep for evermore it'll be great and rate!!

07.0 Tim McGraw

08.0 Picture To Burn

08.5 Teardrops On My Guitar - Radio Version

07.0 A Place In This World

07.5 Cold As You

06.5 The Outside

05.5 Tied Together With A Smile

05.0 Stay Beautiful

08.5 Should've Said No

06.0 Mary's Song (Oh My My My)

08.0 Our Song

07.5 I'm Only Me When I'm With You

06.0 Invisible

05.0 A Perfectly Good Heart

08.0 Teardrops On My Guitar - Pop Version

 

06.0 Last Christmas

07.5 Christmases When You Were Mine

05.0 Santa Baby

05.0 Silent Night

06.0 Christmas Must Be Something More

04.0 White Christmas

 

07.0 Jump Then Fall

09.0 Untouchable

08.0 Forever & Always - Piano Version

06.5 Come In With The Rain

06.0 SuperStar

06.0 The Other Side of The Door

10.0 Fearless

07.0 Fifteen

09.0 Love Story

07.0 Hey Stephen

07.0 White Horse

08.0 You Belong With Me

07.0 Breathe (ft. Colbie Caillat)

08.0 Tell Me Why

07.5 You're Not Sorry

07.0 The Way I Loved You

08.5 Forever & Always

07.0 The Best Day

10.0 Change

 

08.0 Mine

08.0 Sparks Fly

10.0 Back To December

09.0 Speak Now

07.0 Dear John

09.0 Mean

08.0 The Story Of Us

07.0 Never Grow Up

08.0 Enchanted

10.0 Better Than Revenge

07.0 Innocent

10.0 Haunted

07.5 Last Kiss

08.5 Long Live

08.0 Ours

07.0 If This Was A Movie

07.0 Superman

08.0 Tim McGraw

08.5 Picture To Burn

08.0 Teardrops On My Guitar - Radio Version

09.0 A Place In This World

10.0 Cold As You

07.5 The Outside

06.0 Tied Together With A Smile

09.0 Stay Beautiful

10.0 Should've Said No

05.5 Mary's Song (Oh My My My)

09.0 Our Song

10.0 I'm Only Me When I'm With You

07.5 Invisible

07.0 A Perfectly Good Heart

09.0 Teardrops On My Guitar - Pop Version

 

09.0 Last Christmas

06.5 Christmases When You Were Mine

07.5 Santa Baby

02.0 Silent Night --> omg I forgot how awful this was

07.0 Christmas Must Be Something More

05.0 White Christmas

 

07.0 Jump Then Fall

07.5 Untouchable

09.5 Forever & Always - Piano Version

06.0 Come In With The Rain

06.0 SuperStar

06.0 The Other Side of The Door

09.0 Fearless

08.5 Fifteen

10.0 Love Story

08.0 Hey Stephen

08.0 White Horse

10.0 You Belong With Me

10.0 Breathe (ft. Colbie Caillat)

08.0 Tell Me Why

10.0 You're Not Sorry

07.0 The Way I Loved You

10.0 Forever & Always

09.0 The Best Day

06.5 Change

 

11 Mine

10.0 Sparks Fly

09.5 Back To December

09.0 Speak Now

08.5 Dear John

10.0 Mean

09.5 The Story Of Us

09.0 Never Grow Up

11 Enchanted

10.0 Better Than Revenge

-1 Innocent

10.0 Haunted

08.5 Last Kiss

09.0 Long Live

09.0 Ours

07.5 If This Was A Movie

10.0 Superman

Moving to top.

Dont let me forget to do this plz and thank you x

08.0 Tim McGraw

10.0 Picture To Burn

09.0 Teardrops On My Guitar - Radio Version

05.0 A Place In This World

08.5 Cold As You

04.0 The Outside

06.0 Tied Together With A Smile

08.5 Stay Beautiful

10.0 Should've Said No

10.0 Mary's Song (Oh My My My)

08.5 Our Song

04.5 I'm Only Me When I'm With You

05.0 Invisible

04.0 A Perfectly Good Heart

08.0 Teardrops On My Guitar - Pop Version

 

04.0 Last Christmas

06.5 Christmases When You Were Mine

03.0 Santa Baby

03.0 Silent Night

04.5 Christmas Must Be Something More

03.5 White Christmas

 

05.0 Jump Then Fall

07.0 Untouchable

08.5 Forever & Always - Piano Version

10.0 Come In With The Rain

05.0 SuperStar

10.0 The Other Side of The Door

06.5 Fearless

09.0 Fifteen

08.5 Love Story

07.5 Hey Stephen

08.5 White Horse

09.0 You Belong With Me

10.0 Breathe (ft. Colbie Caillat)

09.0 Tell Me Why

09.0 You're Not Sorry

10.0 The Way I Loved You

10.0 Forever & Always

09.5 The Best Day

04.0 Change

 

11.0 Mine

06.0 Sparks Fly

09.0 Back To December

08.0 Speak Now

09.5 Dear John

07.0 Mean

07.0 The Story Of Us

07.5 Never Grow Up

11.0 Enchanted

05.0 Better Than Revenge

08.0 Innocent

09.5 Haunted

10.0 Last Kiss

07.0 Long Live

08.5 Ours

09.0 If This Was A Movie

05.0 Superman

I shall fill in the rest tomorrow! I'm relistening/refreshing as I go and I am too tired to finish this section tonight. Especially when these first few albums are about 800 tracks per album xx

 

Taylor Swift:

07.0 Tim McGraw

08.5 Picture To Burn

09.0 Teardrops On My Guitar - Radio Version

08.0 A Place In This World

06.0 Cold As You

07.5 The Outside

06.0 Tied Together With A Smile

06.5 Stay Beautiful

10.0 Should've Said No

08.0 Mary's Song (Oh My My My)

07.0 Our Song

09.5 I'm Only Me When I'm With You

06.0 Invisible

07.0 A Perfectly Good Heart

08.0 Teardrops On My Guitar - Pop Version

---

Holiday Collection:

07.5 Last Christmas

05.0 Christmases When You Were Mine

06.0 Santa Baby

03.5 Silent Night

06.5 Christmas Must Be Something More

06.0 White Christmas

---

Fearless:

07.5 Jump Then Fall

06.0 Untouchable

06.5 Forever & Always - Piano Version

06.0 Come In With The Rain

05.0 SuperStar

06.0 The Other Side of The Door

07.0 Fearless

09.0 Fifteen

10.0 Love Story

07.5 Hey Stephen

06.0 White Horse

10.0 You Belong With Me

05.5 Breathe (ft. Colbie Caillat)

08.0 Tell Me Why

07.0 You're Not Sorry

07.0 The Way I Loved You

07.5 Forever & Always

06.5 The Best Day

08.5 Change

---

Speak Now:

08.5 Mine

08.5 Sparks Fly

09.0 Back To December

08.0 Speak Now

06.5 Dear John

10.0 Mean

10.0 The Story Of Us

06.0 Never Grow Up

10.0 Enchanted

10.0 Better Than Revenge

07.5 Innocent

10.0 Haunted

06.0 Last Kiss

09.0 Long Live

07.0 Ours

08.0 If This Was A Movie

09.0 Superman

I've edited in my scores for 'Fearless' and 'Speak Now'.

 

'Speak Now' really is incredible, isn't it? :cheeseblock:

Enchanted. :heart: