14 of you voted in round 1 and here are the results!

 

4 I Don't Wanna Live Forever vs Lights Up 10

5 Strip That Down vs Little Things 9

12 Sign of the Times vs History 2

2 For You vs Story of My Life 12

11 What Makes You Beautiful vs This Town 3

8 Watermelon Sugar vs Perfect 6

9 PILLOWTALK vs One Way or Another (Teenage Kicks) 5

9 Night Changes vs Best Song Ever 5

1 Gotta Be You vs One Thing 13

5 Just Hold On vs Dusk Till Dawn 9

9 Drag Me Down vs Slow Hands 5

6 Adore You vs Steal My Girl 8

5 Live While We're Young vs Kiss You 9

12 Back to You vs Wishing On a Star 2

 

But WAIT! 14 songs are through to round 2, but to make it easier in future rounds, the two closest losers have also been put through as wildcards. Congratulations to Perfect and Adore You that are also in the next round!

 

In the post below is a series of pairings between One Direction's top 10 hits, group and solo. Simply bold your favourite song from each pairing, and the pair with the most votes will go through to round 3. Each pairing has been randomised.

Watermelon Sugar vs PILLOWTALK

Dusk Till Dawn vs Night Changes

Drag Me Down vs Steal My Girl

Lights Up vs Story of My Life

Back to You vs Perfect

Sign of the Times vs Little Things

What Makes You Beautiful vs Adore You

One Thing vs Kiss You

Watermelon Sugar vs PILLOWTALK

Dusk Till Dawn vs Night Changes

Drag Me Down vs Steal My Girl

Lights Up vs Story of My Life

Back to You vs Perfect

Sign of the Times vs Little Things

What Makes You Beautiful vs Adore You

One Thing vs Kiss You

 

Considering the quality of the songs through, this ended up being not too difficult to decide! WMYB vs Adore You is definitely the hardest battle :drama: but even then my choice was clear!

Watermelon Sugar vs PILLOWTALK

Dusk Till Dawn vs Night Changes

Drag Me Down vs Steal My Girl

Lights Up vs Story of My Life

Back to You vs Perfect

Sign of the Times vs Little Things

What Makes You Beautiful vs Adore You

One Thing vs Kiss You

Watermelon Sugar vs PILLOWTALK

Dusk Till Dawn vs Night Changes

Drag Me Down vs Steal My Girl

Lights Up vs Story of My Life

Back to You vs Perfect

Sign of the Times vs Little Things

What Makes You Beautiful vs Adore You

One Thing vs Kiss You

Watermelon Sugar vs PILLOWTALK

Dusk Till Dawn vs Night Changes

Drag Me Down vs Steal My Girl

Lights Up vs Story of My Life

Back to You vs Perfect

Sign of the Times vs Little Things

What Makes You Beautiful vs Adore You

One Thing vs Kiss You

 

Everything on the right *_*

Yay for Watermelon Sugar and Perfect both surviving, definitely one of the toughest battles of the first round!

 

Watermelon Sugar vs PILLOWTALK

Dusk Till Dawn vs Night Changes

Drag Me Down vs Steal My Girl

Lights Up vs Story of My Life

Back to You vs Perfect

Sign of the Times vs Little Things

What Makes You Beautiful vs Adore You

One Thing vs Kiss You

 

Watermelon Sugar vs PILLOWTALK

Dusk Till Dawn vs Night Changes

Drag Me Down vs Steal My Girl

Lights Up vs Story of My Life

Back to You vs Perfect

Sign of the Times vs Little Things

What Makes You Beautiful vs Adore You

One Thing vs Kiss You

 

Everything on the right *_*

 

Except almost nothing about this is right! :nono:

Watermelon Sugar vs PILLOWTALK

Dusk Till Dawn vs Night Changes

Drag Me Down vs Steal My Girl

Lights Up vs Story of My Life

Back to You vs Perfect

Sign of the Times vs Little Things

What Makes You Beautiful vs Adore You

One Thing vs Kiss You

 

'Watermelon Sugar' and 'PILLOWTALK' are probably the two strongest solo 1D songs for me :drama: whereas 'Back To You' and 'Perfect' are my least favourites here :lol:

Watermelon Sugar vs PILLOWTALK

Dusk Till Dawn vs Night Changes

Drag Me Down vs Steal My Girl

Lights Up vs Story of My Life

Back to You vs Perfect

Sign of the Times vs Little Things

What Makes You Beautiful vs Adore You

One Thing vs Kiss You

Watermelon Sugar vs PILLOWTALK

Dusk Till Dawn vs Night Changes

Drag Me Down vs Steal My Girl

Lights Up vs Story of My Life

Back to You vs Perfect

Sign of the Times vs Little Things

What Makes You Beautiful vs Adore You

One Thing vs Kiss You

 

This is just making me realise how many bops they've put out collectively!

Watermelon Sugar vs PILLOWTALK

Dusk Till Dawn vs Night Changes

Drag Me Down vs Steal My Girl

Lights Up vs Story of My Life

Back to You vs Perfect

Sign of the Times vs Little Things

What Makes You Beautiful vs Adore You

One Thing vs Kiss You

Watermelon Sugar vs PILLOWTALK

Dusk Till Dawn vs Night Changes

Drag Me Down vs Steal My Girl

Lights Up vs Story of My Life

Back to You vs Perfect

Sign of the Times vs Little Things

What Makes You Beautiful vs Adore You

One Thing vs Kiss You

Watermelon Sugar vs PILLOWTALK

Dusk Till Dawn vs Night Changes

Drag Me Down vs Steal My Girl

Lights Up vs Story of My Life

Back to You vs Perfect

Sign of the Times vs Little Things

What Makes You Beautiful vs Adore You

One Thing vs Kiss You

 

Again, most of these were really easy choices for me!

Watermelon Sugar vs PILLOWTALK

Dusk Till Dawn vs Night Changes

Drag Me Down vs Steal My Girl

Lights Up vs Story of My Life

Back to You vs Perfect

Sign of the Times vs Little Things

What Makes You Beautiful vs Adore You

One Thing vs Kiss You

Watermelon Sugar vs PILLOWTALK

Dusk Till Dawn vs Night Changes

Drag Me Down vs Steal My Girl

Lights Up vs Story of My Life

Back to You vs Perfect

Sign of the Times vs Little Things

What Makes You Beautiful vs Adore You

One Thing vs Kiss You

the way so many songs I would've voted for in round 1 went out oops

 

Watermelon Sugar vs PILLOWTALK

Dusk Till Dawn vs Night Changes --> this is close

Drag Me Down vs Steal My Girl --> both are meh

Lights Up vs Story of My Life

Back to You vs Perfect

Sign of the Times vs Little Things --> little things deserved better

What Makes You Beautiful vs Adore You

One Thing vs Kiss You --> both are dreadful

Watermelon Sugar vs PILLOWTALK

Dusk Till Dawn vs Night Changes

Drag Me Down vs Steal My Girl

Lights Up vs Story of My Life

Back to You vs Perfect

Sign of the Times vs Little Things

What Makes You Beautiful vs Adore You

One Thing vs Kiss You

Watermelon Sugar vs PILLOWTALK

Dusk Till Dawn vs Night Changes

Drag Me Down vs Steal My Girl

Lights Up vs Story of My Life

Back to You vs Perfect

Sign of the Times vs Little Things

What Makes You Beautiful vs Adore You

One Thing vs Kiss You

 

 

Watermelon Sugar vs PILLOWTALK

Dusk Till Dawn vs Night Changes

Drag Me Down vs Steal My Girl

Lights Up vs Story of My Life

Back to You vs Perfect

Sign of the Times vs Little Things

What Makes You Beautiful vs Adore You

One Thing vs Kiss You

 

Watermelon Sugar vs PILLOWTALK

Dusk Till Dawn vs Night Changes

Drag Me Down vs Steal My Girl

Lights Up vs Story of My Life

Back to You vs Perfect

Sign of the Times vs Little Things

What Makes You Beautiful vs Adore You

One Thing vs Kiss You