The regular American seasons went down well, so I'm doing one for the All-Stars seasons. Note on this one I've decided to include a 3rd option on each lipsync for both. as with one or two of these ones you really can't choose between the 2 Queens.

There have been to this current date 6 All-Stars seasons with 9 Double Shantays, but who you guys think really won or did they both deserve the win?

Jujubee vs Raven - Dancing On My Own (All-Stars 1)
Alyssa Edwards vs Tatianna - Shut Up And Drive (All-Stars 2)
BenDelaCreme vs Shangela - I Kissed A Girl (All-Stars 3)
Manilla Luzon vs Monet X Change - Jump To It (All-Stars 4)
Latrice Royale vs Monique Heart - Sissy That Walk (All-Stars 4)
Monet X Change vs Trinity The Tuck - Fighter (All-Stars 4)
Miz Cracker vs Morgan McMichaels - Where Have You Been (All-Stars 5)
Brooke Lynn Hytes vs Ra'Jah O'Hara - Miss You Much (All-Stars 6)
Eureka vs Jaida Essence Hall - Good Golly Miss Molly (All-Stars 6)

I forgot Miz Cracker got a double shantay for Where Have You Been- how random. Morgan wiped the floor with her

I heard a rumour that they stopped and refilmed Morgan vs Cracker because Morgan was doing too well the first time!

I think more of these are "actual" worthy double shantays than the normal series! Not much riggory or random shit going on:

 

Jujubee vs Raven - Dancing On My Own (All-Stars 1) I'd say Juju won really but they actually both said they'd give up their spot to the other, Juju did try but Raven basically threw it for Juju, and I feel like it was symbolic for them both to survive this with that, in a season about teams with a friendship like that.

 

 

Alyssa Edwards vs Tatianna - Shut Up And Drive (All-Stars 2) - I feel like you couldn't not have this as a double shantay

 

BenDelaCreme vs Shangela - I Kissed A Girl (All-Stars 3) - but Shangela shouldn't have even been in this top 2 over Aja :whistle:

 

Manilla Luzon vs Monet X Change - Jump To It (All-Stars 4)

Latrice Royale vs Monique Heart - Sissy That Walk (All-Stars 4)

 

Monet X Change vs Trinity The Tuck - Fighter (All-Stars 4) - Monet absolutely DEMOLISHED Trinity here and that's why the double win feels so unnecessary

 

Miz Cracker vs Morgan McMichaels - Where Have You Been (All-Stars 5)

Brooke Lynn Hytes vs Ra'Jah O'Hara - Miss You Much (All-Stars 6) - I'd edge it to Ra'Jah but I get why it was a double win

 

Eureka vs Jaida Essence Hall - Good Golly Miss Molly (All-Stars 6) - Eureka defintiely hold her own, but Jaida is just such a flawless performer

 

I heard a rumour that they stopped and refilmed Morgan vs Cracker because Morgan was doing too well the first time!

Yep, apparently they wanted the girls to win more as it was week 4 and only Shea had won to Neutron Dance :lol:

i put both for manila vs. monet, but what i really meant was neither

omg i LOVE the jump to it lip sync!

 

so underrated (although, i guess not in terms of the double shantay - but i feel like that decision was made purely so that the numbers were even for the lalaparuza).

This is how I'd rank them:

1. Alyssa Edwards vs Tatianna – Shut Up and Drive
2. Brooke Lynn Hytes vs Ra’Jah O’Hara – Miss You Much
3. Manilla Luzon vs Monet X Change – Jump to It
4. Miz Cracker vs Morgan McMichaels – Where Have You Been
5. BenDeLaCreme vs Shangela – I Kissed a Girl
6. Latrice Royale vs Monique Heart – Sissy That Walk
7. Eureka vs Jaida Essence Hall – Good Golly Miss Molly
8. Jujubee vs Raven – Dancing on My Own
9. Monet X Change vs Trinity the Tuck - Fighter

Edited April 2, 20223 yr by Nina West