Welcome to a new series of polls, pitting Harry's solo music against the 1D group singles! Poll 1 will focus on their respective first single, before poll 2 focuses on single 2, etc. At the end I'll total up who's won the most polls! Vote for your favourite in the poll above and tell us below what you've voted for.

 

Round 1: Sign of the Times (12) vs What Makes You Beautiful (10)

 

Harry: Two Ghosts

 

 

One Direction: Gotta Be You

 

Interesting that the 2nd single wasn't a memorable moment on either attempt for Harry...! Two Ghosts is the one I'd choose to listen to now, it's underrated even if not one of my fave Harry singles.

I'm not familar with Two Ghosts so had a listen and was about to choose it, and then I listened to Gotta Be You and it was just a bit more catchy.

 

Gotta Be You was a terrible follow-up to What Makes... for 1D... and some of the lyrics are really odd.

Not really keen on either of those but 'Gotta Be You' is slightly better so voted for that.

'Two Ghosts' but even that's like a 3 at best.

Two Ghosts for me! A beautiful song

Two ghosts it's a lovely song.

 

Gotta be you is possibly the worst One Direction single it's terrible.

'Two Ghosts', which isn't a major Harry highlight or anything, but is much preferable to the alternative here!

Not a huge fan of either songs but slightly prefer two ghosts.

Two Ghosts.