Lets do a quick poll about the Vault tracks!

 

Which ones are your favourites?

Which "Taylor's Version" currently has the best overall selection?

How many do you actually like?

Which rounds were toughest/easiest??

 

Whatever else you want to discuss!

 

ROUND 01:

You All Over Me (feat. Maren Morris) vs Nothing New (feat. Phoebe Bridgers) vs Electric Touch (feat. Fall Out Boy)

 

ROUND 02:

Mr. Perfectly Fine vs Message In A Bottle vs When Emma Falls In Love

 

ROUND 03:

We Were Happy vs I Bet You Think About Me (feat. Chris Stapleton) vs I Can See You

 

ROUND 04:

That's When (feat. Keith Urban) vs Forever Winter vs Castle's Crumbling (feat. Hayley Williams)

 

ROUND 05:

Don't You vs Run (feat. Ed Sheeran) vs Foolish One

 

ROUND 06:

Bye Bye Baby vs The Very First Night vs Timeless

ROUND 01:

You All Over Me (feat. Maren Morris) vs Nothing New (feat. Phoebe Bridgers) vs Electric Touch (feat. Fall Out Boy)

 

> VERYYYYY nearly went for 'Nothing New', but I do love 'Electric Touch' and I actually think it's underrated! <

 

---

 

ROUND 02:

Mr. Perfectly Fine vs Message In A Bottle vs When Emma Falls In Love

 

> MPF vs MIAB is CRUEL! WEFIL is cute, but against these 2 which are top 3 with 'I Can See You' from her entire original Vault collections... but MIAB is just such a bop that SHOULD have been a single! <

 

---

 

ROUND 03:

We Were Happy vs I Bet You Think About Me (feat. Chris Stapleton) vs I Can See You

 

> Poor WWH & IBYTAM... don't stand a CHANCE against ICSY for me. What a song! <

 

---

 

ROUND 04:

That's When (feat. Keith Urban) vs Forever Winter vs Castle's Crumbling (feat. Hayley Williams)

 

> I don't really go back to any of these three and I think this is the weakest round. But TW gets my vote. They're all "fine" I just think she has better. <

 

---

 

ROUND 05:

Don't You vs Run (feat. Ed Sheeran) vs Foolish One

 

> I enjoy TFO a lot. I really like DY too and very nearly went for it. I can take or leave 'Run' but I think I slightly prefer it over their other collab from this album. <

 

---

 

ROUND 06:

Bye Bye Baby vs The Very First Night vs Timeless

 

> I really like all three of these! I thought I was going to be voting BBB... but then I just relistened to TVFN and forgot how much of a bop it actually is! <

 

 

FEARLESS (TAYLOR'S VERSION) (1); RED (TAYLOR'S VERSION) (2) vs SPEAK NOW (TAYLOR'S VERSION) (3)

 

I do think that's about fair tbh. I will rank soon, but as of right now SN is definitely my favourite Vault collection.

ROUND 01:

You All Over Me (feat. Maren Morris) vs Nothing New (feat. Phoebe Bridgers) vs Electric Touch (feat. Fall Out Boy)

 

>> You All Over Me is one of my least favourites on Fearless and Nothing New is cute but Electric Touch is SO good! In my top 3 in the entire album as of right now!

 

ROUND 02:

Mr. Perfectly Fine vs Message In A Bottle vs When Emma Falls In Love

 

>> All of these are really good, MPF vs MIAB was particularly hard MPF is a discography highlight of hers for me!!

 

ROUND 03:

We Were Happy vs I Bet You Think About Me (feat. Chris Stapleton) vs I Can See You

 

>> Probably the easiest choice here. ICSY is a BOP

 

ROUND 04:

That's When (feat. Keith Urban) vs Forever Winter vs Castle's Crumbling (feat. Hayley Williams)

 

>> Forever Winter vs Castles Crumbling was so hard for me but I think CC just about takes it!

 

ROUND 05:

Don't You vs Run (feat. Ed Sheeran) vs Foolish One

 

>> Weakest round here, I like Run but not huge on the other 2 at all

 

ROUND 06:

Bye Bye Baby vs The Very First Night vs Timeless

 

>> Timeless is stunning and I almost chose it but The Very First Night is just such a bop!

 

 

So 1 for Fearless, 2 for Red and 3 for SN for me as well! That's definitely how I'd rank them I think, Red & SN are close but Fearless is a little way behind for me.

ROUND 01:

You All Over Me (feat. Maren Morris) vs Nothing New (feat. Phoebe Bridgers) vs Electric Touch (feat. Fall Out Boy) - Easy because I love Nothing New.

 

ROUND 02:

Mr. Perfectly Fine vs Message In A Bottle vs When Emma Falls In Love - A bit hard because I also love WEFIL...the piano. :heart:

 

ROUND 03:

We Were Happy vs I Bet You Think About Me (feat. Chris Stapleton) vs I Can See You - Easy one, I don't care for the other two.

 

ROUND 04:

That's When (feat. Keith Urban) vs Forever Winter vs Castles Crumbling (feat. Hayley Williams) - Love Castles Crumbling, so very easy.

 

ROUND 05:

Don't You vs Run (feat. Ed Sheeran) vs Foolish One - A default choice, not fond of these.

 

ROUND 06:

Bye Bye Baby vs The Very First Night vs Timeless - Timeless, it's beautiful.

 

 

Vault track rankings:

1. Speak Now

2. Red

3. Fearless

ROUND 01:

Nothing New (feat. Phoebe Bridgers)

 

ROUND 02:

Message In A Bottle (that was a tough one)

 

ROUND 03:

I Can See You

 

ROUND 04:

Castle's Crumbling (feat. Hayley Williams)

 

ROUND 05:

Don't You

 

ROUND 06:

Timeless

 

Speak now - 3

Red - 2

Fearless - 1

 

I might listen to them all again and rank them from fav to least for all

 

Round 1

Nothing new

 

Round 2

Mr perfectly fine

 

Round 3

I can see you

 

Round 4

Castles crumbling

 

Round 5

Run

 

Round 6

The very first night

 

Mr perfectly fine, I can see you , the very first night my favourite 3 vault tracks overall

speak now vault is so funny to me because it houses both a top 5 in taylors discography song with (i can see you) and a bottom 5 of tays discography with (electric touch). red vault is still the strongest imo as the only vault songs from it i skip are better man and run, the rest are all stunners. speak now has to be middle of the road because of electric touch (one of the worst songs shes ever done imo. i can only listen to verse 1 and chorus 1, as soon as fall out boy jpins in singing i cant continue he ruins it completely for me) and fearless vault is too many fillers. i only really listen to mr perfectly fine from it

The way I'm tempted to just close this thread now that we have 13 votes

Sorry to ruin the lucky 13 x

ROUND 01:

Nothing New (feat. Phoebe Bridgers)

 

ROUND 02:

Mr. Perfectly Fine

 

ROUND 03:

I Can See You

 

ROUND 04:

Castles Crumbling (feat. Hayley Williams)

 

ROUND 05:

Run (feat. Ed Sheeran) (really not big on any of these 3, in time Foolish One will probably take over for me)

 

ROUND 06:

The Very First Night (super close with this and Timeless!)

 

Fearless: 1

Red: 3

Speak Now: 2

Red definitely has the strongest vault so far for me, but Speak Now is growing on me!