Welcome to the S Club ultimate rate! Over the next month, you have a chance to revisit and score every S Club song out of 10 in a mission to find out a full ranking of BuzzJack's favourite S Club songs. Every Sunday at 7:30pm, starting TOMORROW (28th April), we'll be hosting listening parties for each album + era. Please feel free to join if you think you need a refresher of each song!

 

28th April, 7:30pm - S Club (+ b-sides)

5th May, 7:30pm - '7' (+ b-sides)

12th May, 7:30pm - Sunshine (+ b-sides)

19th May, 7:30pm - Seeing Double (+ b-side)

26th May, 7:30pm - Best (+ b-side) and other S Club songs

 

Rules

 

- Score every song on the list from 0 to 10. Please try not to leave any unrated - join the listening parties or utilise streaming services/YouTube for those you don't know!

- You are allowed three scores of 11 across the entire rate. No -1s please!

- Half marks are allowed (but obviously no 10.5).

- You do not have to submit your rate in one go. If you want to submit a partial rate after each listening party, or prefer instalments regardless, that is completely fine!

- You may edit your rate before the deadline, but please post to say what's changed because I may have already inputted your rate into my spreadsheet.

 

The deadline is quite far away - end of the day on Tuesday 28th May 2024 - but this is after all of the listening parties have occurred. Results will occur that week, while I'm off work.

 

The Songs

 

S Club

xx.x Bring It All Back

xx.x You're My Number One

xx.x Two in a Million

xx.x S Club Party

xx.x Everybody Wants Ya

xx.x Viva La Fiesta

xx.x Gonna Change the World

xx.x I Really Miss You

xx.x Friday Night

xx.x It's a Feel Good Thing

xx.x Hope for the Future

 

xx.x So Right

xx.x Hello Friend

xx.x Our Time Has Come

xx.x We Can Work It Out

xx.x Down At Club S

 

'7'

xx.x Reach

xx.x Natural

xx.x I'll Keep Waiting

xx.x Bring the House Down

xx.x Best Friend

xx.x All in Love Is Fair

xx.x Love Train

xx.x Cross My Heart

xx.x The Colour of Blue

xx.x I'll Be There

xx.x Stand By You

xx.x Spiritual Love

xx.x Lately

xx.x Never Had a Dream Come True

 

xx.x Someday, Someway

xx.x If It's Love

xx.x Perfect Christmas

 

Sunshine

xx.x Don't Stop Movin'

xx.x Show Me Your Colours

xx.x You

xx.x Have You Ever

xx.x Good Times

xx.x Boy Like You

xx.x Sunshine

xx.x Dance Dance Dance

xx.x It's Alright

xx.x Stronger

xx.x Right Guy

xx.x Summertime Feeling

xx.x I Will Find You

 

xx.x Dangerous

xx.x The Long & Winding Road

 

Seeing Double

xx.x Alive

xx.x Whole Lotta Nothin'

xx.x Love Ain't Gonna Wait for You

xx.x Bittersweet

xx.x Straight from the Heart

xx.x Gangsta Love

xx.x Who Do You Think You Are?

xx.x Do It Till We Drop

xx.x Hey Kitty Kitty

xx.x Dance

xx.x Secret Love

xx.x The Greatest

xx.x In Too Deep

xx.x Let Me Sleep

xx.x Every Kinda People

 

xx.x Discotek

 

Best + Rarities

xx.x Say Goodbye

xx.x Everybody Get Pumped

xx.x Rain

 

xx.x Special Kind of Something

 

xx.x Dancing Queen

xx.x The Two of Us

xx.x Anytime, Anywhere

xx.x Can You Feel the Love Tonight

xx.x Family

xx.x These Are the Days

xx.x Good Times (Bradley & Jon)

First part!

 

S Club

10.0 Bring It All Back

09.0 You're My Number One

09.5 Two in a Million

10.0 S Club Party

08.0 Everybody Wants Ya

09.0 Viva La Fiesta

07.0 Gonna Change the World

09.5 I Really Miss You

09.5 Friday Night

08.5 It's a Feel Good Thing

07.5 Hope for the Future

 

08.0 So Right

07.5 Hello Friend

10.0 Our Time Has Come

09.0 We Can Work It Out

08.0 Down At Club S

 

Got 2 songs in mind for an 11, am undecided on a third yet so gonna keep it safe...

S Club

09.5 Bring It All Back

08.5 You're My Number One

09.0 Two in a Million

10.0 S Club Party

07.5 Everybody Wants Ya

08.0 Viva La Fiesta

05.5 Gonna Change the World

08.5 I Really Miss You

08.0 Friday Night

07.0 It's a Feel Good Thing

07.0 Hope for the Future

 

07.0 So Right

07.0 Hello Friend

08.0 Our Time Has Come

06.5 We Can Work It Out

06.5 Down At Club S

 

Average score: 7.72

Done my rate along with the listen through. Not sure if I'll post it yet though as I'm still undecided on the 11's.

Same here!

I’m quite confident about where my 11s are going but #nospoilersplease x

S Club

09.0 Bring It All Back

08.5 You're My Number One

08.0 Two in a Million

08.5 S Club Party

08.0 Everybody Wants Ya

07.5 Viva La Fiesta

06.0 Gonna Change the World

08.5 I Really Miss You

07.0 Friday Night

08.0 It's a Feel Good Thing

07.0 Hope for the Future

 

 

'7'

07.5 Reach

06.5 Natural

07.0 I'll Keep Waiting

08.0 Bring the House Down

05.0 Best Friend

04.0 All in Love Is Fair

06.0 Love Train

07.0 Cross My Heart

07.0 The Colour of Blue

08.0 I'll Be There

05.5 Stand By You

05.5 Spiritual Love

04.0 Lately

07.5 Never Had a Dream Come True

 

 

Sunshine

11 Don't Stop Movin'

06.5 Show Me Your Colours

11 You

11 Have You Ever

07.0 Good Times

06.5 Boy Like You

06.0 Sunshine

06.0 Dance Dance Dance

04.0 It's Alright

06.5 Stronger

05.0 Right Guy

05.5 Summertime Feeling

03.5 I Will Find You

 

 

Seeing Double

06.0 Alive

06.5 Love Ain't Gonna Wait for You

06.0 Say Goodbye

 

S Club

9 Bring It All Back

9 You're My Number One

10 Two in a Million

9 S Club Party

8 Everybody Wants Ya

9 Viva La Fiesta

7 Gonna Change the World

7.5 I Really Miss You

6 Friday Night

11 It's a Feel Good Thing

5 Hope for the Future

 

xx.x So Right

xx.x Hello Friend

xx.x Our Time Has Come

xx.x We Can Work It Out

xx.x Down At Club S

 

'7'

9.5 Reach

10 Natural

9 I'll Keep Waiting

8.5 Bring the House Down

5 Best Friend

7 All in Love Is Fair

8 Love Train

6 Cross My Heart

8 The Colour of Blue

8.5 I'll Be There

10 Stand By You

xx.x Spiritual Love

xx.x Lately

11 Never Had a Dream Come True

 

xx.x Someday, Someway

xx.x If It's Love

xx.x Perfect Christmas

 

Sunshine

8 Don't Stop Movin'

xx.x Show Me Your Colours

9 You

10 Have You Ever

xx.x Good Times

xx.x Boy Like You

xx.x Sunshine

xx.x Dance Dance Dance

xx.x It's Alright

xx.x Stronger

xx.x Right Guy

xx.x Summertime Feeling

xx.x I Will Find You

 

xx.x Dangerous

xx.x The Long & Winding Road

 

Seeing Double

6.5 Alive

xx.x Whole Lotta Nothin'

9 Love Ain't Gonna Wait for You

xx.x Bittersweet

xx.x Straight from the Heart

xx.x Gangsta Love

xx.x Who Do You Think You Are?

xx.x Do It Till We Drop

xx.x Hey Kitty Kitty

xx.x Dance

xx.x Secret Love

xx.x The Greatest

xx.x In Too Deep

xx.x Let Me Sleep

xx.x Every Kinda People

 

xx.x Discotek

 

Best + Rarities

10 Say Goodbye

xx.x Everybody Get Pumped

xx.x Rain

 

xx.x Special Kind of Something

 

xx.x Dancing Queen

xx.x The Two of Us

xx.x Anytime, Anywhere

xx.x Can You Feel the Love Tonight

xx.x Family

xx.x These Are the Days

xx.x Good Times (Bradley & Jon)

 

I need to listen to some of the others so I can come back to it. If someone could DM remind me that would be super

Will do, thanks Jupiter!

PLEASE SEE NEW LISTENING PARTY TIMES!

 

Tuesday 14th May, 8:00pm - '7' (+ b-sides)

Thursday 16th May, 8:30pm - Sunshine (+ b-sides)

Sunday 19th May, 7:30pm - Seeing Double (+ b-side)

Sunday 26th May, 7:30pm - Best (+ b-side) and other S Club songs

 

Note the times for Tuesday and Thursday's parties as well. Sorry for the inconvenience about moving these around, but this should now work perfectly!!

'7'

10.0 Reach

09.5 Natural

08.0 I'll Keep Waiting

09.0 Bring the House Down

07.5 Best Friend

08.0 All in Love Is Fair

08.5 Love Train

07.0 Cross My Heart

07.0 The Colour of Blue

09.0 I'll Be There

11.0 Stand By You

07.0 Spiritual Love

06.0 Lately

10.0 Never Had a Dream Come True

 

08.5 Someday, Someway

06.0 If It's Love

09.0 Perfect Christmas

 

Stand By You getting an 11 feels like a slight curveball moment but honestly it's deserved x

'7'

10.0 Reach

11.0 Natural

07.5 I'll Keep Waiting

08.0 Bring the House Down

06.0 Best Friend

06.5 All in Love Is Fair

08.0 Love Train

07.0 Cross My Heart

06.0 The Colour of Blue

08.5 I'll Be There

08.0 Stand By You

07.0 Spiritual Love

03.5 Lately

10.0 Never Had a Dream Come True

 

05.5 Someday, Someway

05.0 If It's Love

09.0 Perfect Christmas

 

Average Score: 7.44

Interested to see where your 11's are allocated Joseph!

Sunshine

11.0 Don't Stop Movin'

10.0 Show Me Your Colours

08.5 You

11.0 Have You Ever

08.0 Good Times

06.5 Boy Like You

08.0 Sunshine

07.5 Dance Dance Dance

07.5 It's Alright

10.0 Stronger

06.5 Right Guy

07.5 Summertime Feeling

07.5 I Will Find You

 

08.0 Dangerous

05.0 The Long & Winding Road

 

Only the last cover letting the album down a bit - a nice rendition but I'm just not fond of the song really x

 

Average score: 8.17 - SMASH :cheeseblock:

Sunshine

11.0 Don't Stop Movin'

10.0 Show Me Your Colours

09.5 You

09.5 Have You Ever

08.5 Good Times

07.0 Boy Like You

08.5 Sunshine

09.0 Dance Dance Dance

08.0 It's Alright

10.0 Stronger

07.5 Right Guy

09.0 Summertime Feeling

07.0 I Will Find You

 

07.5 Dangerous

05.0 The Long & Winding Road

 

And this is me being harsh x

Seeing Double

09.5 Alive

08.0 Whole Lotta Nothin'

09.0 Love Ain't Gonna Wait for You

06.5 Bittersweet

09.0 Straight from the Heart

08.5 Gangsta Love

10.0 Who Do You Think You Are?

09.0 Do It Till We Drop

09.5 Hey Kitty Kitty

08.5 Dance

07.5 Secret Love

06.0 The Greatest

08.0 In Too Deep

11.0 Let Me Sleep

06.0 Every Kinda People

 

10.0 Discotek

Seeing Double

09.0 Alive

07.5 Whole Lotta Nothin'

09.0 Love Ain't Gonna Wait for You

05.0 Bittersweet

08.0 Straight from the Heart

08.0 Gangsta Love

08.0 Who Do You Think You Are?

08.0 Do It Till We Drop

07.0 Hey Kitty Kitty

08.0 Dance

07.0 Secret Love

05.0 The Greatest

07.0 In Too Deep

08.5 Let Me Sleep

05.0 Every Kinda People

 

08.5 Discotek

 

Average: 7.41

 

Seeing Double lacks the major highs that the first three albums all have, but it's got quite a lot of strong album tracks here! Only three songs letting it down a bit.

S Club
10.0 Bring It All Back
09.0 You're My Number One
10.0 Two in a Million
10.0 S Club Party
07.0 Everybody Wants Ya
08.0 Viva La Fiesta
06.0 Gonna Change the World
08.0 I Really Miss You
07.5 Friday Night
08.0 It's a Feel Good Thing
06.5 Hope for the Future

06.0 So Right
07.0 Hello Friend
06.5 Our Time Has Come
05.5 We Can Work It Out
06.0 Down At Club S

'7'
10.0 Reach
09.0 Natural
07.0 I'll Keep Waiting
10.0 Bring the House Down
06.0 Best Friend
05.0 All in Love Is Fair
09.0 Love Train
07.0 Cross My Heart
08.0 The Colour of Blue
08.0 I'll Be There
10.0 Stand By You
07.0 Spiritual Love
04.0 Lately
10.0 Never Had a Dream Come True

06.0 Someday, Someway
04.0 If It's Love
07.5 Perfect Christmas

Sunshine
11.0 Don't Stop Movin'
11.0 Show Me Your Colours
09.0 You
10.0 Have You Ever
08.0 Good Times
06.0 Boy Like You
08.5 Sunshine
07.0 Dance Dance Dance
07.5 It's Alright
10.0 Stronger
05.0 Right Guy
08.0 Summertime Feeling
07.0 I Will Find You

06.5 Dangerous
03.0 The Long & Winding Road

Seeing Double
09.0 Alive
08.0 Whole Lotta Nothin'
09.5 Love Ain't Gonna Wait for You
05.0 Bittersweet
08.0 Straight from the Heart
07.5 Gangsta Love
10.0 Who Do You Think You Are?
09.0 Do It Till We Drop
08.0 Hey Kitty Kitty
10.0 Dance
07.0 Secret Love
06.0 The Greatest
07.5 In Too Deep
11.0 Let Me Sleep
05.0 Every Kinda People

10.0 Discotek

Best + Rarities
08.0 Say Goodbye
05.0 Everybody Get Pumped
08.5 Rain
06.0 Special Kind of Something

I'm unfortunately not going to be able to make Sunday sorry! I have Girls Aloud tomorrow night and Nicki Minaj on Sunday!

S Club

10 Bring It All Back

11 You're My Number One

9.5 Two in a Million

10 S Club Party

9 Everybody Wants Ya

8.5 Viva La Fiesta

8.5 Gonna Change the World

9.5 I Really Miss You

8 Friday Night

8.5 It's a Feel Good Thing

8 Hope for the Future

 

8 So Right

7.5 Hello Friend

8.5 Our Time Has Come

8.5 We Can Work It Out

10 Down At Club S

'7'

10 Reach

8 Natural

8.5 I'll Keep Waiting

9 Bring the House Down

7 Best Friend

8.5 All in Love Is Fair

8 Love Train

8.5 Cross My Heart

9 The Colour of Blue

8.5 I'll Be There

10 Stand By You

6.5 Spiritual Love

4 Lately

10 Never Had a Dream Come True

 

8.5 Someday, Someway

4.5 If It's Love

10 Perfect Christmas

Sunshine

11 Don't Stop Movin'

10 Show Me Your Colours

8 You

10 Have You Ever

7.5 Good Times

7 Boy Like You

7.5 Sunshine

8.5 Dance Dance Dance

8 It's Alright

8.5 Stronger

7.5 Right Guy

7.5 Summertime Feeling

7 I Will Find You

 

9.5 Dangerous

3 The Long & Winding Road

 

Seeing Double

9 Alive

9 Whole Lotta Nothin'

8 Love Ain't Gonna Wait for You

8.5 Bittersweet

7.5 Straight from the Heart

8 Gangsta Love

8 Who Do You Think You Are?

6 Do It Till We Drop

10 Hey Kitty Kitty

8 Dance

8 Secret Love

6 The Greatest

8.5 In Too Deep

11 Let Me Sleep

5 Every Kinda People

 

9 Discotek

 

Best + Rarities

8.5 Say Goodbye

6.5 Everybody Get Pumped

8 Rain

 

5 Special Kind of Something

 

4 Dancing Queen

5.5 The Two of Us

6 Anytime, Anywhere

4 Can You Feel the Love Tonight

4 Family

6.5 These Are the Days

7 Good Times (Bradley & Jon)