Well bang me backwards, Rachel was excellent! Amazing in fact. Wonderful vocal, just enough of her own pizazz to really pull it off. Kept the interest all the way through too with decent stage direction. Yay! 10/10

 

JLS did a great performance too but a bit starz in their eyes and they think they've won it :rolleyes:

Why oh why when a Beatles medley is put together do they always choose the same bloody songs? JLS were awful .... how the hell Cheryl can say they did it as good as Take That I do not know (and I don't even like Take That's Beatles medley - glad they've dropped the bloody thing).

 

Rachel was brilliant!

 

So far for me:

 

Daniel 7/10

Alexandra 8/10

JSL 4/10

Rachel 10/10

 

Norma

Daniel

Not bad, but just nowhere near the standard that contestants at this stage should be. There's not much more to say really.

5/10

 

Alexandra

Vocally flawless, if perhaps a little unexciting.

9/10

 

JLS

It's becoming increasingly evident that they are much better entertainers than singers. But they have a huge likability factor, which saved this performance from being off. I enjoyed the Hey Jude at the end.

6/10

 

Rachel

Well she was NEVER going to fail with this track, such an obvious choice. By far her best and most comfortable performance so far. Simon was quite right, that IS Rachel's natural voice and was not put on., but I wouldn't go as far as to say she "put her own stamp" on it as Dannii claimed. It would be IMPOSSIBLE for her to do that because her voice is so naturally similar to Winehouse's on that track, there was no way Rachel would be able to do anything but an identikit copy.

9/10

Alexandra was amazing again this week :wub:

 

She just has to win!

Owens song is BORING!!!!!!!!

JLS did a great performance too but a bit starz in their eyes and they think they've won it :rolleyes:

 

They kind of obviously really don't....

 

 

Eoghan's FIT. Don't care about everyone on here saying he looks like a child lol.

Ouch @some of his notes though, still good though!

eeugh Eggnong/ Ewok/ Eoughan .?

 

seriously i want to hit him. i have no idea who dressed him, a blind person?

 

what is this song? it is really dull?

Ughan very boring, does nothing for me, I wish it be goodbye tonight 1/10, I don't see the appeal with this kid.

Eoghan really gets on my f***ing t*ts. I just want to rip his face off :mellow: It's so f***ing annoying!

Eggnog; After last weeks surprisingly good performance, this was pretty weak. His voice didn't really inflate enough for the track. And it was also, pretty boring. 4/10

Oh dear - painful! Daniel can take comfort in that so far two acts are worse than him tonight ... JLS AND Orville!

 

Daniel 7/10

Alexandra 8/10

JSL 4/10

Rachel 10/10

Orville 3/10

 

Norma

Eoghan

Just DULL. No doubt he'll walk it, but I WISH one of the judges would have the balls to point out that he's not the best singer there. If he wins this year, that's it. No more X Factor for me.

4/10

05: Eoughan Quigg - One More Try Well... time for Eggnog. I must say, I am SURPRISED :o Truly :o It suited him down to the ground. His voice suited this song soo much. His best performance, vocally, in the whole damn show! :o 8/10

Edited November 15, 200816 yr by Johnjo07

My mum just fell asleep wating Eggnog's performance! Myself, I didn't think it was that bad... But not as good as last week.

 

He will never be bottom 2 though.

f***ing hell, do they need to milk Diana's ''illness'' so much? :/

Eoghan (aka Eggnog/Orville/Ewok) - One More Try - What does it matter that week in week out this I'd Do Anything Oliver reject sings bums notes, in an over emotive Gareth Gates/Westlife manner. He is going to win this year's competition isn't he even with performances likes this which are more Shoot The Dog than Careless Whisper. 4/10

Talk about milking her illness... :o

Yay Diana time!!!

Eoghan did awful. Some alright vocals but mostly off, and that 'yoou!!' vote was SO nasty. 4

 

Diana's speaking voice, as an aside, is horrifically patronising. Emphasis on everything. I really WANT to SHOW people I can DO this. Ergh!